With Election Day looming, all eyes are on Pennsylvania’s counting of ballots. The state, with its 19 Electoral College votes, is widely expected to be the must-win linchpin to either candidate making it to the Oval Office.
But don’t expect results in close races late Tuesday.
Pennsylvania Secretary of State Al Schmidt said it likely will be days before close races can be called — including for president.
Polls show the presidential race between Vice President Kamala Harris and former President Donald Trump is a statistical dead heat. But because of the number of mail-in ballots, the complicated process required to count them, and state law — which prohibits election officials from starting the vote count until 7 a.m. on Election Day — it’s unlikely the race in Pennsylvania will be called on Tuesday night.
Mr. Schmidt has said it could be days before all the mail-in ballots are processed statewide. He has urged patience while election workers accurately count ballots from all eligible voters.
“The closer the race, the longer it takes the media to call the race, as it has always, ever been — with mail ballots, before mail ballots,” Mr. Schmidt said.
Read More
How long it will take counties to count mail-in ballots depends on a multitude of factors: how many workers each county has, how many mail-in ballots they need to process, and what equipment they have to help with that.
But Allegheny County will not be the reason for any delay, officials say.
Allegheny County officials are confident that they will be able to have all in-person and mail-in ballots counted and processed by midnight Tuesday. That’s because they have the personnel and equipment needed to help open and sort envelopes and scan hundreds of mail-in ballots.
All of that activity will occur in a large warehouse on Pennsylvania Avenue on Pittsburgh’s North Side. It has been heavily secured in recent weeks, and Elections Division Manager David Voye said during a media tour last week that county police will have a significant presence safeguarding the facility on Election Day.
The warehouse’s location also helps with the mail-in ballot processing, said Assistant Division Manager Chet Harhut: “The Postal hub for Pittsburgh is across the street,” he said. “So all the ballots come there, and on a daily basis, we coordinate with them, get them from their loading dock and bring them in.”
Other jurisdictions might take longer to count ballots, including Philadelphia, the largest in the state. The Philadelphia City Commissioners — a three-member, bipartisan board that oversees election operations — recently voted to allow election workers to use newer equipment to help with mail-in ballot processing.
But it’s not only about the equipment, Allegheny County officials said. It’s also knowing how to use it, and being able to work together.
“This is our eighth election doing this now,” Mr. Harhut said. “And so with everything, you tweak this, you tweak that, you refine your process. And so it's getting faster and faster every time, for sure. And we've gotten some new equipment, which helps, too.”
Allegheny County also presses as many available non-emergency county employees as they can find into election work counting ballots.

On Election Day, more than 230 workers from various county divisions and departments will converge at the warehouse to help with pre-canvassing mail-in ballots. That’s in addition to more than 6,900 poll workers who will assist voters at more than 1,300 precincts at 766 physical locations around the county.
Patrick Dowd, CEO of Pittsburgh’s Environmental Charter School, has helped with election operations since the 2020 general election. Mr. Dowd is the former chief operating officer and then acting director of the county’s health department.
He worked at the elections warehouse helping pre-canvass mail-in ballots in 2020, 2021 and the primary in 2022. Since then, he’s been an “elections lead,” meaning he helps monitor a group of polling places on Election Day, helping them work through any logistical issues that may arise.
He said helping the elections division with operations was a simple choice. During the COVID-19 pandemic, his department leaned on election workers and other staff to help run vaccine clinics and other related tasks, he said. So he sees helping the Elections Division not only as a civic duty, but as a way to build camaraderie among other county workers.
“We clearly understood one of the most important functions for our county, and every county, is to provide a fair, safe and honest election … in a democracy, this is an all-hands-on-deck moment,” Mr. Dowd said.
After the county Board of Elections met last month, Republican Councilman Sam DeMarco criticized Philadelphia’s ballot-counting system, which he said would add unnecessary delays to the process.
