A different perspective or a new context can often aid our understanding of a problem, and that applies to the current controversy over deer in Pennsylvania's forests.
Conservationists and biologists have been trying to convince the hunting public that there can be such a thing as "too many deer," and that we've experienced that very condition here in Pennsylvania. Their warning has always been a hard sell.
That may be because the biologists' most compelling arguments are about things that deer have removed or caused to disappear from the forest. It is hard for humans to get concerned about things they can't see.
Biologists warn that forests are not regenerating, that songbirds are disappearing from over-browsed habitat, and that the deer themselves are not as healthy and robust as they could be in smaller herds. But all those liabilities are difficult to get the mind around because we can't see what's not there. The evidence is often all about absence. And if what's missing is something you've never known, it can be tough to believe there's a problem.
Surprisingly, Banff National Park in Alberta, Canada, offers the aforementioned new perspective. Its ecological situation frames our own deer issue. Banff is a 1,000-square mile slice of the Canadian Rockies about 100 miles north of the U. S. border. It's a popular tourist destination--Canada's Yellowstone, to put it provincially.
Originally Banff featured a full and vibrant Rocky Mountain ecosystem. Implementing the logic of their times, managers decided to improve that ecosystem by exterminating the park's wolves in the 1950s. Predictably, after the wolves' demise the elk herd mushroomed. For decades, park visitors enjoyed and grew accustomed to large herds of elk. They did not notice--did not know to look for--the growing scarcity of young willow trees favored by elk as forage. Nor did they recognize the disappearance of birds, beavers and other wildlife that depended on the willow. Elk were what visitors expected to see. The absence of other elements of Banff's ecosystem was rarely considered.
Then, in the 1980s wolves began to return to the park, but not the entire park. They stayed in the more remote sections and avoided those areas developed for tourists. The wolves' chief prey was elk, and scientists began to notice some fascinating changes in parts of the park where wolf packs hunted.
Scientists at the University of Alberta began to study the relationship between wolves, elk and the Banff ecosystem. This summer chief researcher Mark Hebblewhite published their findings about the importance of "top predators" in the journal Ecology. Banff offered an ideal research location because it held some habitat with wolves and some without, allowing a comparative study of both kinds of sites.
Hebblewhite and his assistants documented that wolf packs reduced elk numbers in those areas they hunted. More importantly, where wolves thrived they documented the return of willows and other vegetation that was absent in those sections wolves avoided. And where the willow returned, the researchers noted more diverse wildlife. Beaver dams and dried up wetlands returned, and wetland birds, waterfowl and other wildlife thrived again where they had not been seen in decades. Over-grazed grasses flourished anew on upland prairies.
"We found that as elk populations climbed, active beaver lodges declined, probably because beavers could no longer find sufficient trees with which to build their dams," Hebblewhite said.
Hebblewhite describes the effect of the absence of wolves and the surge in elk numbers as a "trophic cascade."
"The cascade refers to the kind of domino or waterfall-like effect where the absence of the top predator, in this case wolves, ripples and trickles down through the whole ecosystem," he said. "So, in essence, without wolves we're left with basically a beige ecosystem -- just plainer, simpler, less variation, less biodiversity."
Obviously, it is not practical to re-introduce or encourage wolves in modern Pennsylvania. But the lesson of Banff helps us see the importance of the role of deer hunters in Pennsylvania's forests. Deer hunters must now take the place of wolves and mountain lions to control deer numbers. Because strict hunting regulations prevented adequate deer harvests for so long, the impacts on the forest environment have been profound and widespread. If our forests are to exhibit the kind of diversity and resilience they once had, deer hunters need to accept and support continued aggressive deer management.
"As a society, we want to try to conserve ecosystems, but it's expensive. And we often don't know the best way to do that," Hebblewhite said.
The best way to do that in Pennsylvania is through deer hunting, and deer hunters face a win-win situation. While enjoying our annual outdoor ritual, we can restore the balance and health of Pennsylvania's forest ecosystems. Few people get the opportunity to contribute to such an important achievement.


Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.