An anecdote in the sources section of “Amity and Prosperity,” Eliza Griswold’s 2019 Pulitzer Prize-winning book, reveals the spark that led her to write about the toll the natural gas boom has taken on several families in Washington County.

“This book was born in Nigeria in 2007 after a bridge collapsed,” Ms. Griswold wrote. “I was riding across a river on an empty oil drum thinking about Minneapolis, where the I-35W Bridge had recently fallen into the Mississippi River, killing thirteen people. So many of the problems of collective poverty plaguing Africa and Asia were becoming more evident in America. I decided it was time to come home, to turn my attention to how we tell stories about systematic failings here in the United States.”

Ms. Griswold, 46, found plenty to write about in southwestern Pennsylvania, from community quarrels to years-long legal battles that had state-wide implications. She was back in the area earlier this month as she continues to cover ongoing environmental issues related to the oil and gas boom, a topic she examined in-depth not only in “Amity and Prosperity” but also has written about in various articles.

Some of what Ms. Griswold has discovered surprised her, particularly the level of disenfranchisement felt by those living in rural communities. But the poet-turned-journalist, a contributing writer for The New Yorker who has a vast amount of experience reporting on religion around the world, also confirmed some universal truths.

Advertise with us

“The sophistication of the people or the complexity of human understanding did not surprise me because that was true everywhere,” Ms. Griswold said in a recent interview at Jackson’s, a restaurant connected to the Hilton Garden Inn in Southpointe. “And I feel like that almost more than anything else is what I am doing as a reporter — kind of complicating what we think we know about people as much as about industry.”

That’s what Ms. Griswold attempts to do in “Amity and Prosperity” — to build a picture of individuals living in rural communities whose views and beliefs are far more complex than they often are portrayed as being. To do that, she spent as much time as she could not only reporting, but also learning about the customs, traditions and history of the communities and individuals who are the subjects of her work.

She attended town meetings, church services, hearings and fairs. She spent many hours with the people she wrote about. It helped her, she said, develop a better sense of the realities those living within feet of the oil and gas boom and the reasoning behind the choices they make.

“You can’t understand the fracking boom here if you don’t understand coal,” she said. “And time and again, these articles come out about the evils of fracking, and the people who sign contracts, as if they’re getting duped. And you’re like, ‘You don’t understand, the longwall coal mine was going to come under their farm, and they knew that.’ So, anyway, I think it’s important for authenticity, legitimacy and narrative to get into the history of a place, especially a place as interesting as here.”

“Amity and Prosperity” centers on the story of Stacey Haney, a single mother of two living on her family farm in southern Washington County who grew up in poverty and wants to give her children a better life. She sees the fanfare around fracking and decides to lease the gas rights under her land to to help pay for some much-needed upgrades around the farm. She’s also worried that if she doesn’t lease to the gas company, a coal company will undermine her land anyway.

Advertise with us

Ms. Haney starts to regret her decision when her happy, athletic teenage son, Harley, begins suffering from an unexplained illness, and several of her farm animals die. Her neighbors have similar experiences, and they come to believe that the nearby Range Resources industrial site is contaminating their water and air.

They lose faith in the government when the state Department of Environmental Protection and federal Environmental Protection Agency prove ineffective and unable to help them. But with the help of the lawyer couple John and Kendra Smith, they take on Range Resources and the government, which is trying to loosen restrictions on the industry.

The legal battles against an industry that many people believe is beneficial to the community — jobs are returning and the ailing economy is getting a boost — threatens the Haney family’s reputation. They start to feel like outsiders in a community where they have lived for generations.

“I think ultimately one of the tactics that industry uses to discount local voices is to discredit those who challenge them as outside somehow,” Ms. Griswold said. “And I think spending a lot of time and learning about the complexity of people and reporting from that place challenges that, and that’s really important.”

Ms. Griswold traveled to the region 37 times over seven years, beginning in March 2011, as she worked on her book, sometimes staying with a friend in Pittsburgh and, when someone else was footing the bill, at the Hilton Garden Inn.

Advertise with us

The hotel is not far from the Range Resources and Smith Butz law offices that played such a key role in the book. It’s one of the hotels in rural America where, as Ms. Griswold notes in her book, journalists flooded after Donald Trump was elected president in 2016, a media “enterprise that risked reducing sophisticated points of view to sound bites missing the larger story of a complex American landscape.”

“I think that it’s too easy a narrative by journalists that make their work not as strong, but also you can understand it,” she said. “You know how valuable time and money are, so you don’t get to do much beyond the coffee shop and the diner.”

But that extra time can lead to a better story.

Ms. Griswold did not first come to southwestern Pennsylvania as a journalist to report on fracking. Her initial idea was to report on infrastructure.

“I wanted to write about how our failure as a society to invest in our lifeline systems reflects aged-out bridges,” she said. “They’re literally called obsolete, but we’re still using them. ... So I started looking at bridges, and I would go out with PennDOT, which was a total disaster. I did not understand a word they said.”

Advertise with us

Through that work, Ms. Griswold met Rose Reilly, a biologist with the Army Corps of Engineers in Pittsburgh, who was interested in fracking. The two took a fortuitous trip to a meeting at the Morgantown, W.Va., airport where Ms. Griswold would meet Ms.Haney.

“She lived in Amity ... and her family all came from Prosperity,” Ms. Griswold said. Ms. Griswold then began “learning about Prosperity being undermined and how that all worked. So that’s how that came to be.”

Rural Pennsylvania is not where Ms. Griswold, whose background is in poetry, expected to find herself.

Early in her career, she was working at Vanity Fair magazine for about six months where she watched experienced journalists like Sebastian Junger, who reported on blood diamonds in Sierra Leone, and saw the kind of work she wanted to do.

In early 2001, she went to the Middle East to do a story on honor killings for The New Republic and the London Sunday Times. Back in the United States a few weeks later, she was walking through Central Park in New York City when the planes hit the World Trade Center on 9/11. She called her editor at the Sunday Times and asked if they needed a stringer to cover the story, and they did.

Advertise with us

Two weeks later — with dust from the Twin Towers still in her shoes — she was on her way to Pakistan to report on refugee camps.

Much of Ms. Griswold’s work focuses on religion; she wrote her first nonfiction book, “The Tenth Parallel,” about the geographical and ideological front line where Christianity and Islam collide.

She points to her childhood in Philadelphia as the daughter of a Episcopal priest who ended up becoming the presiding bishop of the Episcopal church in America as the reason she was drawn to reporting on religion.

Ms. Griswold said she sees similarities in the work she’s done on religion and on fracking, particularly when it comes to dispelling stereotypes about those touched by both.

“We dumb down faith, and we discount people of faith, especially in the bubbles of New York City — Pittsburgh, too, maybe — that people who believe in God are either dumb or poor or disenfranchised in some way,” she said. “And most of my work has been about puncturing that, because I think that’s just wrong. Whether that’s in Afghanistan or Somalia or Nigeria or Indiana.”

Andrew Goldstein: agoldstein@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1352.