“Philadelphia, they do their stuff backwards,” he said, explaining that elections officials there wait to count mail-in ballots after the polls close. “That doesn’t allow them to do the pre-canvassing and all the other stuff that we do, which is an issue.”
But Seth Bluestein, a Republican who serves as one of the city commissioners in Philadelphia, disputed that claim.
“Unfortunately, Sam has a misunderstanding of the ballot counting process in Philadelphia. I want to make sure our voters don’t have the same misunderstanding,” Mr. Bluestein wrote in an email.
“At 7:00 a.m. on Election Day, Philly begins pre-canvassing all mail ballots received prior to the last update to the poll books. Only ballots received in the last few days get reconciled against the poll books to ensure only one vote is counted for those voters.”
Philadelphia has about 155,000 more registered voters than Allegheny County, and yet, according to the state, Allegheny has received about 20,000 more mail-in ballot requests than the state’s largest city.
Even after all the ballots are counted, there could be delays due to election deniers becoming involved with the certification process in swing states.
Informing Democracy, a nonprofit focused on the voting and certification processes, has flagged 16 swing-state counties that it estimates have enough election deniers in office to stop or deadlock certification. Six of those counties — Berks, Bradford, Butler, Fayette, Lancaster, and Northampton — are in Pennsylvania, more than any other state.
Also of concern are county officials who have not explicitly disputed election results in the past but could be swayed to help deniers subvert democracy, said Lindsey Miller, the director of strategic research at Informing Democracy. The nonprofit has listed an additional 109 counties across 11 states that are at some risk of being undermined by deniers.
David Becker, executive director and founder of the nonpartisan, non-profit Center for Election Innovation & Research, said he isn’t quite sure why Pennsylvania has become ground zero for election-related challenges and lawsuits. One reason, perhaps, is because the state has 19 electoral votes, the most of any swing state.
There are two major concepts to watch for as election-related lawsuits are filed, Mr. Becker said. First, the question, “Why now?” should be asked in each case, meaning the timing of the suit, he said.
The other question is whether the claims can actually be used by the courts to rectify problems in the post-election period — or whether they are being used as “fuel” for claims of a stolen election, he added.
“Watch after the election and see how many claims are revived — claims that have been defeated in courts time and time and time again,” Mr. Becker told reporters during a news briefing Thursday. “See how many of those claims are revived in the post-election period. That will tell you a lot about what the possible intent might have been prior to the election.”
Pennsylvania is one of the most decentralized states in the country when it comes to election administration, which limits Mr. Schmidt’s powers, said Jenny Gimian, director and senior policy council at Informing Democracy. In this unusual dynamic, individual counties can create their own policies where state law is silent, she said.
An example of this is curing mail-in votes, as the state does not have an applicable law.
The Pennsylvania Supreme Court has put on hold until after this election a case it is currently hearing out of Washington County that will decide whether counties have to notify voters if they discover a defect with their ballots before Election Day.
Some counties, like Allegheny, go out of their way to notify voters and allow them to cast provisional ballots to fix the issue. Others do not, which may result in a noticeable variation in the number of provisional ballots by county, said Ms. Gimian.
Peter Bondi, the managing director of Informing Democracy, said delays in vote counting in counties like Philadelphia would present “a window for misinformation,” but voters should keep their faith in the system.
“The most important thing to keep in mind, regardless of how long the process takes, is that you know the votes have been cast,” he said.
“By the time polls have closed, the election is decided. We won’t know the count yet and need to ensure that there is patience to let the votes be counted, but the outcome is not going to change after the voters have made their decision.”
In this year’s election, it is important to value accuracy over speed when it comes to processing ballots, said Ms. Gimian.
“A delay is a sign, honestly, that they are taking the time and care to count all of the votes in a secure fashion,” she said. “It’s not a sign that things are going wrong — it’s a sign that people take this seriously and are doing it correctly and with dedication and following all of the steps to get it done.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.