The former spiritual leader of West Virginia’s Catholics must make restitution for nearly $800,000 for misspent funds and must apologize to those he targeted for sexual harassment and workplace intimidation, his successor announced Tuesday.

Retired Bishop Michael Bransfield must also apologize to his former flock of West Virginia Catholics for the damage he caused to them and the local church’s reputation through the scandals that broke into public view upon his abrupt resignation in September 2018.

Pope Francis had already imposed a series of sanctions on Bishop Bransfield in the wake of a church investigative task force’s report on his conduct over 13 years in office.

Those sanctions included prohibitions on presiding at Mass publicly or residing in West Virginia, where he had planned to retire. The pope left it up to his successor to determine how he would make restitution.

Advertise with us

That successor, Bishop Mark Brennan, who was installed in August, announced the plan Tuesday.

Bishop Brennan said his office conducted its own review of his predecessor’s spending and concluded that Bishop Bransfield spent $441,492 in diocesan funds on travel, vacations, clothing, alcohol and other personal expenses not related to his official duties.

It further determined that Bishop Bransfield spent another $351,146 “attributable to the former bishop’s luxurious lifestyle.”

Added together, Bishop Brennan is requiring Bishop Bransfield to make restitution for $792,638. Bishop Brennan believes his predecessor has the means to repay that amount, his spokesman said.

In a written statement, Bishop Brennan acknowledged “there is a deep and abiding sense of betrayal resulting from the former bishop’s actions” among clergy, staff and Catholics throughout the Wheeling-Charleston diocese, which covers the entire state.

Advertise with us

He said at a news conference he believes the acts of restitution are for Bishop Bransfield’s own “spiritual welfare” and will also “satisfy the righteous indignation of the Catholic faithful,” enabling them to move on from the scandal.

The plan requires Bishop Bransfield to make “apologies to the people the former bishop sexually harassed and for the severe emotional and spiritual harm his actions caused them” and an “apology to diocesan employees who suffered from a culture of intimidation and retribution which the former bishop created.”

And Bishop Bransfield must apologize “for the grievous harm he caused to the faithful of the diocese and the reputation of the Catholic Church here in West Virginia,” his successor added.

Bishop Bransfield will also have to return, or pay fair-market value for, the car he received upon his 2018 retirement. He will receive only a basic level of living expenses and medical benefits. And his ban on re-entering the state will extend beyond his lifetime, as he will not be allowed to be buried there.

Bishop Brennan said he took the actions “not as punishment but as acts of restorative justice to individuals and to the faithful of this diocese. This is a moral and spiritual matter, not primarily a legal one.”

Advertise with us

Bishop Bransfield resigned as required upon his 75th birthday under church law in September 2018.

But it was unusual that the pope accepted the resignation so quickly, within days and without a successor in place. But the following months brought revelations that the former bishop sexually harassed young priests and spent lavishly on luxuries and on gifts to fellow clerics he hoped to influence.

A diocesan commission found Bishop Bransfield had spent excessively on his residence, tapping oil royalties that had been given to the diocese.

Bishop Brennan said Tuesday he offered his predecessor the chance to craft his own restitution plan, but “he really hasn’t come up with a plan on his own, so I created one.”