As much as 15 billion gallons of sewage-laced stormwater has overflowed the regional sewer system into the Pittsburgh region’s rivers in each of the last two years, according to Jordan Fischbach, a senior policy researcher and co-director of the RAND Corp.’s Climate Resilience Center.

That’s a significant increase from the 9 billion gallon overflow estimate used by the Allegheny County Sanitary Authority to formulate its federally mandated, $2 billion-plus overflow control plan, and calls into question whether the plan can handle that stormwater and sewage tsunami.

Mr. Fischbach, who is the lead author of an upcoming RAND report on green infrastructure approaches to the regional sewage system overflows, said the volume of wet weather sewage discharges has increased dramatically in recent years. That’s because of more precipitation in a changing regional climate, and more impermeable land use — parking lots, roadways, buildings — in Alcosan’s 82 member municipalities and the city of Pittsburgh.

Alcosan didn’t take into account the higher rainfall volumes or the bigger overflow amounts to formulate its control plan, Mr. Fischbach said.

Advertise with us

Instead, Alcosan used rainfall and overflow numbers from 2003, which were consistent with historical volumes a dozen years ago when the authority began putting together its wet weather plan, said Mr. Fischbach, who also headed a 2017 RAND review of local stormwater management.

But rainfall amounts are on the rise. In 2004, the region’s second wettest year in the last 20, Alcosan’s overflows were 14 to 15 billion gallons, Mr. Fischbach said, while the first and third wettest years locally were 2018 and 2019. Climate change models predict that wetter trend will continue.

“Our expectation is that overflows for 2018 and 2019 will look a lot like 2004,” Mr. Fischbach said. “Our report recommends that when making an infrastructure plan for facilities that will last 50 years, you take into account the expected future changes.”

Aly Shaw, an environmental justice organizer with Pittsburgh United, a citizen’s organization that has been active on public water issues, said the Alcosan wet weather plan will be the most expensive public works project in the history of the region, and it’s important that it take climate change into consideration and fix the overflow problem the right way.

“But we don’t want anything delayed. We’re saying let's go ahead with green infrastructure projects as much as we can right now to take as much stormwater as we can out of the system” Ms. Shaw said. “Then we can build adequate gray infrastructure once we make sure we have accurate projections of rainfall and stormwater overflows.”

Advertise with us

Joseph Vallarian, an Alcosan spokesman, said the authority, which serves about 825,000 people, correctly used a “historically typical year for rainfall” at the time the plan was first developed more than a decade ago.

“The current CWP is sized to meet consent decree and Clean Water Act water quality goals, which do not require elimination of combined sewer overflows,” Mr. Vallarian said in an email response to questions.”The Clean Water Plan meets compliance requirements, while managing cost and affordability.”

But he also signaled some flexibility is possible.

“As part of its ongoing planning,” he said. “Alcosan will be considering how voluntary upsizing of projects to address future uncertainties — such as projected changes in future rainfall — could impact the sizing, cost and affordability of the plan.”

Fixing the overflow problem

Advertise with us

The Alcosan system, like hundreds of other older sewage systems in the U.S., was designed to prevent damage to the treatment operation by automatically diverting storm-swollen sewage overflows directly into rivers and streams.

But most of those discharges were banned by the 1972 Clean Water Act because they can contaminate rivers and streams, damage aquatic life, degrade water quality and put public water supplies at risk.

In 2008 Alcosan signed a federal consent order requiring the authority to stop all illegal raw sewage discharges into rivers from 52 sanitary sewer outfalls and reduce overflows from 153 combined sewer outfalls by 85%.

After lengthy negotiations, the EPA approved a modified consent agreement in September 2019 that extends the authority’s original deadline for fixing those overflows by a decade, to 2036, and proposes construction of more than 15 miles of 14-foot-diameter storage tunnels underground along the city’s rivers to capture the overflows during storms.

The stored liquid would be pumped out of the tunnels during dry weather to the Woods Run treatment facility, which is undergoing a $300 million expansion that will eventually double its treatment capacity.

Advertise with us

The EPA said in September that the improvements to and expansion of the Alcosan collection, storage and treatment system by 2036 should allow it to capture 6.6 billion gallons, or 73% of the annual overflows.

To reduce 15 billion gallons of overflow by that percentage, Alcosan would need to capture almost 11 billion gallons a year.

