The Route 30 landslide in East Pittsburgh on April 7 collapsed a roadway used by 21,000 vehicles a day, damaged two apartment buildings and two homes, and is just one of more than 70 recently displaced examples of the region’s roiling hills.
Because when push comes to shove in Western Pennsylvania, land slides, steep slopes slump and the earth moves — usually not in a good way — for locally inconvenienced residents and travelers.
The region’s hillsides have been answering to gravity since the last Ice Age, and what happened out on Route 30 just comes with the territory, said Helen Delano, senior geologic scientist with the Pennsylvania Department of Conservation and Natural Resources.
And after a record wet February and big early April storms, it seems the region’s hillsides have been letting go even more often than in the past.
Ms. Delano said the region’s steep hillsides, and a sedimentary geology that includes slippery shale and clay layers known as the “Pittsburgh red beds,” make the area prone to landslides.
Throw in February’s seven plus inches of rain and snow, an erratic March freeze-thaw cycle and a big early April storm that dumped two more inches of rain in the region, and the conditions are ripe for the land to slip and slide.
Read More
Road or lane closures due to landslides Record rainfall and erratic freeze-thaw cycle have combined to make the region’s hills slip and slide onto more than a dozen roadways.
*As of April 10 Sources: Pennsylvania Department of Transportation, Esri
“Landslides are always due to a combination of factors -- hill slopes, soil material, human disturbances and moisture,” Ms. Delano said. “Of course moisture is the one that changes.”
That moisture, whether it comes from snow or rain or leaky water or sewer pipes, can affect the geologic “cohesion” of the rock and soil layers that make up the region’s hilly topography, said Daniel Bain, assistant professor in the University of Pittsburgh’s Department of Geology and Environmental Science.
“Cohesion depends on the shape and makeup of soils. Certain clays stick together better than others,” Mr. Bain said. “If there’s water in the hill slope, the clays become heavier and there’s more weight, more force pushing down on the soil. The water floats the clay and the cohesion is reduced.”
Philip Reeder, dean of the Bayer School of Natural and Environmental Sciences at Duquesne University and an expert in landscape evolution, also cited the region’s topography, geology and weather as causes for the region’s recent slope instability.
“I’m sure it has something to do with the wetter than normal spring and the temperature fluxuations,” he said. “Given the nature of the (rock and soil) materials we have here in Allegheny County and the region, the repeated cycles of freezing and thawing, wet and dry, we see hillside movements that can be grouped under the term ‘mass wasting,’ a process in which gravity pulls down rock and soil and is potentially at work all the time.”
Mr. Reeder said the Route 30 slide appears to be a classic example of such topographic wasting, which caused the retaining wall at the bottom of the slope to collapse, removing support for the roadway.
“There was likely movement down the slope prior to the collapse, imperceptibly adding more stress on the wall until it couldn’t take it anymore,” he said. “That’s the force of gravity.”
That landslide wasn’t the first in the region and won’t be the last. Old U.S. Geological Survey maps document more than 15,000 ancient and geologically recent major landslides in Allegheny and Washington counties.
Those landslides can be inconvenient, closing and causing damage to roads like more than a dozen around the region right now, or even deadly. In February 1983 two persons died when their cars were crushed by soil and rocks in a landslide on Saw Mill Run Boulevard near its intersection with McArdle Roadway.
The biggest recent local landslide occurred in September 2006, at a commercial development site in Kilbuck Township when more than 500,000 cubic yards of earth and stone cascaded down a hillside and buried four high traffic lanes of Ohio River Boulevard and three adjacent railroad lines.
That slide spawned a state Legislature review in 2008 of landslide hazards in the region that recommended development of a statewide map and inventory of landslide and sinkhole prone areas. At the time, the state Department of Conservation and Natural Resources estimated such an inventory would cost $9 million.
Ms. Delano, who was on the advisory committee of that task force, said legislation to create the inventory was introduced in 2008 but never made it out of committee.
“The Legislature did not make that investment, and such a sum is outside the operating budget of the department and bureau,” said Terrence Brady, a DCNR spokesman.
Neil Shader, a DEP spokesman, said the department does not have the authority to require geologic hazard reviews as a part of permit applications for earth disturbance, erosion and sediment control, and post-construction stormwater management.
Giving the DEP such authority would require legislative action, Mr. Shader said, and no such bills are presently pending before the Legislature.
The DEP does include recommendations in its erosion and sedimentation and post-construction stormwater management manuals on how to avoid landslide slope failures.
Federal legislation, under the title “National Landslide Preparedness Act,” was introduced last year in the House and Senate to establish a National Landslide Hazards Reduction Program through the U.S. Geological Survey to better identify and understand landslide risks, protect communities, save lives and property and help improve emergency preparedness.
The legislation was introduced in response to a massive landslide that killed 43 people and destroyed 42 homes near Oso, Washington, in March 2014.
According to the USGS and National Research Council, landslide hazards in the U.S. kill 25 to 50 people a year and cause between $1.6 billion and $3.2 billion in damage.
Ms. Delano said she and several colleagues have been collecting landslide information with the goal of building understanding about the scope of the problem in the state.
“Landslides have been attracting national attention within the geological community for the last several decades and especially since the big one in Washington state,” Ms. Delano said. “There’s been a national discussion about preparing landslide inventory maps. Pennsylvania rivals anywhere else in terms of numbers. Most of them are small but they add up.”
Don Hopey: dhopey@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1983, or on Twitter @donhopey





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.