On the steep Elkton Street in Elliott, weeds rise through the cracks of sidewalks and wrap around the boarded-up windows of abandoned homes.
Annette Schwartzmiller said the sight is a constant reminder of years of neglect.
“We're forgotten. Elliott, Sheraden, Esplen — we’re all forgotten,” the 67-year-old resident said as she scanned the scene from her front porch.
Discontent is bubbling in parts of Pittsburgh’s West End, where some residents say that they feel overlooked by city government and that their concerns about blight and public safety have gone unanswered for years.
Now, longtime Councilwoman Theresa Kail-Smith — a fierce advocate for her constituents who has a reputation for rebuking city administrators — is stepping down after 16 years, which included two terms as council president ending in January 2024.
That leaves District 2, separated physically from the halls of city government by rivers and rolling hills, with a contested City Council race for the first time since President Barack Obama’s first year in office.
Read More
Three candidates — Kim Salinetro, a Democrat and Ms. Kail-Smith’s chief of staff; Erin Koper, a Republican and community organizer in Elliott; and David Tessitor, an independent who entered the race late — are competing in a race that guarantees new leadership for the district.
Ms. Salinetro will almost certainly win without much fanfare — there are three times as many registered Democrats as Republicans in District 2, and Ms. Kail-Smith has run unopposed each of the three times she was up for re-election.
But the contested race is one of the few during this election cycle, aside from the race for mayor, that will bring someone new into city office.
That there is a Republican challenger at all in Ms. Koper — someone who gained national recognition when she spoke to a prime-time, national TV audience at the Republican National Convention in July 2024 — could be indicative of a movement that Republicans hope begins to challenge the Democratic dominance in Pittsburgh, which hasn’t seen a Republican council member for nearly 100 years.

Geographic divisions
Across the Monongahela and Ohio rivers from Downtown Pittsburgh, District 2 stretches from Mount Washington’s scenic overlooks to the far westward reaches of Fairywood. It’s a patchwork of neighborhoods that also include Sheraden, Crafton Heights, Elliott and Esplen — all bound together by narrow streets, aging infrastructure and a shared sense that they aren’t on City Hall’s radar.
“Nothing's ever done. I haven't seen anything big in our neighborhood,” said Ms. Schwartzmiller, who’s lived in the neighborhood her entire life. She recalled growing up with mom-and-pop shops all around her and neighborhood kids always outside.
Now, she said she doesn’t feel comfortable letting her grandchildren, ages 5 through 12, go trick-or-treating in the neighborhood.
“It's not the same neighborhood anymore. You used to be able to walk down the street and not be afraid,” she said.
The district’s neighborhoods are also economically stressed.
The median household income for the whole district is slightly over $35,000, Pittsburgh census data from 2022 shows, and 1 in 6 residents lives below the poverty line.
For decades, residents say, they have called 311 to complain about overgrown lots, vacant homes and crumbling streets.
Several told the Post-Gazette that they go through the same process of calling various departments for months before an issue gets resolved.
That feeling of neglect has shaped District 2’s politics for years.
Ms. Kail-Smith, who has represented the district since 2009 and served two terms as council president, has built a reputation as a hands-on problem-solver, advocating for infrastructure improvements and youth programs for her constituents.
Several residents told the Post-Gazette they’re satisfied with how she’s responded to their complaints and advocated to get things done.
“Every time I’ve called that office, they’ve assisted me,” Ms. Schwartzmiller said.
Ms. Kail-Smith, who grew up in the district, has also been one of council’s more independent voices, frequently clashing with progressive members and Mayor Ed Gainey on housing, zoning and public safety issues.
Most recently, she was one of four council members who voted to approve amendments introduced by District 8 Councilwoman Erika Strassburger that would make inclusionary zoning requirements for developments optional, a proposal that divided the council and drew controversy city-wide.
Ms. Kail-Smith’s moderate takes have made her well-liked and respected throughout her district. She won re-election in uncontested races time and time again.
“Running against her would have been extremely difficult for any candidate,” said Jason Richey, chair of the Allegheny County Republican Committee. “Her decision to step down created a perfect opening for a Republican to step in.”

