With the presidential race in Pennsylvania deadlocked for months, the undecided voter has been the Holy Grail — not only for the candidates, but also for pollsters and the media.

The number of undecideds is small; pollsters have put the percentage in single digits. The latest nationwide CNN poll puts it at 2%.

Yet these are the people who could decide the election in Pennsylvania and for the nation — in an election the experts say will be determined on the margins, this could be the most important margin of all.

In August the Post-Gazette went in search of undecided voters: Who were they and what were they thinking? And then we followed up with them last week. We conducted the search in Erie County.

Advertise with us

If Pennsylvania is the state to win in this election, Erie County is how to get there — undecided voters there could be the key to the Oval Office.

Erie County is considered a presidential bellwether because it flipped from voting for Barack Obama in 2008 and 2012 to Donald Trump in 2016; then, in 2020, it switched back to the Democratic column, helping to send President Joe Biden to the White House. The winning margin in Erie in both elections was less than 2%.

U.S. Sen. John Fetterman recently rallied a crowd for Kamala Harris at the Erie Insurance Arena with the line: “If you win Erie, you win Pennsylvania and you’re the next president.”

When Trump visited Erie on Sept. 29, he invited U.S. Senate candidate Dave McCormick onto the stage, and Mr. McCormick told him: “This is the place where we're going to retire Joe Biden and Kamala Harris and send you back to the White House, right here in Pennsylvania… right here in Erie. Erie, the bellwether, right here.”

If the 2024 election will be decided on the margins, one those margins is likely to be undecided voters in purple places like Erie.

Advertise with us

To find the undecideds, the Post-Gazette focused on people registered as independent or unaffiliated — the least likely to have strong affiliations based on party and arguably the more likely to be undecided.

Berwood Yost, head of the Franklin & Marshall poll, said “The real gain [in registration numbers] since 2020 is non-affiliated voters… The question is ‘How does that registration translate into political identity?’ and it isn’t clear.”

He said, “You can make the argument that these are the people that will decide the election.”

At the beginning of August, the Post-Gazette used public voter rolls to reach out to registered independent and unaffiliated voters across Erie, from the lakeside city to the rural surrounding areas, months before the election. We made more than 240 calls. The vast majority of people — about 90% — either didn’t pick up the phone or declined to comment. Others answered and shared their thoughts.

Most had already made up their minds, even though Ms. Harris had just become the Democratic candidate.

Advertise with us

Some, like Leah Humphries, were thrilled with Ms. Harris.

“I think she’s amazing and she’s a breath of fresh air,” said Ms. Humphries, 56, a resident of the Fairview suburb right outside the city. Last week that opinion remained. Ms. Humphries said, “She’s been incredible.” Ms. Humphries said she used to vote Republican, but “that changed with Donald Trump… He’s awful, and he’s an idiot, and there’s no way.”

Others, like Michael Vickey, were more focused on voting against Trump.

“The man is insane and has absolutely no business being the leader of any country,” said Mr. Vickey, 71, a resident of the more rural area of the county.

“My mother was a German resident, and her family moved in the late 1920s,” said Mr. Vickey. “I’m very sensitive to what’s happening now because it seems to me like a repeat.”

Advertise with us

He said, “I’d elect my neighbor before I elect Trump.”

Still others, like Donald Smith, were casting a Trump vote, vehemently.

Mr. Smith, 49, who also lives in a more rural area of the county, said the Democratic Party has “gone so far left it's become unrecognizable,” and last week, he said “if anything, Harris has gotten worse” since she ascended to the top of the ticket in August.

“What a hack and a phony she is,” he said. “I’m even more upset with her than before.”

Mr. Smith said she is “having the media run interference and cover for her… it’s just so bad, so bad… I’ve never seen the bias in the media as bad as it is now. It’s dangerous how biased the media is because it’s divided the country.”

Advertise with us

Only three of the people we talked to in August were undecided.

Elizabeth Whitmire, a 55-year-old resident of Downtown Erie, had registered as an independent after losing confidence in Mr. Biden and his administration. She knew she would be voting but wasn’t confident how.

In August, she was something like “98%” sure Trump was off the table, citing anxiety as a woman with a disability and her employment for an immigration nonprofit. She had her fingers crossed for a “third viable option” and was interested to learn more about Ms. Harris, who she felt didn’t have a clear stance on much besides abortion.

“It would be nice to know where she really stands on some of these issues,” she said at the time. “I need to feel like when she speaks, I trust her.”

