Pennsylvania Republican Sen. Pat Toomey, and Democrat Sens. Charles Schumer of New York and Richard Blumenthal of Connecticut do not often see eye-to-eye on legislative matters.
But the three lawmakers are teaming up to introduce a measure aimed to keep a trove of Iraqi Jewish artifacts in the United States, they announced in a news release Thursday.
The proposed resolution, co-sponsored by Sen. Marco Rubio, R-Fla., calls for 2,700 priceless books, religious texts and civic documents that were unearthed in the basement of Saddam Hussein’s secret police headquarters in 2003 to remain in the U.S.
The U.S. had previously agreed to restore the items, many of which were badly damaged, and send them back to Iraq in September. The senators’ proposal calls on the United States to renegotiate that agreement to allow the archive to remain in America for a longer period of time.
“It makes no sense for this material to return to Iraq when the vast majority of Iraqi Jews and their descendants live in the Diaspora,” Mr. Toomey said in the news release. “I hope that the Senate swiftly approves our resolution to once again urge the State Department to keep these artifacts in the United States.”
Carole Basri, a law professor at Fordham, said another compelling reason for keeping the collection of artifacts was that it would be “safer” in America than Iraq.
“Why are we sending it back to people who trash their own national archives for anything that’s Jewish?” she said.
Others, though, have contested that the artifacts should return to Iraq.
University of Pittsburgh professor Julia Santucci said that although she remains unsure where the archive should end up, there are a few compelling points in favor of Iraq.
“The United States removed these artifacts after occupying the country with the agreement of the provisional government of Iraq that they would be returned,” she said. “We don’t want to be seen as an occupying power that took artifacts from the country and didn’t bring them back.”
She added that not returning the archive could “become a hiccup in bilateral relations with Iraq.”
Plus, she said, the Trump administration could secure “specific commitments” from Iraq that the archive will be “accessible” to Iraqi Jews upon its return.
Thursday’s resolution does not mark the first time governmental officials have considered the fate of the Iraqi Jewish archive.
Fareed Yasseen, Iraq’s ambassador to the U.S., said in an interview that he discussed the issue with congressmen Wednesday and has met with representatives from Jewish non-governmental organizations in recent weeks. He declined to comment further on the archive.
Mr. Toomey has previously weighed in on the debate. In 2014, he introduced a resolution that urged the State Department to reconsider returning the artifacts to Iraq. The United States had initially been scheduled to return the Jewish archive to Iraq in June 2014. The Senate unanimously backed his resolution and the archives have remained in the United States since then.
Ultimately, however, it may not be the Senate’s choice where the archives go.
The resolution can express the “intent of Congress” but it does not “actually have a legal bearing on what the administration does,” Ms. Santucci explained.
It’s “still in the executive branch’s hands to decide how to proceed,” she said.
Caroline S. Engelmayer: cengelmayer@post-gazette.com or on Twitter @cengelmayer13.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.