Hundreds of makeshift boats no longer race down Ten Mile Creek in rural Washington County each year in an “Anything That Floats” race.

The Marianna Outdoorsmen Association says that's because Pennsylvania's Department of Transportation and Department of Environmental Protection unlawfully polluted the stream with boulders and riprap — layers of large, heavy, loose stones or concrete chunks used to armor shorelines, riverbanks and slopes against erosion.

The nonprofit association, which originally formed to stock trout in Ten Mile Creek near Marianna, according to its website, filed a lawsuit in Commonwealth Court against both state agencies last Thursday, alleging they violated the Clean Streams Law and the Environmental Rights Amendment of the state constitution.

"This is a David and Goliath scenario, where the little guy is standing up and putting their foot down," Marianna Outdoorsmen Association Executive Director Jason White said. "What has not only gone on, but what has continued to go on, is completely wrong."

Advertise with us

The group's “Anything That Floats” race, which billed itself as the largest canoe race in Pennsylvania, began in 2007 and ended up drawing over 250 riders and thousands of spectators. The Outdoorsmen Association’s broader mission has been to promote conservation efforts and outdoor activities along the Ten Mile Creek watershed, but the race was its biggest annual fundraiser.

Since 2019, the race has not taken place.

According to the lawsuit, in 2016 Marianna Outdoorsmen's Association was notified that the state's Department of Environmental Protection approved a permit for PennDOT to start a road stabilization project for Marianna’s Main Street. The project installed boulders and "riprap," a layer of large stones to prevent soil erosion, near a streambank along a portion of the creek abutting property that MOA leased from the borough near the location of the race.

Despite being advised by the Outdoorsmen’s Association and PennDOT's own internal engineers that the plan would cause significant damage to the creek, the lawsuit said, PennDOT proceeded.

"We were told ‘this is all fine,’ " White said. "Well, two weeks after they finished, the entire hillside that they spent six months working on collapsed into the stream, basically destroying the entire park space where we had the canoe race."

Advertise with us

The lawsuit describes that over the winter of 2016 and 2017, the rocks slid into the creek, eventually extending all the way across the width of the creek. As a result, the Outdoorsmen’s Association permanently canceled the canoe race —  an event that brought them $50,000 in revenue in its last year.

White said the biggest issue is getting onto the stream, rather than the stream itself. He said the streambanks used to be a smooth park space, acting as a transition area to get into the creek. They used to have a ramp and a grassy space where even a person in a wheelchair could get down to the stream.

"Now it's jagged rocks," White said. "There's a 1-foot drop off because of so much erosion.”

According to the lawsuit, the association has lost $400,000 in revenue since being unable to hold the event. White said the group has "done everything" to meet with agencies, district managers and politicians to discuss the situation before taking legal action.

PennDOT said it cannot comment on pending litigation. PA’s Department of Environmental Protection similarly said it does not comment on litigation.

Advertise with us

In 2025, the Department of Environmental Protection inspected the roadway stabilization project and advised PennDOT on a plan for remediation. But the lawsuit says that "to the best of the association's knowledge," PennDOT failed to provide a comprehensive response to the plan and has "taken no further steps."

The Marianna Outdoorsmen's Association's attorney said he cannot comment on ongoing litigation. Marianna Borough is described in the lawsuit as having suffered substantial economic loss due to PennDOT's work on a portion of the creek; a person who answered the phone at the borough office said the borough has no comment and "has nothing to do with it."

State Rep. Bud Cook, who represents parts of Washington County, said he supports the lawsuit.

"If you can't come to an agreement and you feel like you've been done wrong, that's your course of action, to go ahead and try it to get it resolved that way," Cook said.

Cook referenced the significant tourism industry in Pennsylvania, and said that the absence of the canoe race might negatively affect Marianna Borough in its tourism sector.

Advertise with us

"Travel and tourism dollars turn like 40 times in a community," Cook said.

The lawsuit asks the court to affirm that the Department of Environmental Protection violated the Clean Streams Act and the state’s Environmental Rights Amendment by ignoring its duties to abate “ongoing nuisances in recreational waterways,” ensure waterways remain clean and unpolluted, prevent and eliminate water pollution in order to sustain economic growth, and maintain "an indiscriminate and comprehensive watershed management and control program.”

It also seeks an order instructing PennDOT to restore the impacted portions of the creek, and for PennDOT and the Department of Environmental Protection to reimburse the Marianna Outdoorsmen’s Association for all costs and fees related to the matter.