VATICAN CITY — The lone U.S. bishop scheduled to address Pope Francis’ global summit on clergy sex abuse on Friday called for members of the Roman Catholic hierarchy to police each other’s behavior and offered the most concrete proposal yet for dealing with prelates who mishandle abuse allegations against priests or face claims of sexual misconduct themselves.
In his speech on the conference’s second day, Cardinal Blase Cupich of Chicago urged his colleagues to empower him and other metropolitan archbishops to investigate their colleagues in neighboring dioceses. Another authority would be appointed to do so in cases in which the archbishop himself was accused.
The recommendation stands at odds with an alternative proposition, floated last fall by bishops in the U.S., to let a board led by Catholic laity investigate allegations against prelates.
“This past year has taught us that the systematic failures in holding clerics of all rank responsible are due in large measure to flaws in the way we interact and communicate with each other in the college of bishops,” Cardinal Cupich said. “But they also reveal in too many cases an inadequate understanding [of] the relationship between the pope and the bishops, bishops among themselves … and the role of bishops’ conferences.”
Cardinal Cupich had proposed a similar suggestion at a meeting of U.S. bishops in November, when it became clear that the Vatican and many of his colleagues were uncomfortable with the idea of investigations led by civilians outside the church’s traditional leadership structure.
By endorsing it again Friday from a Vatican pulpit — and before an audience of more than 190 bishops and religious superiors from around the world — Cardinal Cupich helped propel to the forefront his solution to the most acute problem currently vexing the hierarchy in the U.S.
Read More
In the last year, nearly all of the scandals that have erupted in the American church — from the allegations against now-defrocked former Cardinal Theodore McCarrick to the Pennsylvania grand jury report that implicated the state’s bishops in decades of systematic cover-up — have been focused less on individual abusers than on the church leaders who enabled them by turning a blind eye.
Mr. McCarrick’s alleged abuse of seminarians and minors, for instance, is said to have been an open secret for years in some corners of the hierarchy before news emerged last summer that two of the four dioceses he led in his career had secretly paid settlements to his victims, leading to his suspension and ultimate laicization this month.
Like other bishops, he operated with relative impunity, answering only to the pope. They have been historically hesitant to take on the responsibility of policing each other’s conduct.
The plan the cardinal described Friday would grant new authority to metropolitan archbishops — a title given to those prelates tasked with both leading an archdiocese and supervising bishops in nearby dioceses.
It remained unclear Friday whether Cardinal Cupich’s ideas had gained traction — either with his audience, which remained behind closed doors as it has throughout the summit, or the abuse victims who have camped outside in St. Peter’s Square all week.
Survivors of sexual abuse by Pennsylvania clergy are in Rome and spent Friday mainly waiting to see what actions the bishops take.
“I’m sensing a change in their language” for the better, said James Faluszczak of Buffalo, N.Y., a former priest who was abused as a minor by a priest in the Erie Diocese. But he and Jim VanSickle of Coraopolis, who was abused by another Erie priest as a teen, said they wanted to see more details on how bishops will put that talk into action, such as how bishops would hold one another accountable.
Many of the victims pointed out that Mr. McCarrick himself was the metropolitan archbishop of Washington when his accusers came forward. They questioned how this system would work with a prelate with his own problems at the helm and insisted that after years of cover-up the time for allowing the bishops to police each other was over.
Post-Gazette religion editor Peter Smith contributed.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.