The singers’ harmonies wove through the pulsing electric accompaniment of the worship band as close to a hundred worshipers stood in front of their rows of seats and sang along to lyrics on the video screens.
“Welcome to Orchard Hill — Strip District,” said the worship leader between songs, describing the urban expansion of the evangelical church, which has its much larger Wexford Campus in Franklin Park and a third in Butler County. “We are a multi-site church with a mission of becoming a diverse expression of the gospel of Christ here in Pittsburgh.”
The relaxed, contemporary scene last Sunday was a far cry from what these walls witnessed in generations past, when Slovak worshipers knelt as priests said Mass at an altar in front, in the now-open space where the band played.
But it was an even farther cry from what was in between.
After the Roman Catholic Diocese of Pittsburgh closed St. Elizabeth Church on Penn Avenue in 1993 amid a major parish consolidation, the relatively small sanctuary was sold and converted to use as a nightclub, most recently known as the Altar Bar, featuring entertainers like Snoop Dogg and Twenty One Pilots.
After more than two years of renovation work, the building reopened as the Orchard Hill campus in May.

In an era when many urban churches are going silent due to membership decline and population shifts, the Strip District property offers an unusual case in which a former sanctuary reverts to becoming one again, in a new form.
Many urban planners lament the demise of old sanctuaries because they have served not just as spiritual homes but as gathering points for their wider communities, with their upward-pointing spires serving to elevate the spirits of even a casual viewer. And many more sanctuaries are likely to go vacant in the coming years as the Catholic diocese carries through on a new round of parish consolidations.
“Here's our hope for this space,” said Joel Haldeman, campus pastor for Orchard Hil-Strip District. “We don't want this to be one of those churches that’s open on Sundays, and closed on the weekdays.” He spoke of everything from members already befriending the local needy to the idea of opening the building’s children’s rooms during the week, not as a drop-off child-care center but as a place where parents and kids could play and relax together.
That’s one vision for a closed church.
A different vision
Another is shaping up in East Liberty with the vast, vacant sanctuary of the former SS. Peter and Paul Catholic Church, which also closed in the 1990s and was sold to a non-denominational church that could not sustain it.
Now it’s under the conservatorship of East Liberty Development Inc., which stabilized the building and is working to find a new use beneath its soaring spires and Gothic arches. The group has methodically been conducting tours and hearings, gleaning public input for its uses.
Lending its expertise was the Philadelphia-based Partners for Sacred Space, a national non-profit that advises on ways that struggling churches can keep their doors open through such things as sharing space with community groups — and if the churches can’t stay open, how neighbors can keep them going as centers for community life.
“The key piece here for us is that we wanted to learn the process,” said Matthew Craig, president of the Young Preservationists Association of Pittsburgh, which also has been involved. “There’s going to be such a need for that [redevelopment] with all these other churches coming into the real estate market over the next several years.”
That’s on top of a current crop of vacant houses of worship that remain in the City of Pittsburgh itself and in surrounding suburbs, as The Post-Gazette described in its 2016 series, “Silent Sanctuaries.”
A widely admired model for church reuse is the Union Project in Highland Park, a former Presbyterian sanctuary that is now home to a non-profit with a strong ceramics program and a mission of using “the arts to bridge gaps between communities.”
But Mr. Craig cautioned against everyone using the same model, such as trying to “make another Union Project here in East Liberty.” That would set up two competing non-profit organizations.
“People will say, ‘We’ve got this empty church, what do we do with it?’ ” he said. “It’s a process, because there are 100 answers, and none of them are wrong, but how can this building continue to serve the community’s needs?”
That’s what they’re exploring in the Strip District now. Orchard Hill started the urban campus in 2013, and it led a migratory existence until now, worshiping at the Omni William Penn, the August Wilson Center and elsewhere before acquiring its permanent location.
“You don’t have to tear everything down every week and move it” as they did in rented space, said member Chuck Colbert. “The building’s available all the time.”
It took a while to get that building in shape, however. Orchard Hill purchased the church building in 2016 for $800,000, but there were renovations to do.
Workers had to replace much of the roof, including removing a former cupola in the center. They did save some of the stained glass windows, but the sanctuary is largely unadorned, marked by clean, simple lines and natural light through clear-glass windows. A wraparound upstairs balcony, remaining from the Altar Bar days, is set up for socializing and overflow seating.
Pastor Haldeman and others hope the church becomes a fixture amid the growing residential population of the Strip District, which is seeing new housing development.
“I love the small venue,” said Paula Petruska of Ross. “I think the space is gorgeous. I’m hoping get more people from the city.”
The Rev. Nicholas Vaskov, who now oversees the neighboring St. Stanislaus Kostka and St. Patrick churches as director of what’s now called the Shrines of Pittsburgh, said he’s glad to see the Penn Avenue building back in use as a church.
“The Strip District does not have many other churches” compared with other neighborhoods, he said. “We hope to be good neighbors and see if there are ways we can work together.”
What’s next?
It’s too soon to predict which Catholic sanctuaries may be closed in the coming years, said the Rev. Tom Kunz, vicar for canonical services for the diocese. Decisions about closures are recommended by the parish before being approved by the bishop, he said.
Decommissioning a sanctuary involves removing sacred items and other steps, and parish leaders are expected to work with real-estate professionals to find responsible buyers who, among other things, have the resources to maintain the buildings.
“Unfortunately, after the initial sale, buildings are sometimes re-sold to other parties who are not respectful of that heritage or who do not have a viable financial plan to operate or maintain the structures,” he said in a statement. “Such re-sale is beyond our control.”
There are limits to how the diocese wants an old church to be repurposed. Deed restrictions for sales of former Catholic sanctuaries nowadays typically forbid one from being used, for example, as an adult-entertainment site.
“We believe a church building maintains a sacred character because it was consecrated to God and sacred events occurred there,” Father Kunz said. “Therefore, we place certain deed restrictions on the sale of a church building to ensure that its future use does not violate our beliefs.”
Peter Smith: petersmith@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1416; Twitter @PG_PeterSmith.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.