GROVE CITY — In the large, echoing gym at Grove City College here, more than a thousand United Methodists prayed as a group and sang guitar-led choruses like "Go Tell It on the Mountain."
From Wednesday to Saturday, they heard reports from their foundation, their credit union, their camp ministry. During one of the breaks, youths in matching T-shirts exuberantly sang a medley of a capella choruses.
But sober discussions were mixed in with the otherwise upbeat tone in the annual gathering last week of delegates and other church members from the Western Pennsylvania Conference of the United Methodist Church.
The looming question: whether these Methodists, one of the largest Protestant bodies in Western Pennsylvania and the nation, can live up to their name and remain united.
Can they succeed where other mainline denominations have not, in somehow resolving titanic debates over sexuality, biblical interpretation and the role of LGBT people? It's an especially crucial question in these parts, as Western Pennsylvania has been ground zero in recent schisms of other Protestant denominations.
A showdown is set for February 2019, when United Methodist delegates from throughout the world meet in St. Louis in a rare special convention. They will vote on a compromise their bishops are presenting.
The bishops’ so-called “One Church Plan” would remove long-standing language from the church's Book of Discipline that bans “self-avowed, practicing homosexuals" from ordination. It would instead give Methodists in the U.S. a local option on such questions.
Under the proposal, recommended by an overwhelming vote of the worldwide denomination's bishops, each pastor in the American church could decide whether to preside at a same-sex wedding; each congregation could decide whether to host one; each board of ministry could decide whether to recommend an openly gay person for ordination; and churches or congregations conflicted on the issue wouldn't be forced to take a side, according to a summary presented by conference Bishop Cynthia Moore-Koikoi.
The overseas jurisdictions of the church would be able set their own rules based on their own cultural contexts. These include large and typically conservative churches in Africa, where in some countries homosexual activity is illegal.
Western Pennsylvania clergy already have engaged in various dialogue sessions that give a preview of what's at stake.
In small gatherings around the region in recent months, some feared the denomination would make any change to keep the peace, while others feared it would refuse to do so for the same reason.
"Our discussions were candid, emotional and difficult at times," said the Rev. Tom Strandburg, pastor of Mt. Lebanon United Methodist Church and one of those on the clergy board who helped organize the dialogues. "... The task of finding common ground is difficult. Compromise is often viewed as capitulation."
But, added the Rev. Renee Mikell, another board member and assistant to Bishop Moore-Koikoi, "people agreed to disagree. We agreed to bear with each other in love."
In her own talk, Bishop Moore-Koikoi alluded to concerns voiced by both conservatives who believe the church is being asked to affirm sexual sin and liberals who believe the ban on gay marriage and ordination is an injustice.
"Questions have been raised about how we can live together as a church family...with people we believe are knowingly engaged in sin and are unrepentant about that sin," she said.
"You can ask my dad that question," she continued. If they were alive, you could ask my grandparents that question," she said.
That's because in 1939, the year her father was born, the forerunner of the United Methodist Church segregated itself into white and black conferences.
"We all know racism is sin," said Bishop Moore-Koikoi, who is the first African-American woman bishop of the Western Pennsylvania Conference. "As a denomination, we institutionalized that sin."
Yet her grandparents had her parents baptized and raised in the denomination.
"They chose to do that because they had hope," she said. "... They had hope in the dream that one day this denomination would look like the kingdom of God."
In the 1960s, the Methodists abolished the segregated church conferences.
"And now my grandparents' granddaughter is a bishop serving in an annual conference where 97 percent of the people are white. If they had not had stayed and endured the sin, i wouldn't have gotten to know you all. I would not have been blessed in this way."
She said she doesn't "want to imagine a church where I'm not working ... with folks who I disagree with on this one thing."
In an earlier interview, Bishop Moore-Koikoi said she has established a task force to promote dialogue on the issue throughout the region, and she urged people not to show up with an inflexible stance.
"We truly believe God shows up in the midst of our holy conferencing," she said. "It is my hope that we will discern a way to move forward in unity.”
In interviews before and during the conference, local Methodists agreed the church will face change of some kind in February 2019.
Efforts to repeal the current discipline have repeatedly failed at the once-every-four-year General Conventions by increasingly firm margins, largely on the strength of the large numbers of delegates from conservative African churches.
But some liberal U.S. conferences are installing openly gay pastors and one bishop in defiance of church law.
Those supporting the current language in the Book of Discipline say it reflects the church’s traditional understanding of the Bible.
“For us as a congregation, we support the current discipline, and we’re continuing to operate on that,” said the Rev. Steve Cordle, lead pastor of Crossroads Church, which is one of the region’s largest United Methodist congregations as it has branched out from its North Fayette base to multiple campuses.
But he’s concerned about the outcome.
“We don’t know what’s going to happen in February," he said, but "the status quo won't stay."
Attendees here voiced hope for unity.
"What we try to do is at all times ask God's guidance," said Mark Yonko, a member of Banning United Methodist Church in Fayette County. "To stay away from judgment and to stay in faith."
Pastor Pamela Ramsey, a youth minister at Bethel United Methodist Church in Lower Burrell, said Christians are called to love God and neighbor and that "everything else is in God's hands."
"I don't know how it's going to work out," she said. "It's extremely divisive. Our country is extremely divided."
She had a beloved late cousin who was gay and believes virtually all gay persons are born with their orientation.
"They have a right to happiness and a right to relationship," she said. At the same time, "I have friends in the Methodist Church who don't feel exactly as I do, and that's OK, because it's for me to love them, too."
Peter Smith: petersmith@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1416; Twitter @PG_PeterSmith.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.