The Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission is challenging a series of state decisions that it claims allow commercial sand and gravel dredging operations to harm rare and endangered freshwater mussel and fish breeding areas in the Allegheny River, 50 miles northeast of Pittsburgh.
The commission says the state Department of Environmental Protection approved amended dredging permits based on questionable survey conclusions about the aquatic life in Pool 8, between the towns of Mahoning and Rimer in Armstrong County, according to the latest of three appeals the commission filed with the state Environmental Hearing Board.
The underwater survey required as a condition of the permit process concluded there are no "significant mussel resources'' in Pool 8.
But the commission says that section contains the Northern riffleshell, a federal- and state-listed endangered mussel species, and the rayed bean and papershell mussels, two species that are rare in Pennsylvania.
"We question a definition of the term 'significant mussel resource' that would fail to find 135 individual [mussels] of eight species in a survey of 0.5 miles [of river] to be significant,'' John Arway, chief of the commission's division of Environmental Services, wrote in an April 2003 letter to the DEP critical of the survey methods.
"The most likely impact of dredging projects of this nature centers on the loss of habitat, which is important to the ecology of many fish and other aquatic species and in particular the endangered, threatened and candidate species found in the project area,'' Arway wrote.
Two state threatened fish species -- goldeye and smallmouth buffalo -- and two candidates for state listing -- longnose gar and river redhorse -- are also known to exist in the vicinity of the expanded river reaches permitted for dredging in January.
The appeals are the latest chapter in a contentious five-year battle over whether commercial river dredging should be allowed to continue on portions of a 100-mile stretch of publicly owned riverbed of the Allegheny and Ohio rivers.
DEP granted the river aggregates industry a five-year permit renewal in May 2001, but imposed new restrictions to protect aquatic life, including a requirement that the companies survey the river bottoms for rare shellfish before dredging.
Arway and Laurie Shepler, the commission's attorney, met with dredging industry representatives and DEP officials yesterday in Pittsburgh to discuss a settlement of the appeals. No resolution was reached.
Arway and Shepler declined to comment on the meeting.
Helen Humphreys Short, a DEP spokeswoman, said the matter is "in litigation and it would be inappropriate to comment further.''
Dan Giovannitti, a spokesman for dredging industry members Lane Construction Co., Glacial Sand and Gravel Co. and Hanson Aggregates P.M.A., formerly Pioneer Mid-Atlantic, said the river survey methods questioned by the Fish and Boat Commission were part of an October 2003 settlement of a lawsuit brought by environmental groups opposed to the renewal of the dredging permits.
"That discussion has been around for five years,'' Giovannitti said. "The protocol those guys are using to survey mussels has been accepted by the DEP and is appropriate.''
The Fish and Boat Commission was not a party to the lawsuit or the settlement.
The industry digs approximately 3.6 million tons of sand and gravel from the river bottoms a year. About 65 percent is used for road building, with about 35 percent sold directly to the Pennsylvania Department of Transportation, which values the hardness and skid resistance of the aggregate left behind by receding glaciers at the end of the last Ice Age.
The Fish and Boat Commission receives a royalty of 30 cents a ton for sand and gravel dredged from the rivers that the industry sells for up to $12 a ton.
No hearing date on the appeals has been set.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.