The first indication that something was wrong was the sound of sirens.
They were constant.
Fire trucks raced up and down Bacon Avenue for several hours throughout the evening and into the morning.
Jess Conard, a multigenerational resident of East Palestine, Ohio, was at home with her family when she heard the chaos on Feb. 3, 2023 — the night a Norfolk Southern freight train derailed nearby, sparking a massive fire and releasing toxic chemicals into the small village near the Ohio-Pennsylvania border.
In the days that followed, residents said they struggled to get clear information about what they had been exposed to.
In an effort to prevent an explosion, officials carried out a controversial “vent and burn” procedure of five tank cars containing vinyl chloride, a carcinogen that can cause liver, brain and lung cancer.
Read More
Once the vent and burn was completed, Ms. Conard returned to her home after briefly evacuating with her children, who were 3, 9 and 10 at the time.
“When I pulled into my driveway, the smell was horrific — this pungent, acrid, chemical, heavy smell that sticks to your eyes and your tongue,” she said. “And you could see this big black plume that, at the time, you couldn’t tell if it was coming from the sky or coming from the ground.”
She compared it to a tornado that “covered the entire town.”
Three years later, the derailment in East Palestine has thrust vinyl chloride back into the national spotlight as Congress debates whether to overhaul the law designed in part to control it.
Last month, House Republicans introduced a discussion draft that proposed amendments to the Toxic Substances Control Act, the nation’s primary law that governs how chemicals are tested, reviewed and restricted.
Supporters of the bill argue the changes would make U.S. manufacturers stronger competitors in the global market. But environmental advocates and scientific experts are warning of the consequences on industrial workers, communities near chemical plants and consumers.
“When I first saw it, I thought, this is gutting any protections and clearly is putting profits ahead of our health,” said Maria Doa, senior director for chemical policy at the Environmental Defense Fund and a former Environmental Protection Agency employee.

Toxic Substances Control Act
In the 1970s, the White House Council on Environmental Quality and EPA officials raised concerns about vinyl chloride after several workers exposed to it died of a rare form of liver cancer.
The chemical was labeled a carcinogen in 1974, and soon thereafter, environmental leaders and members of Congress met to write the original Toxic Substances Control Act, or TSCA, to ensure chemicals were made and used safely.
“The discovery of the cancer-causing potential of vinyl chloride is an all-too-familiar example of the consequences of failing to look for and deal with the chronic health effects of chemical products, including those resulting in cancer, genetic mutation, and birth defects,” Russel W. Peterson, former chairman of the Council on Environmental Quality, said during a legislative hearing on the bill in 1975.
Once TSCA was passed in 1976, it gave the EPA the authority to mandate reporting, record-keeping, testing requirements and restrictions of certain chemical substances and mixtures.
In 2016, the law was amended to include a mandatory requirement for the EPA to evaluate existing chemicals with enforceable deadlines, conduct risk-based chemical assessments and increase public transparency for chemical information.
The new law also mentioned that consistent funding would be provided for the EPA to carry out its new responsibilities.
“When TSCA was strengthened, it gave the EPA a process for dealing with these chemicals that have been on the market for a long time,” Ms. Doa said. “This would make TSCA worse than it was before 2016.”

