HARRISBURG — Like the campaigns they’re running, Republican Mehmet Oz and Democrat John Fetterman clashed in their one and only debate in a confrontation that was heavier on attacks than substantive policy.
The pair began swinging at each other during the first question Tuesday evening, about what qualifies them to be a U.S. senator. Mr. Fetterman introduced what he called the “Oz Rule: If he’s on TV, he’s lying.” Mr. Oz accused him of “trying to get as many convicted murderers out of prison as possible.”
It was one of the highest-stakes debates in the country during this midterm election year, with control of the U.S. Senate hanging in the balance. A heavy security presence surrounded the television station where the debate took place. Police cordoned off side streets in the otherwise quiet neighborhood, where brick colonial homes line leafy sidewalks.
With just two weeks to go before Election Day in a race that is nearly deadlocked according to the latest polls, the highly anticipated debate offered Mr. Oz a chance to connect with voters in a state he’s only relatively recently moved to, gave Mr. Fetterman the chance to show he’s up to the job despite the stroke he suffered in May, and provided the opportunity to rebut attacks against them while delivering attacks of their own face-to-face.
Mr. Fetterman addressed the “elephant in the room” almost immediately.
“I had a stroke. He’s never let me forget it,” Mr. Fetterman said. “I might miss some words during this debate. It might knock me down but I’m going to keep getting back up.”
Read More
Around midnight Tuesday, Mr. Fetterman’s campaign announced that it has raised over $1 million since the debate ended at 9:00 p.m.
Mr. Fetterman used a monitor to read closed-captioned versions of the questions. Because of his stroke, Mr. Fetterman has trouble processing spoken words, though his doctors say he has no cognitive problems. Both candidates could see the monitor, though Mr. Oz’s campaign blocked a request by Mr. Fetterman’s to let reporters see the system. A Fetterman campaign spokesman accused Mr. Oz’s campaign of wanting to make it easier for “insane conspiracy theories” about what was on the monitors to spread online.
The former Braddock mayor and current lieutenant governor spoke haltingly at times, had difficulty stringing words together and mispronounced words in some instances during the hour-long, rapid-fire debate. Mr. Fetterman also said he wouldn’t release his full medical records for the sake of transparency, as Mr. Oz and other Republicans have demanded.
“For me, transparency is showing up,” something he said he does regularly in front of crowds of thousands of people during the campaign and Tuesday night on the debate stage, Mr. Fetterman said. “My doctor believes I am fit to be serving.”
Questions about Mr. Oz’s fitness to serve surround his long-running television show, during which he promoted unproven treatments. Doctors at Columbia University, where Mr. Oz is a faculty member, demanded in 2015 that the university kick him out for hawking what they called “quack treatments.”
Mr. Oz said his popular daytime show empowered people to take control of their health, and said he never recommended people take anything dangerous.
“It’s a television show like this is a television show,” Mr. Oz said. “People can run commercials.”
The candidates were given at most 60 seconds to answer questions from the two moderators at WHTM abc27’s studios.
One of the sharpest clashes of the night came over abortion rights, a key issue in the first federal election since the U.S. Supreme Court overturned Roe v. Wade and eliminated a constitutional right to abortion.
“I don’t want the federal government involved in that at all. Let states decide for themselves,” Mr. Oz said. Asked how he’d vote on a bill introduced by Republican Sen. Lindsey Graham that would enact a federal ban on abortions after 15 weeks, Mr. Oz didn’t directly answer. But, he added, “Any bill that violates what I said [about imposing a federal mandate on states], I am against.”
He also accused Mr. Fetterman of wanting to allow abortions “on the delivery table,” something Mr. Fetterman denied.
Mr. Fetterman said he supported codifying Roe’s abortion protections into federal law. That 1973 decision forbade banning abortions before a fetus could live on its own outside the womb, a threshold known as viability which usually occurs between 22 and 24 weeks into a pregnancy.
“If you believe the choice should be between you and your doctor, that’s what I fight for,” Mr. Fetterman said.
The two agreed, on the debate stage, about supporting fracking for natural gas in Pennsylvania, but evaded questions about past statements they’d made about the practice.
“I absolutely support fracking,” Mr. Fetterman said. Confronted with a 2018 quote saying he ‘doesn’t support fracking at all,’ Mr. Fetterman, after a pause, replied “I’ve always supported fracking.”