An upper hand
While Democrats hold a commanding advantage across Pittsburgh, District 2 stands out as not quite as intensely blue as some other areas.
It has one of the highest percentages of Republicans in the city, with 20.5% registered Republicans compared to 62.2% Democrats, according to Allegheny County voter registration data.
It’s a close second to District 4, which includes neighborhoods such as Beechview, Carrick and Brookline.
By comparison, registered Democrats make up 69% of the city as a whole, and Republicans account for 13%.
In recent local and national elections, Democratic candidates have still dominated, but with slightly smaller margins in District 2 compared to the rest of the city.
For example, in 2021, Mr. Gainey won District 2 by just 6 percentage points, topping Republican Tony Moreno 52.7% to 46.7%.
And in the 2024 presidential election, Kamala Harris beat President Donald Trump 70% to 28% there, compared to her citywide margin of 76% to 21%.
At least half a dozen residents in the district told the Post-Gazette they would vote for a candidate based on how well they align with their values, regardless of political party affiliation.
“I am a Democrat, but I've certainly crossed party lines. I don’t stick to one party,” said a retired police officer who lives in Banksville and asked not to be named. He said he voted for Mr. Moreno in the 2021 mayoral election.
Mr. Richey said Ms. Kail-Smith’s seat opening offered the “potential to capitalize on shifting voter sentiment.
“More voters are expressing frustration with one-party dominance and are open to new leadership,” he said.

The Democratic candidate
Hoping to follow in her boss’s footsteps and keep the seat Democratic is Ms. Salinetro, who has worked in Ms. Kail-Smith’s office for more than a decade as chief of staff. In May’s primary election, she received more than 4,000 votes. Ms. Koper, the Republican candidate, got 639.
A lifelong resident of the district — born and raised in Sheraden, now living in Banksville — Ms. Salinetro says her experience inside City Hall is what District 2 needs.
“Effective city council leadership requires understanding both the technical nature of city government and grassroots needs,” she wrote in her campaign launch post last December.
Some of Ms. Salinetro’s priorities include increasing the city’s police force, clearing abandoned structures and expanding access to green spaces, according to her campaign website. She’s also pushing for more development in the West End, including efforts to expand mixed-income housing.
Her campaign has been backed by the Allegheny-Fayette County Labor Council, the Pittsburgh Federation of Teachers and the Fraternal Order of Police Lodge 1, among others.
At least half a dozen residents told the Post-Gazette they plan to vote for her simply because of her background and relationships within city government.
“I've dealt with Kim a lot, so I think Kim is a go-getter,” Ms. Schwartzmiller said.
It’s an apprentice system that has worked well for other council members in the past.
Current Councilman Bob Charland served as the chief of staff for former Councilman Bruce Kraus and ran for his seat once Mr. Kraus retired.
Ms. Strassburger had been chief of staff for Dan Gilman before running for the seat herself.

The Republican candidate
Ms. Koper, 44, represents a stark contrast to Ms. Salinetro’s path.
A Republican and community organizer from Elliott, Ms. Koper gained local and national attention in summer 2024 when she spoke at the Republican National Convention in Chicago. There, she blamed Mr. Gainey; U.S. Rep. Summer Lee, D-Swissvale; and Allegheny County Executive Sara Innamorato for “demoralizing and disrespecting our police while unleashing criminals into our communities."
Ms. Koper has described her district as beset by abandoned homes and rising crime, centering her campaign on public safety, infrastructure and restoring government “accountability and transparency.”
“In recent years, I had a front row seat to the chaos caused by Democrats and their soft-on-crime policies,” she told the crowd at the RNC.
Though her path to victory is steep, Ms. Koper’s candidacy marks a rare challenge from the GOP in Pittsburgh. And District 2, with it’s rare status as a district with a substantial bloc of registered Republicans, has at least put the race for Ms. Kail-Smith’s seat into conversations around the city.
She, too, has prioritized issues such as neighborhood blight and economic investment throughout her campaign. She also wants to “demand accountability and transparency in the allocation of taxpayer dollars to ensure funding benefits the community directly,” she writes on her campaign website.
The GOP leadership is keeping an eye on how her effort is received.
“This race represents a critical opportunity to build momentum for Republicans in the city of Pittsburgh,” Mr. Richey said. “We plan on becoming more and more competitive in the coming years.”
Incumbent Democrats are running in the other three city council races on the ballot Tuesday and figure to win their re-election bids.
In District 4, Republican Tracy Larger is challenging Anthony Coghill for the area that covers the city’s southern neighborhoods.
Council President Dan Lavelle is facing Republican challenger Jacob Dumont in District 6, which represents a swath of the North Side, Downtown and the Hill District.
Ms. Strassburger is running unopposed for her position in District 8, which covers Shadyside, Squirrel Hill and parts Oakland.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.