They came from as far as Meadville to mourn, to pray, to sing, to embrace and to shed tears outside the synagogue where 11 people lost their lives a week ago in a horrific act of hate.

About 9:45 a.m. Saturday, at roughly the same time the first shots were fired inside the Tree of Life synagogue in Squirrel Hill seven days before, Chuck Diamond, its former rabbi, raised up his voice in a song of peace.

Shabbat at Tree of Life, one week after shootings

For nearly an hour, more than 100 people, Jewish and non-Jewish alike, crowded together on the sidewalk outside of the synagogue still roped off by yellow police tape or across the street to join him in a moving and emotional time of prayer, song and reflection.

It was not a regular Saturday morning Shabbat service. But Rabbi Diamond, who likes to refer to himself as the rabbi of the unaffiliated, felt compelled to deliver a message of healing after a tragic week filled with sorrow and funerals.

Advertise with us

“Last week at this time … think about what was going on here. And everybody wanted to be here to help in some way. And so to be here this Shabbat at the same time is extra meaningful and I thought a lot of people needed to be here,” he said. “And I guess I needed to be here.”

Rabbi Diamond served as the synagogue’s spiritual leader for seven years, up to a year and a half ago. He knew nine of the 11 victims killed in the attack by a gunman identified by police as Robert Bowers of Baldwin Borough.

In his remarks Saturday, Rabbi Diamond told how he was greeted at the synagogue each week by Cecil and David Rosenthal, brothers who were killed in the massacre.

“I can close my eyes — and I have to smile — I would hear Cecil and Cecil would say to me, ‘Rabbi, how come you’re late?’ Of course, it would be 20 minutes early,” he said.

Cecil, he recalled, would stand near the door of the chapel with another of the victims, Irving Younger, welcoming people.

Advertise with us

“I almost expected Cecil to greet me this morning,” he said.

Rabbi Diamond said David Rosenthal often would stand next to him during the service, prompting him to give him the title of “assistant rabbi.”

“They were such a joy and a gift to our community, angels given to us full of love and joy,” he said.

Rabbi Diamond passed the house of Rose Mallinger, another of the victims, on his way to the synagogue Saturday.

“She would have been here right after we started perhaps or at the beginning with her daughter. Thank God her daughter survived … but has to live with this terrible tragedy,” he said.

Advertise with us

The rabbi called the victims, seven members of the Tree of Life and four from two other congregations that shared the building, heroes. “They died as martyrs of Israel,” he said.

As for the accused gunman, “People have asked me all week, are you able to forgive? I said ‘I’m not even thinking about this guy. The justice system will take care of him. And he’ll get whatever is due to him.’”

Joining Rabbi Diamond in offering prayers Saturday was retired Presbyterian minister Lee Clark, who in his remarks recited part of Psalm 91, “Whoever dwells in the shelter of the Most High will rest in the shadow of the Almighty.”

He said he wanted to be part of the gathering because he grew up in a neighborhood similar to Squirrel Hill and was very much aggrieved by the attack. He added, “Jews are as close to me, as close to being my people, as anyone else.”

“I could not not come. I was compelled to come,” he said. “The only way to confront hatred is to face it with love. To show love is being present.”

Advertise with us

Rabbi Diamond called the synagogue shooting “an attack against all of us. So when the reverend says to me he is a rabbi, thank God for the reverend. We are here. We stand together. We stand united.”

In a time when it is perhaps impossible to make sense of the senseless, Rabbi Diamond said it is OK to be angry with God.

“You can challenge God. To me that’s a sign of a healthy relationship with God. There are many things in this world we don’t understand. What happened last Shabbat, there is so much about it I don’t understand. There’s so much about it that I struggle with,” he said. “I struggle with God on a daily basis but he is always there to comfort me and to give me faith.”

Hallie Goldstein, 25, of Squirrel Hill, who attends the synagogue, broke down during the service. Tree of Life was where she learned Jewish prayers with Ms. Mallinger’s grandchildren. She also knew or recognized many of the other victims.

She was in Houston, Texas, last week during the attack. Since returning, she has been at the site almost every day and has helped to set up tents that protect the countless flower bouquets and signs that have been left in memory of those who perished.

Advertise with us

“I knew I had to join and help set up the tents because I need to do something. I need to bring creation in the face of destruction like this,” Ms. Goldstein said.

Ruth Berry of Swissvale said she worked in a kosher meat market in Squirrel Hill years ago and got to know many of the Jewish people and their customs. She wanted to stand in solidarity with them Saturday.

“This is a very large hole in my heart,” she said of the tragedy. “To see this in my lifetime … it hurts.”

Nick Ozorak got up at 6:30 a.m. to drive from Meadville, Crawford County, for the service. He still considers the people of Squirrel Hill, where he lived from 2013 to 2015, to be his neighbors.

The hatred experienced by his grandfather, a Holocaust survivor, still exists, he said.

Advertise with us

“I needed to be here as a sign of solidarity and support. I also felt support come back at me, so it’s a two-way street,” he said.

He did not know the service would be taking place outside of Tree of Life but figured there would be some type of observance.

“Fear that acts like this try to generate needs to be counteracted with the strength of resilience,” he said. “I think what was very overwhelming was the amount of peace that certainly I felt and I think others felt as well.”

Near the end of the service Saturday, Rabbi Diamond noted that it is customary at Jewish weddings to step on a glass as a way to momentarily remember, amid the joy, the tragedies Jewish people have faced throughout their existence.

His hope for the Tree of Life, the Jewish community as a whole, and all of those standing in sorrow with them is that “we are able to break the glass so, for a moment, we remember the tragedy.

Advertise with us

“But it cannot overshadow that this building is and will be in the future, a place of joy for future generations,” he said.

Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1262.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.