If the EPA holds to the 85% reduction mandate in its original consent decree, Alcosan would need to capture 12.75 billion gallons of wet weather sewage flow annually, almost twice what the EPA said in September the plan can accomplish.

The consent agreement also contains an “adaptive language” provision allowing Alcosan to make adjustments to include more so-called “green infrastructure” like wetlands, parklets, permeable pavement, and rain gardens to capture precipitation where it falls.

Although only 3% of the more than $2 billion-plus Clean Water Plan is ticketed for green infrastructure, increasing spending in that area could reduce the amount of stormwater entering the system and therefore the amount that overflows.

Advertise with us

Mr. Fischbach said the focus of the RAND study, which was commissioned by the Heinz Endowments, the Hillman Foundation and 3 Rivers Wet Weather, is on green infrastructure projects that could reduce wet weather overflows.

That study is undergoing peer review and won’t be published or publicly released for another two or three months. He said it didn’t specifically review Alcosan’s final clean water plan.

“We think the Alcosan plan will still have a marked impact on reducing wet weather overflows,” he said. “It will have an effect. But whether it will be enough to satisfy the EPA is a question.”

But the EPA, which accepted Alcosan’s modified consent decree in September 2019, said the authority can address climate change impacts at a later date with additional modifications, if necessary.

“If rainfall patterns change for any reason, this information can be entered into Alcosan’s models of the sewer system as appropriate,” said Terri White, a spokeswoman for the agency’s Region III office in Philadelphia, in an email response that did not mention climate change.

Advertise with us

Asked if the existing $2 billion-plus Alcosan wet weather plan will solve the overflow problem, Ms. White stated it’s a place to start. She added that the planned construction work on the Alcosan conveyance, storage and treatment facilities, combined with city and municipal flow reduction efforts could bring the authority into compliance with the Clean Water Act and the consent decree by 2036.

“The need for ALCOSAN to complete additional work will be determined based upon post-construction monitoring of receiving water quality and remaining discharges in 2036,” she stated.

RAND’s 2017 report titled “Robust Stormwater Management in the Pittsburgh Region,”  acknowledged the volatility of the overflow volumes and the potential impacts of a changing climate on them.

“Adding to the challenge is potential deep uncertainty as to how the overflow problem might change in the future,” the report summary said. “Recent projections suggest that the northeastern United States could see increased precipitation caused by climate change, which challenges the traditional practice of using historical observations alone as a basis for future water infrastructure planning and design.”

The 2017 report said decision makers and planners in Allegheny County communities must make crucial infrastructure and policy decisions and investments to reduce sewer overflows, but don’t have good information about future conditions.

Advertise with us

“These decisions,” the study said, “will have implications for many decades to come, so the choices made today must also be resilient to possible changes and future conditions,” the study said.

Brenda Smith, an Alcosan board member and executive director of the Nine Mile Run Watershed Association, said Alcosan’s lengthy planning process coupled with monthslong delays in the federal review and approval schedule, resulted in a wet weather plan based on outdated rainfall volumes. Taking the new rainfall volumes into account will likely necessitate a follow-up amended consent decree, she said.

“It’s unfortunate that it took so many years to produce a plan, but EPA runs the show and the regulatory delays could stretch to years,” Ms. Smith said. “If we were considering rainfall that occurred last year or the year before, this plan would look different.

“And the fact the plan doesn’t seem adequate to today’s conditions demonstrates the problem that no one is taking climate change seriously.”

Ms. Smith was also critical of state and federal politicians for cutting infrastructure funding over the last several decades.

Advertise with us

“Even if Alcosan wants to do more to reduce stormwater into the system,” she said, “it’s unrealistic to think that ratepayers money alone will be able to pay for solutions to all the problems we are facing,

And although she has been a strong advocate for more green infrastructure, she said the higher volume overflows mean both green and gray construction will be necessary.

“It’s now very clear we can do a ton of green projects first,” Ms. Smith said, “but we’ll still need a ton of gray investment, too.”

The public comment period for the revised consent decree ended at the beginning of December and attracted more than 700 comments. The EPA and the Department of Justice are reviewing the comments and preparing responses, prior to final action by the U.S. District Court in Pittsburgh.

Don Hopey: dhopey@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1983. Twitter: @donhopey. 

Correction (made at 5:40 p.m. Jan. 28): Information about increased wet weather sewage overflows into area rivers should have been attributed to Jordan Fischbach, a RAND Corp. researcher, and not to an as-yet-unfinished study about new approaches to fixing the problem.