‘Fundamentally unscientific’ changes?
As the EPA works through its risk assessment of vinyl chloride, the law guiding that process may soon change.
On Jan.15, Rep. Brett Guthrie, R-Ky., chair of the House Committee on Energy and Commerce, and Rep. Gary Palmer, R-Alabama, chair of the subcommittee on commerce, announced a hearing for the following week titled “Chemicals in Commerce: Legislative Proposal to Modernize America's Chemical Safety Law, Strengthen Critical Supply Chains, and Grow Domestic Manufacturing."
The two House Republicans said the hearing would be focused on discussing a draft bill to modernize TSCA.
“Since TSCA was last addressed nearly a decade ago, we have heard that these reforms are needed to modernize the law and ensure new chemicals undergo a more predictable review process,” a spokesman for the Committee on Energy and Commerce told the Post-Gazette in an email. “We can bring safe chemicals to market in the United States while maintaining strong protections for human health and the environment.”
Among the most significant revisions is a shift in the standard for regulatory action and risk assessment.
The current law requires the EPA to “prevent or eliminate unreasonable risks” to health or the environment that are associated with a chemical substance or mixture.
The proposed bill directs the agency to “minimize risk to the extent reasonably feasible.” The bill also suggests considering “cost-effectiveness” in decision-making and speeding approvals for chemicals given the green light in other countries.
“There's a little bit of softening of the language that doesn't necessarily say that exposures will be prevented, but rather that it's a good faith effort to reduce exposure,” said Carla Ng, an associate professor in the department of civil and environmental engineering at the University of Pittsburgh. “So that, to me, really reads like it is taking some of the teeth out of TSCA.”
If accepted as currently written, the amendments would also narrow how exposure is evaluated.
Under the new bill, EPA administrators would need to issue a written determination justifying why the consideration of aggregate exposure to a chemical substance — meaning the total combined exposure from all possible sources such as food, water, air and products — was necessary for a risk evaluation.
Ms. Doa said the change “basically tells the EPA to exclude ways people are exposed.”
“It's just fundamentally unscientific,” she said.

Supporters of the bill say the changes address industry concerns, particularly regarding the speed of the chemical review process, which some say puts manufacturers at a disadvantage, hinders innovation and slows economic growth.
“Despite the progress made since TSCA was last modernized, we continue to face significant challenges,” Kimberly Wise White, vice president of regulatory and scientific affairs at the American Chemistry Council, said during the Jan. 22 hearing. “EPA’s delays in chemical reviews, its inconsistent application of scientific principles, and the lack of clarity and regulatory decisions have created uncertainty for manufacturers and downstream users, threatening U.S. competitiveness in the global marketplace.”
But others, such as Ms. Ng, believe the drafted changes do not address challenges and inefficiencies in chemical regulation.
“I think a large part of the problem is the fact that the EPA has been hamstrung for many years before, because it's often difficult to get information from submitters, and also because, especially now, they don't have the resources available to them to carry out these evaluations in a timely manner,” Ms. Ng said.
The EPA’s workforce has also been shrinking drastically since the start of President Donald Trump’s second term, according to data compiled by the U.S. Office of Personnel Management, or OPM.
Between 2024 and 2026, more than 2,000 employees have departed the EPA, the data shows.
“You can't be cutting the agency staff and scientific experts on one hand and then saying, well, we need to change this law because it's too slow to do things right,” Ms. Ng said. “That doesn't make a lot of sense to me.”
Life after the derailment
In the aftermath of the derailment, current and former East Palestine residents are still reeling from the effects of chemical exposure.
Just a few months after the explosion, Ms. Conard noticed her youngest son began having coughing fits and trouble breathing. He was later diagnosed with asthma, which she said does not run in their family.
Her partner also began experiencing issues with his eyes and migraines. And Ms. Conard herself developed hormonal issues and skin rashes.
According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, irritation of the eyes and respiratory tract, as well as changes to the skin, are symptomatic of vinyl chloride exposure.
And a year later, when the family decided to use specialized canisters to test for chemical substances in their home, they found traces of vinyl chloride on their back porch, pushing them to sell what they believed was their “forever home.”
“I feel homesick every day, but I feel like I can never go home,” Ms. Conard said.
Although Ms. Conard has since moved out of East Palestine, she continues to be a leader in environmental advocacy and rail-safety work.
And as discussions on amending TSCA continue, she urges community members to call their legislators to urge them to protect the law’s current framework.
“Weakening TSCA puts people at risk, because you're potentially opening up the opportunity to put more hazardous substances in or near neighborhoods,” she said.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.