Rabbi Keren Gorban was newly ordained and had just started her first synagogue assignment in Denver in 2012 when she received a text one summer morning from her brother, asking if she was safe.
That was how she learned that a gunman had killed 12 people and injured scores several hours earlier at the midnight showing of a Batman movie in the nearby suburb of Aurora, Colo.
She and others at her congregation helped members and the community cope with the senseless massacre and its aftermath.
And on Oct. 27 of this year, as soon as Rabbi Gorban and her fellow congregants at Temple Sinai in Squirrel Hill emerged from a lockdown, she began that process once again, with the unwanted benefit of experience. Her congregation is near the Tree of Life / Or L’Simcha synagogue, where a gunman killed 11 worshipers from three congregations.
She’s joined a small but tragically growing group of community leaders who have a grim vantage point on the crisis of mass shootings. She’s witnessed first-hand how far the country has come in six years in quickly mobilizing vigils, trauma counseling and other support systems to respond to mass shootings. In fact, the country has become adept at responding to them — but not at stopping them.
“Because it has become so frequent, there are resources available and ready to be deployed the second it happens,” said Rabbi Gorban, associate rabbi at Temple Sinai in Squirrel Hill.
Read More
“There is something seriously messed up and out of whack in our society if we can't stop this,” she said. “And the thing is, I don't think we can't. I think there has been an explicit choice by some people not to make the decisions that could put a stop to this.”
Rabbi Gorban recalled that her Denver congregation talked about the theater shootings at its Shabbat service immediately afterward, and she did her best to counsel a congregant who had taught some of the victims in the Aurora schools.
“But I was totally out of my league as a brand-new rabbi, as well as trying to deal with my own trauma around that, which I had never experienced before,” she said.
More than a year after the Aurora shootings, there was a school shooting nearby that claimed one life. Some of the congregation’s teens attended that school.
She and others at the congregation knew it was important to hold an open forum with teens at the synagogue, to help them to process their reactions. But even then, it was congregational leaders, not specially trained trauma counselors, conducting the discussions.
By 2018, it was clear that professional counselors would be needed to help people process trauma, both individually and in groups. Temple Sinai made such counselors available for students at its religious school.
“With the increased frequency of mass shootings, we just assume now that everyone is going to be traumatized and is going to need support,” said Rabbi Gorban, who moved here in 2015. “I can't imagine we didn't know that six years ago, but now we know how wide that spreads.”
The vigils that followed the Tree of Life shooting also show the evolution of the communal response to trauma.
After the Aurora shootings, people gathered for a vigil, but Rabbi Gorban doesn’t recall it being a broad-based community event like those held in Pittsburgh, which drew thousands including top public officials.
On Oct. 27, Rabbi Gorban herself had a role at one evening vigil, when hundreds packed Sixth Presbyterian Church in Squirrel Hill and many more gathered outside. She read a prayer “for healing after a hate crime,” resonant with outrage and lament, composed by a Washington state rabbi after a different kind of synagogue invasion — one that had left a sanctuary desecrated with the menacing symbol of a swastika.
The 2012 and 2018 massacres differed in apparent motive, or lack of one in the case of the man convicted of the Aurora shootings. Defense lawyers claimed he suffered psychosis, and he apparently targeted a crowded theater so he could kill as many as he could.
In contrast, Pittsburgh police say the gunman here targeted the synagogue due to his hatred of Jews, voiced online and out loud.
But whether motivated by hatred, psychotic delusions or something else, both killers had access to weaponry that could claim large casualties in a short time.
“We can talk about mental illness, we can talk spewing hatred and the cultural context that allows that vitriol to spread and be accepted and tolerated,” Rabbi Gorban said. “As with any sort of disease, we can treat the symptoms or we can treat the underlying illness. Right now, all we're doing is palliating the symptoms of the disease, which is comforting families or individuals after a shooting. The disease, the underlying problem is access to guns. And not every gun, because we've really got a significant difference between a pistol and a semi-automatic weapon.”
She sees the role of clergy as being more than chaplains to the grieving and the wounded.
That’s something she’s learned growing up in the Reform Jewish denomination, which encourages and trains members from their youth to advocate for better public policies.
“I learned that from my rabbis, this need to be involved politically and socially to ensure the world is a just place,” she said. “If people are dying for no other reason than that they showed up in a place they thought they would be safe, then that's a social problem that we need to address.”
Peter Smith: petersmith@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1416; Twitter @PG_PeterSmith.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.