For longtime parishioners, the announced closing of the St. Peter Catholic Church building on the South Side came as a deep disappointment, but not a surprise.
With declining Roman Catholic numbers in the neighborhood and increasing costs to maintain their building on South 28th Street, they’re not surprised that their parish, Prince of Peace, decided to consolidate worship at nearby St. Adalbert. The latter is the last of what were once seven thriving parish churches on the South Side, dating from when legions of Catholic immigrants worked at nearby steel mills.
“Heartbreaking,” said Leona Rogowski, who lives on the South Side, as she left the 11 a.m. Mass on Sunday at St. Peter. “This is the second one we’ve belonged to ... that’s closing. It’s within walking distance of my home. It’s hard on Catholics today.”
The closing, to take effect after a final service on Jan. 12, is one of numerous sanctuary closings during a current wave of parish consolidations in the Diocese of Pittsburgh in the program called On Mission for the Church Alive.
St. Peter is part of Prince of Peace Parish. Only St. Adalbert, on South 15th Street, will remain open from the seven parishes that merged in the 1990s to create Prince of Peace.
The parish received Bishop David Zubik’s permission to close the St. Peter building, citing the growing costs of maintaining the building. The diocese announced the closing this weekend.
“It was in the works,” Ms. Rogowski said. “The date we didn’t know.”
She and her brother, Dan Potanko, will now look for new church homes. They had grown up in nearby St. Matthew, one of the other now-closed parishes that merged into Prince of Peace.
After the closure of St. Peter, the sacred objects will be removed from the sanctuary. The building will be sold for a use that the church considers in harmony with its original purpose. The church’s former school building, located across the street, was sold years ago and renovated into apartments.
The Rev. Michael Stumpf, the pastor-administrator of the parish grouping that includes Prince of Peace and St. Mary of the Mount, sought to offer “words of encouragement, words of hopefully accompanying one another in the transition.”
He said it’s painful but necessary to close the church.
Historic religious groups, not just Catholic, often find themselves struggling to cope with changing communities, in this case the post-steel South Side.
“When things started changing demographically, the culture started shifting underneath us,” Father Stumpf said.
Many congregations aged, without a replenishing of younger members.
“Resources were more scarce, and then those resources end up being put toward maintenance — maintenance of buildings, maintenance of the status quo,” he said.
In his homily, Father Stumpf said he sought to put the closing in the context of the liturgical season of Advent, which aims to “call us to the core of our being, who we are as a people.”
St. Peter typically draws about 150 people to a Sunday Mass, he said.
Among those attending Sunday was a small group of younger adults who normally attend St. Mary of the Mount. They wanted to show support to St. Peter’s parishioners on a difficult day.
“I could empathize with what it would feel like to have the place where you had all of your sacraments for generations” close down, Vanya Britto said.
St. Peter began as a parish in the 1870s. Its original, ornate sanctuary burned in the 1950s. The current building, built with red-brick walls and structural steel believed to have been provided by nearby Jones and Laughlin Steel Co., opened in 1953.
Andrew Zenchak, who grew up serving as an altar boy at St. Peter and is now an usher and lector, recalls attending school at St. Peter and going to the crowded parish street festivals. He still hopes for the church to remain open.
“It’s part of your heritage,” he said. “You grew up here, you went to weekly Mass. It’s very, very sad.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.