In an election that saw a historic realignment of the national political map as well as historic disaffection among Pennsylvania Democrats, Allegheny County held the line. Turnout was down somewhat, but otherwise election results were static compared to other areas of the state, a bulwark of sorts in a sea of change.
President-elect Donald Trump’s most striking accomplishment in Western Pennsylvania was growing his vote margin in the more conservative counties surrounding Allegheny — in some by more than three points.
Vice President Kamala Harris won Allegheny County with 59.2% of the vote, according to unofficial returns. Trump won 39.4% of the vote. Joe Biden’s performance against him in 2020 was better, but not by much: 59.4% for Biden and 39% for Trump.
But in an election the experts long predicted would be decided on the margins, small shifts make a difference. Those shifts occurred across the state.
In Allegheny County, Ms. Harris got about 10,000 fewer votes than Biden did here in 2020, but she outperformed Hillary Clinton by more than 50,000 — in contrast to Philadelphia, where Ms. Harris got more than 32,000 fewer votes than Ms. Clinton in 2016.
Allegheny County saw lower voter turnout overall — by nearly 14,000 voters — than in 2020, when Trump lost to Mr. Biden, but the apparent drop in turnout may simply reflect the fact provisional, overseas and military ballots had not yet been counted, election officials said. Numbers in this story are based on returns as of Friday afternoon. While Trump got about 3,000 fewer overall votes in Allegheny County than he did in 2020, he did make tiny gains — about 0.7 points in Pittsburgh — while making larger inroads against Vice President Kamala Harris in outer areas, like a 2.8 point increase in Forward.
Read More
Trump’s victory in Tuesday’s election was a multi-part equation — increasing his margins in more conservative parts of the state, including southwestern Pennsylvania; benefiting from lower Democratic support in traditional strongholds like Philadelphia and the collar counties. He also made tiny gains in some precincts of traditionally blue enclaves like Allegheny County, helping to hold the line on overall losses.
Trump’s gains in southwestern Pennsylvania were most dramatic in Fayette, Washington, and Beaver counties, where he increased his margins by roughly 4.6 points, 3.6 points and 3.2 points respectively. He also improved in Armstrong, Westmoreland and Butler, although by a smaller amount: 0.3 points in Armstrong and 0.1 points in both Westmoreland and Butler.
He won all those counties outright, but by more than he did four years ago.
Ben Wren, a longtime GOP political consultant in southwestern Pennsylvania, said that Democrats did about as well as could be expected in Allegheny County — in recent cycles, getting 60% of the vote is usually a good sign that elections are going well for the party statewide.
But that wasn’t the case this time, Mr. Wren said.
“Allegheny County kind of stayed static, especially compared to the rest of the state,” Mr. Wren said. “I think there has been a leftward shift in Allegheny County, and you see that with the ascension of candidates like Sara Innamorato and Summer Lee and Matt Dugan … and Ed Gainey, but I think that’s caused a counteraction in the outlying counties.”
Ms. Harris did do better in some places outside of Pittsburgh than Mr. Biden had in 2020. In Aleppo, she improved by about 3.3 points. In O’Hara, she picked up about 6.3 points.
Those trends become even more stark when you compare Trump’s win in 2016 against Ms. Clinton to his performance against Ms. Harris in 2024.
The biggest shift was in Trafford, a borough of just over 3,200 people: in 2016, Trump beat Ms. Clinton by 27 points there. In 2024, Ms. Harris beat Trump by 8 points — a 35-point swing in eight years towards the Democrats.
Haysville, where around 90 people reside, saw a similar blue shift. In 2016, Trump beat Ms. Clinton by about 17 points. This year, Ms. Harris won one of Allegheny County’s smallest municipalities by 7 points — a 24-point swing.
Larger municipalities have seen blue shifts, as well. Trump won Bethel Park, a borough of about 32,000 on the southern edge of the county, by 8 points in 2016. In 2024, Ms. Harris won by 1 point — a 9-point swing.
In Upper St. Clair, a township of just under 20,600 west of Bethel Park, Trump won by 3 points there in 2016, while Ms. Harris won by 9 points this year — a 12-point swing. McCandless, a township in northwestern Allegheny County, went to Trump by 5 points eight years ago. By 2024, Ms. Harris had won by a 7-point margin, a swing of a dozen points.
Despite those shifts, some Democrats, including the vice president, were likely hurt by a drop in turnout in the overall election: roughly 74.8% this year (as of Friday) versus 77.1% in 2020. And in both elections, turnout was lower in precincts in Pittsburgh and its inner suburbs versus the outer reaches of the county.
Mike Butler, a longtime Democratic consultant in Pittsburgh, said that since the last presidential election was during a global pandemic, more people might have had more time to cast a ballot.
Mr. Butler, like Mr. Wren, said there were more shifts across the state than in Allegheny County — for instance, in Philadelphia, where there was a drop in voter turnout, and in Centre County, which Ms. Harris carried by about 2.2 points this year, but which Mr. Biden won by roughly 4.8 points in 2020.
It’s perhaps surprising that Trump “had room to grow” in some counties around Allegheny, given his already strong voter bases there, he said.
But some Democrats did have some success, including Rep. Chris Deluzio, who won re-election against Republican state representative Rob Mecuri by more than 7 points, in what had been billed one of the most competitive congressional races in the state.
Part of that may be the fact that it’s easier to run a race in a congressional district than in a presidential election, Mr. Butler said. Regardless, campaigns like Deluzio’s could help Democrats at higher-level races in the future, he added.
“When there are elections like this, when somebody is bucking the trend, the powers that be start looking at, is there something there we can emulate?” Mr. Butler said.
In some of the Allegheny’s suburbs and its surrounding counties, Trump’s victories could perhaps be attributed to voters’ positions on the economy. But in some areas, anecdotal evidence indicated just how divided local residents remain on issues like abortion, the economy, and immigration.
A snapshot of voters in Upper St. Clair, another blue-shift region that Trump won by 3 points in 2016 but Ms. Harris won by 9 in 2024, showed that divide.
Frank Cherup, 67, said that he was focused on women’s reproductive rights when casting a ballot for Ms. Harris. His recently married daughter was on his mind as he voted at Fort Couch Middle School. He also liked her positions on immigration and climate change.
“I’m concerned about her and my grandkids,” he said, concerning reproductive rights. “I just want to make sure they’re safe.”
Thomas Gallagher, 62, sees things differently. Like Mr. Cherup, he voted with younger Americans in mind — but believes Trump is better equipped to handle immigration and economic issues, given the last four years.
“I like that people have to be vetted at the border, not an open border,” he said. “As far as the economy, the American Dream is becoming unattainable because of inflation. It's unacceptable.”
But even with all the election results and data currently available, more time for analysis will help create a fuller picture, said Christopher Borick, a political science professor at Muhlenberg College.
Large swings in certain municipalities from 2016 to 2024 could be because of educational attainment levels in those areas, Mr. Borick said. But without a more thorough review, it’s hard to say why those swings occurred, why results in Allegheny County remained largely similar from 2020 to 2024, or why Trump did better in some of the surrounding counties.
“It’ll be interesting once we get deep down into granular data, at the ward levels, and a more complete exit poll picture, to diagnose what happened here,” Mr. Borick said.
NOTE: This story has been updated to note that the apparent drop in turnout may simply reflect the fact provisional, overseas and military ballots had not yet been counted as of Friday afternoon.
Post-Gazette staff writers Mike Wereschagin and Ciara McEneany contributed.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.