Last week, Ms. Whitmire immediately answered that she had “absolutely” made up her mind and it’s not for the former president — she said to put it that way.

Advertise with us

“Several things are true now that weren’t true in August,” she said. “One is that I am appalled, daily, by how Trump makes things up and gets his base to believe them.”

Ms. Whitmire said that even though she doesn’t love all of Ms. Harris’s policies, particularly in the Middle East, Trump has continued to “terrify” her, including in his threats to cut the social services she depends on. His running mate, Ohio Sen. JD Vance, with his changing stance on Trump, has similarly pushed her to the Democratic ticket, she said.

Yet much has stayed the same for Ms. Whitmire since August. While living in one of the poorest ZIP codes in the country, she said she has not heard a plan from either side to combat prices going up, or pathways to citizenship for the people she works with day to day.

“Frankly, I wish we had a third viable choice,” she said. “I feel from the comments of Vice President Harris she at least is more aware of what the issues are than the other party, though I’m not sure she really has a plan to fix it.”

William Diefenbach, 74, a “semi-retired” neurosurgeon living in the city of Erie, came to be an independent from the conservative side of politics. He followed the curve of the wider county in recent elections, voting for Trump in 2016 and Biden in 2020.

Advertise with us

This year, Mr. Diefenbach is joining Ms. Whitmire in what he calls an “anti-Trump vote,” a decision he came to in early October. Back in August, he wasn’t so sure. He knew he liked Republican policies better, but just couldn’t stand Trump as an individual.

Mr. Diefenbach had said he wouldn’t vote if it was a Biden-Trump rematch and was waiting to see what Ms. Harris’s platform was, though his hopes weren’t high. Months later, he doesn’t think much has changed.

“I’m still waiting for her to really try to break through and to take really good command and come up with decent policies,” he said, noting that a source of hope for him is looking back to former presidents, like Harry Truman and Lyndon Johnson, who went from being vice presidents with little promise to being powerful presidents. “The question is, can she do the same?”

Though he sees her handling of the border as a bad start, Trump, he said, “poisons everything he touches.” Though he agrees with Trump’s economic policies, concern over Project 2025 and “autocratic control” will be more important to Mr. Diefenbach when filling out his ballot.

“It's a tough choice — it really is a no-choice,” he said. “It’s a vote that's anti-Trump opposed to pro-Harris. I can live with myself that way.”

Advertise with us

Ms. Whitmire and Mr. Diefenbach, among many other voters, described the political split in Erie as one down city lines. Just as elsewhere in Pennsylvania, the city electorate votes blue, and things turn red past the suburbs.

“When I drive 15 mins outside of the city, all I see are Trump flags and Trump signs for hours,” Ms. Whitmire said, who added that she’s seen a Democratic lean in day-to-day interactions but knows immediate family and friends voting for Trump.

Trent Mason, 45, remains undecided — one of just 2% of likely voters nationwide who have yet to choose a candidate. Mr. Mason, who works in the health and human services field, had no idea how he would be voting on Aug. 6 – and he was similarly undecided over two months later.

“I just keep looking at their websites, I’m trying to watch as many interviews as I can,” he said last week. “It might be a ballot box decision for me.”

In August, Mr. Mason said that Ms. Harris’s candidacy was a “reset” button of sorts that would allow him to give both candidates a chance. His biggest voting issue was the economy, he said, because of his family.

Advertise with us

“[The economy is] affecting me directly more than the border or abortion rights … I don’t think about that as much as my pocketbook, my job, my children getting jobs,” he said.

Mr. Mason wanted to be won over by ideas, not a party.

Just days out from the election, he’s still waiting.

He’s attracted somewhat by Trump’s positions on investment and foreign policy, but turned off by the Jan. 6 insurrection and that Trump “can’t keep his mouth shut.” He thinks Ms. Harris will remain more committed to caring about the middle class, but he is concerned by her stance on the border and inaction as the sitting vice president.

He’s disgusted and embarrassed, he said, that these are the choices: “These are the best we have? This is the best and the brightest?” He called it “a cavalcade of narcissistic clowns.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Mason is repelled by the notion of voting for the lesser of two evils — but is also sensitive to the argument that writing in a protest vote is a wasted vote.

“I just can’t imagine why we don’t have younger more energetic candidates who have a greater stake in the game,” he said.

“I’m just going to show up in the moment and decide which is right.”

Post-Gazette staff writer Adam Babetski contributed to this report.