Leaders of the United Methodist Church are gathering in St. Louis beginning Saturday for a four-day conference that could amount to a showdown over a decades-long debate on whether one of the nation’s largest Protestant bodies should ordain and marry gay persons.
But if the only outcome is that one side or another wins, then everyone loses, said Pittsburgh Area Bishop Cynthia Moore-Koikoi. She’s hoping for something more akin to a revival meeting than a legislative session.
“I know there are some folks that are very concerned about the outcome, what the vote will be,” Bishop Moore-Koikoi said in a phone interview before leaving for St. Louis. She oversees the Western Pennsylvania Conference of the denomination, one of the largest Protestant bodies in the region and the nation.
“But my contention is if we don’t feel the presence of God, it doesn’t matter what the vote will be,” she said. “We will continue to have strife and confusion unless we are sure we have responded to God’s will. My hope is we will feel God’s presence has overwhelmed us and that we will engage in holy conferencing as a result.”
The gathering is an unusual special session of the Methodists’ General Conference, which normally meets in years divisible by four.
But the 2016 conference, with more than 100 proposals on sexuality clogging its docket, appointed a commission to prepare for a special 2019 session to focus on the issue.
That day arrives Saturday.
The focus is on the denomination’s longstanding stance that homosexual practice is “incompatible with Christian teaching” and its bans on same-sex marriages and on any “self-avowed practicing homosexual” in ministry.
Proposals range from upholding to overturning it, to reorganizing along ideological rather than geographic lines to allowing a form of local option under what’s called the “One Church Plan.”
Delegates comprised of clergy and lay people will vote. Bishops will attend but not vote; they’ve already weighed in, however, by overwhelmingly recommending the One Church Plan.
That proposal would remove the current church-wide bans on gay ordination and same-sex marriage.
Under the proposal:
- Each pastor in the American church could decide whether or not to preside at a same-sex wedding.
- Each congregation could decide whether or not to host one, and whether or not to accept an openly gay pastor.
- Each conference’s board of ministry could decide whether or not to recommend an openly gay person for ordination.
- Bishops and clergy could choose whether or not to participate at ordinations of LGBT persons or at same-sex weddings.
- The overseas jurisdictions of the church would be able set their own national rules based on their own cultural contexts. These include large, fast-growing and typically conservative churches in Africa, where in some countries homosexual activity is illegal.
The African churches are growing fast, while the U.S. church has been declining in membership but still has a narrow majority in the denomination. There are about 7 million American members and nearly 6 million in Africa, Europe and Asia. The Western Pennsylvania Conference counts about 159,000 members and about 780 churches in its 23 counties.
The United Methodist Church is rooted in the teachings of the 18th century evangelist and theologian John Wesley, whose emphases included an initial conversation experience and ongoing piety on both an individual and a social level.
The church is the second-largest Protestant body in the United States. It is often called a mainline Protestant church with its typical presence in town squares and country crossroads and for its members’ liberal-to-conservative spectrum of opinions.
It’s the last of the major mainline Protestant body to be still debating the ordination and marriage of gay persons, with the largest Presbyterian, Episcopal and Lutheran bodies approving such measures — and seeing significant losses of congregations opposed to such moves.
Western Pennsylvania was a hub for organizing new conservative, breakaway Presbyterian, Anglican and Lutheran denominations.
Area United Methodists, while ranging in opinions, tend toward conservative views on sexuality.
The Rev. Eric Park, superintendent of the district that covers all or part of Butler, Beaver, Lawrence and Allegheny counties, echoed Bishop Moore-Koikoi’s hope for “collective, supernaturally equipped discernment.”
He noted that people on different sides of the issue see a lot at stake.
“I'm hearing a great deal of hope, but it’s hope that’s again moving in different directions,” he said. Many “are hoping that the traditionalist plan or something like it prevails. I’m convinced for many United Methodists, their convictions do not come from a spirit of homophobia but rather a strong conviction that the biblical narrative calls for a particular kind of stewardship over human sexuality.”
For those hoping a more progressive plan prevails, “their concerns and their hopes come from the strong conviction that the governing priority of the church needs to be radical hospitality of all people irrespective of their sexual orientation,” he said.
People “want the church to be the church God is calling it to be, but they have some very different understandings of what it means to be that church,” Rev. Park said.
Regardless of the result, Western Pennsylvania church leaders plan debriefing sessions at churches throughout the conference. “I’ve heard a lot of folks who have said … they want to figure out how we can move forward together even though they have a strong conviction one way or another,” Bishop Moore-Koikoi said.
Peter Smith: petersmith@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1416; Twitter @PG_PeterSmith.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.