Call them collateral benefits.
A new study finds that the Obama administration’s controversial plan to cut climate-changing carbon dioxide emissions from coal-burning power plants could also reduce the number of premature deaths in the U.S. by about 3,500 a year, including 330 in Pennsylvania.
The study findings, published Monday in Nature Climate Change — a peer-reviewed scientific journal — show Pennsylvania would experience the highest number of avoidable premature deaths annually, with Ohio (280) second and Texas (230) third.
The study by scientists from Harvard, Boston and Syracuse universities found that federal policies similar to the Clean Power Plan, intended to reduce carbon dioxide emissions by 30 percent from 2005 levels, would also cause a decline in lung disease and heart attacks. In Pennsylvania, that translates into 71 hospitalizations and 19 heart attacks avoided each year. Nationwide, the policies would result in 1,000 fewer hospitalizations and 220 fewer heart attacks.
“People are focused on climate control and mitigation, but in doing this study we wanted to bring attention to the additional benefits from carbon controls,” said Charles T. Driscoll, lead author of the study and a professor of civil and environmental engineering at Syracuse.
The study investigated three different scenarios for reducing carbon emissions, with the second closely resembling the proposed federal rule that is scheduled to be finalized this summer. The study reviewed the emissions history of 2,417 power plants and tracked emissions for the different scenarios using computer models.
That second scenario, Mr. Driscoll said, was developed prior to the Clean Power Plan proposal, but like that proposal uses a flexible array of options to reduce carbon emissions, and would result in lower annual and peak carbon and ground-level ozone emissions, the principal component of unhealthy smog. The biggest emissions reductions would occur in the northeastern U.S., especially in the Ohio River Valley, the study found.
“This can be pitched as a ‘two-fer,’ and states, if they think smartly, can implement a variety of options that can have ozone reduction benefits and benefits to their crops and forests, in addition to climate change and public health,” Mr. Driscoll said. “Pennsylvania, with its air quality challenges, would also expect to see many health benefits.”
Except for New York, which lies downwind from numerous coal-burning power plants and has a large population, the study found that states that would receive large health benefits from carbon controls are also those states that depend largely on coal-fired electricity. Therefore, it said, states with the greatest health benefits would also be those “where costs of the policy are likely to be greatest.”
Neither Pennsylvania’s Department of Environmental Protection nor the Allegheny County Health Department would comment, saying they had not had a chance to review the study. The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency issued a statement saying the study confirms its research and the health co-benefits of reducing carbon emissions, according to The Associated Press.
While the power industry has been critical of the proposed rule, saying it would result in job losses and possibly power shortages and doesn’t give the industry enough time to change to what would be a new power production mix, environmental organizations have supported the proposed plan.
Davitt Woodwell, president of the Pennsylvania Environmental Council, said that while the council is still developing its position on the Clean Power Plan, its potential to provide co-benefits makes it very attractive.
“We’re still looking at the sources of electricity under the proposed plan, how it incentivizes some and not others,” Mr. Woodwell said. “But there are all kinds of reasons to look at the desired results of the plan. It’s not just about its impact on climate change. This study shows some of those real benefits.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.