If you follow Route 144 north from Snow Shoe to Renovo, you know you are in Pennsylvania's "Big Woods." Almost the entire 30-mile trip winds across the crest of a wooded plateau in the Sproul State Forest in Clinton County. There are no towns or habitations and the only landmarks are signs for places such as "Fish Dam Wild Area." This is where the Pennsylvania Game Commission re-introduced fishers in the state, where there wasn't much chance of the big weasels getting into trouble.
This remote 180-square mile plateau is also the site of recent research into the movements of deer hunters in the woods, considered critical knowledge if the state is to skillfully manage its deer herd, especially in extensively forested habitats.
During the 2001 and 2002 deer seasons, Penn State researchers equipped 300 hunters in the area with Global Positioning System (GPS) units, which recorded hunter movements to within a few feet. The researchers also flew over the region in aircraft, sometimes as low as 600 feet above the trees, to observe and plot hunter distribution. While flying they wore special shooting glasses that make the orange clothing worn by hunters appear "hot pink" so that it was even more visible. They also met with hunters after their hunts, asking them to indicate on maps where they thought they had been hunting.
"Having hunters wear GPS units allowed us to essentially follow them into the woods to see how and where they hunted," said Rich Stedman, associate professor of rural sociology. "The results were surprising."
"No one has ever studied hunter movement before with this kind of technology," said Duane Diefenbach, assistant leader of the Pennsylvania Cooperative Fish and Wildlife Research Unit in Penn State's School of Forest Resources. "We didn't know what to expect. There are a lot of perceptions out there. As uncomfortable as the answers may be, the research is needed for better deer management and we need to know what is going on with hunters. There is a lot of research available that was done by asking hunters where they go and how they hunt, and a lot of opinions. But there are few hard facts about what actually happens on the ground."
What Diefenbach, Stedman and their associates found is that few deer hunters penetrate far into the forest. Hunter density in remote areas was extremely light and few hunters ventured into steep terrain.
"Hunters were bunched in flat areas within a third of a mile of the roads," Diefenbach said. "After the first day of the season, once you got more than a third of a mile from a road, the hunter density dropped to about one hunter for every eight square miles. The highest hunter density we saw was on a first day and it was only about 1.75 hunters per square mile."
The findings of the research indicate that, despite popular belief, deer hunting pressure on public forest lands, most of which are in the more remote northern parts of the state, is low.
"It's evidence that public lands do not have the excessive hunting pressure that many believe," Diefenbach said. "The conventional wisdom is that public lands have high hunting pressure and an overharvest of deer. That may be true in some areas, but certainly not in the region we studied. After the first days of the seasons, we had difficulty just finding hunters to carry our GPS units for the research. We believe this situation exists across the north central region."
Originally, the researchers intended to also record the number and location of deer killed by hunters. But hunters killed so few deer that that part of the study was abandoned.
"There were so few deer killed it wasn't worth the effort," Diefenbach said. "That was the real eye-opener for me. About half of the Sproul State Forest is beyond a third of a mile from any road that can be traveled by a vehicle, and the deer that live in those more-isolated areas are rarely threatened by a hunter. It looks like hunters are not killing enough deer in the big woods for harvest to play a role in management of the herd."
Diefenbach said another surprise was that the study areas were far more crowded with bear hunters during the previous week, approximately four times more hunters than during the deer season.
"The camps in the area were full of bear hunters the week before, but after the first few days of deer season, many of the camps were closed up and empty," he explained. "Given that we know that there are 800,000 to 900,000 deer hunters in the state and there are about 120,000 bear hunters, we were amazed to find more bear hunters. The bear hunting in the Sproul forest is excellent, but still there are far fewer bears than deer up there."
Factors such as temperature, weather conditions and the perceived deer population in the study area all play into hunter densities, Diefenbach said. "Hunting pressure on the publicly owned tracts in the north central region has fallen drastically, in part, because deer are everywhere in Pennsylvania now," he added. "You don't have to travel to the big woods to hunt, and many areas of the state have more and bigger deer. Soils are better in the southern and western parts of the state, and the habitat is healthier there.
"A big part of the reason there are fewer deer today in the big woods is that there were too many deer in the big woods 20 to 30 years ago and the animals overbrowsed the habitat to the point where the region can no longer support as many deer."
The studies also suggest that hunters have difficulty relating their experience in the field to a map. When hunters whose movements had been tracked by GPS were asked to indicate on a map where they had hunted, many got it wrong.
"I want to make it clear we're not saying it is hunters alone who lack these skills," Diefenbach said. "There have been other studies done on the recreational movements of hikers and skiers. Most humans seem to have difficulty transcribing their movements on a map after the fact. It appears to be a common navigational problem."
Diefenbach believes that even though some hunters may feel uncomfortable about his study results, it's important knowledge for managers to have.
"I think there is a positive message here. Now we have some real data about where hunters are hunting and where they are not," he said. "If we want a better distribution of hunters, we can use this knowledge to devise some strategies. At least now we have some real data. We don't have to go on hearsay when we allocate licenses and schedule seasons in these big woods habitats."




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.