Oz, asked about a 2014 op-ed in which he said fracking shouldn’t be allowed until studies show it doesn’t harm people’s health, said he’s “been very consistent.”
“Fracking has been demonstrated — its very old technology — to be safe,” Mr. Oz said. ”It’s a lifeline for this commonwealth to build wealth.”
Like other Republican senate candidates around the country, Mr. Oz’s closing message in the campaign has zeroed in on crime.
Mr. Oz asked Mr. Fetterman to apologize to a black jogger he’d pulled a shotgun on one night near his home after hearing gunshots nearby. The jogger has alleged Mr. Fetterman pointed the gun at him, something Mr. Fetterman has denied, saying he only kept him there until police arrived.
Mr. Fetterman didn’t apologize on the debate stage Tuesday, saying the people in Braddock believe “it was me making a split decision to defend our community.”
“I ran to be mayor in 2005 to fight gun violence and that’s exactly what I did” in Braddock, which went more than five years without a murder committed by gun during his tenure, Mr. Fetterman said. “All he’s done is put a plan up on his website in the last 24 hours.”
Mr. Oz ducked a question about whether he would’ve supported a federal gun control law that passed this year, the first such measure to pass in decades. The senator both candidates are running to replace, retiring Republican Pat Toomey, voted in favor of the bill and had been the leading Republican senator on gun control since the Sandy Hook Elementary School shooting in 2012.
“There are parts of the bill that I like,” such as expanded background checks and increased funding for mental health treatment, Mr. Oz said.
Pressed on whether he’d have voted for or against it, Mr. Oz said, “I would’ve tried to improve the bill … I wasn’t there at the time.”
Similar to other Republicans running across the country, Mr. Oz played up the danger illegal immigration poses to this mid-Atlantic state, linking it to drug trafficking and resulting fentanyl overdoses, a particularly acute problem in Pennsylvania.
“It’s making every state a border state,” Mr Oz said, calling the situation at the border — where customs and border protection have had a record number of encounters with undocumented immigrants — “a catastrophe.”
Mr. Fetterman, whose wife Giselle was an undocumented immigrant, noted the company owned by Mr. Oz’s in-laws was once hit with a record fine for employing undocumented workers.
“I think he should sit this one out,” Mr. Fetterman said.
Running in a state with a large elderly population, Mr. Oz pushed back against the Fetterman campaign’s attacks that he would cut Social Security and Medicare by signing on to a plan by Republican Sen. Rick Scott, which would force the Congress to reauthorize every program every five years.
“No one’s going to touch it on my watch,” Mr. Oz said.
“He would support cutting Medicare,” Mr. Fetterman shot back. “It’s a fact.”
Mr. Oz also tried to capitalize on discontent with President Joe Biden’s student loan forgiveness plan by saying Mr. Fetterman’s plan for higher education is to shovel more money at it. Mr. Oz said the answer to soaring higher education costs is to cut mid-level workers at universities who bloat schools’ costs without affecting education.
Mr. Fetterman, who supports student loan forgiveness, said his opponent “loves free money when it’s a half-million dollar tax break on his mansion in Florida” or the house he recently purchased in Montgomery County. Asked to explain how he’d follow through on getting more resources to colleges, however, Mr. Fetterman had no answer beyond “providing the resources.”
In a rare moment of agreement, both candidates said they oppose expanding the U.S. Supreme Court, which became a minor cause among the political left after Justice Amy Coney Barrett’s confirmation in the waning days of the Trump administration.
“I don’t believe in that,” Mr. Fetterman said. “It’s not about changing the rules, it’s about acknowledging where we’re at.”
Mr. Oz said he would “never touch the makeup of the Supreme Court.”
But, he added Mr. Fetterman could make that possible because of his opposition to the filibuster. Conservatives have argued that the filibuster is a necessary mechanism that forces compromise and bipartisanship. Liberals argue it’s an arcane procedural rule that allows small minorities of senators to block legislation favored by the majority of the country.
“He wanted to bust the filibuster,” Mr. Oz said.
Mr. Fetterman jumped in: “That’s true.”
Mike Wereschagin: mwereschagin@post-gazette.com and @wrschgn





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.