The Allegheny County Sanitary Authority’s long-delayed $2 billion-plus plan to reduce storm-caused sewage overflows into the region’s rivers is scheduled for a public unveiling next week.
Six years after submitting its first wet weather plan, Alcosan plans to hold a 2 p.m. news conference on Sept. 19, to announce the milestone consent agreement and reveal its details, according to an internal authority email, statements made at Wednesday’s Allegheny County Health Board meeting and sources knowledgeable about the authority’s plan.
The email, sent Sept. 5, states, “The moment we have waited for is finally here. On Thursday (we) will announce the release of a modified consent decree and specifics of the authority’s Clean Water Plan.”
On Wednesday morning, Joseph Vallarian, Alcosan’s communications director, declined to comment on the wet weather plan’s release or confirm the press conference, saying only, “as soon as we get permission to go forward we’ll be in touch.” The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency and several Alcosan board members were likewise mum.
But Jim Kelly, the Allegheny County Health Department’s deputy director of environmental health, confirmed at Wednesday’s county health Board meeting that the wet weather plan has been approved and will be announced at the Sept. 19 news conference.
“The terms of the consent order will be made public then,”Mr. Kelly told the board.
Read More
The more than 500-page document, finally blessed by the EPA and U.S. Department of Justice, which delayed release of the final plan for months, extends the authority’s 2026 compliance deadline by a decade, to 2036.
It also contains language that will allow Alcosan the flexibility to use new technology as it becomes available, and add environmentally friendly “green infrastructure” components like roof gardens, bioswales, permeable pavement, wetlands and stream daylighting when they are cost effective to reduce the flow of stormwater into the sewers.
Alcosan had asked the EPA fior time to consider using “green infrastructure” to replace or reduce some, but not all, of the massive, concrete, underground stormwater storage tunnels in the plan.
Environmental organizations and community groups have been adamant and vocal about pushing for more use of green infrastructure in the wet weather plan, even advocating for a "green first" approach. But the final version, while keeping alive those options doesn’t mandate any increased use.
Aly Shaw, environmental justice organizer at Pittsburgh United, hasn’t viewed the final consent document, but said Alcosan has displayed a historic lack of commitment to using green infrastructure, and that’s reflected in the low level of spending for such projects in earlier versions of the wet weather plan.
“(The) minuscule investment in green represents a huge lost opportunity for this region,” Ms. Shaw said. “With green investments we can reduce flooding, curb basement backups, help our climate crisis and create local jobs at the same time as we clean our rivers. We need to follow the City of Pittsburgh's lead and invest first in green solutions and then figure out how much gray is right for our region."
The Alcosan system, which serves about 825,000 people in Pittsburgh and 82 surrounding municipalities., is one of hundreds of older sewer systems in the U.S. that were designed to channel storm swollen sewage overflows directly into rivers and streams to prevent damage to the treatment facilities.
The subsequent passage of the federal Clean Water Act in 1972, along with updated sewage discharge regulations, no longer allows such sewage overflows. And a 2008 consent order mandates that Alcosan stop all 52 illegal sanitary sewer discharges into the region’s rivers and streams and reduce overflows from 153 combined sewer outfalls by 85 percent.
The EPA regulates the sewage overflows because they contaminate rivers and streams, damage aquatic life, degrade water quality and put public water supplies at risk. The Department of Justice is involved because the original consent order is a legal document, filed in federal court, and the amended document, following a 60 day public comment period, is also subject to court approval.
Alcosan submitted an initial plan to stem the wet weather overflows and comply with the EPA’s consent order in 2013, but the agency rejected that plan as “deficient” a year later because it did not reduce or treat enough of the 9 billion gallons of wet weather sewage discharges overflowing into local waterways each year
Negotiations on amending the consent order began in 2014, and in March 2016 the EPA proposed modifications that signaled it was open to inclusion of green infrastructure in the plan, and also to extending by a decade the authority’s original 2026 deadline for completing the required sewer system improvements. The extension was touted as a way to spread out the financial burden on Alcosan customers of paying for the plan.
In May 2017, following numerous email exchanges and negotiations, the EPA sent an amended draft wet weather plan to Alcosan that was not made public, but is similar to the final plan that is the subject of the Sept. 19 news conference.
Alcosan has not been idle while waiting for federal approval of the wet weather plan. It has started formulating a preliminary work plan, and construction is underway on a more than $300 million expansion project that will double the treatment capacity at the authority’s Woods Run facility to 600 million gallons a day.
On a parallel track, the health department is negotiating new, companion consent order agreements with 54 community-owned sanitary systems in the Alcosan service area.
Those negotiations are expected to continue into the winter of 2019.
According to a county health department report distributed at Wednesday’s board meeting, the final Alcosn consent decree will aid negotiators in setting goals and deadlines for municipalities in the Alcosan system for reducing overflows, fixing sewage collection systems and reducing the amount of stormwater and surface water entering the systems.
“What’s happening with the EPA consent order needed to happen,” said Bill Youngblood, a health board member and executive director of the McCandless Township Sanitary Authority, which has 5,000 of its 22,000 customers hooked into the Alcosan service area. We needed Alcosan and the EPA to finalize this order so we municipalities can get on to what we need to do.”
Don Hopey: dhopey@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1983 or on Twitter @donhopey





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.