Kamala Harris needs to win Philadelphia County by at least 600,000 votes to offset the returns from the rest of the Commonwealth in order to win Pennsylvania on Nov. 5, said former Philadelphia Mayor Michael Nutter during a Columbia University panel discussion of battleground states Wednesday afternoon.
Mr. Nutter, who is now a professor of urban and public affairs at Columbia, said that Ms. Harris will also need to run up her totals in Philadelphia’s four “collar counties” — Montgomery, Bucks, Chester, and Delaware. Hillary Clinton won all four counties in 2016 but didn’t get enough votes to pad her lead, which sank her in Pennsylvania, he said.
“If Trump keeps Vice President Harris under 60 [percent] in those four [counties]…'Houston, we have a problem,’” he said.
Mr. Nutter served as the Mayor of Philadelphia from 2008 to 2016 and was one of several academics from across the country brought together to talk about Pennsylvania and North Carolina — two likely swing states in the upcoming election — on a panel hosted by Columbia University’s School of International and Public Affairs.
One area where the Harris campaign has been slipping is its reach with Black men.
In a New York Times/Siena College poll, 70% of Black men supported Ms. Harris, compared to 83% of Black women. In 2020, 85% of Black men supported Mr. Biden in the same poll.
Read More
Mr. Nutter suggested that Democrats should turn to Philadelphia Mayor Cherelle Parker, who was inaugurated earlier this year as the first woman and Black woman to hold the office, to help campaign for Ms. Harris. Ms. Parker was able to build the strong coalition of Black men that Ms. Harris is seeking, he said.
“The most consistent bloc of voters on the Democratic side are Black women, who just figure stuff out and understand, ultimately, self-interest,” he said. “As Democrats, we have to take some responsibility for the… lack of attention…with Black men.”
On the other hand, the Harris campaign has been making inroads with Latino voters in Pennsylvania and North Carolina. Polling suggests that 77% of Pennsylvania’s Latino population supports Ms. Harris, compared to 69% voting for Mr. Biden in 2020, said Voto Latino CEO and MSNBC contributor María Teresa Kumar.
Berks County, a county with a sizable Latino population on the border of Montgomery and Chester counties, is a potential bellwether for the rest of the state’s Latino turnout, said Berwood Yost, the director of the Center for Opinion Research at Franklin & Marshall College.
“If there are issues with Hispanic voters in this state, we're going to see that show up in the margins in Berks County,” he said. “It's likely a county that Trump will win, but if he doesn't, he wins by less than last time, I think that’s a good signal for the Harris campaign.”
Mr. Yost said that the Democrats’ lead in registered voters in Pennsylvania has decreased from 1.2 million in 2000 to around 200,000 today, meaning that elections are naturally going to be more hotly contested. Even still, he was surprised that three-term incumbent Democratic Senator Bob Casey, a “known commodity,” was running the closest race of his political career against challenger Dave McCormick.
There will be a small, but potentially significant group of “split-ticket” voters this year: Around 2% of Trump supporters view Mr. McCormick as a “Republican in Name Only,” or RINO, and intend to vote for Mr. Casey, Mr. Yost said.
Mr. Yost said he was surprised by the state of the presidential polling and theorized that voters who have “nostalgia for a past that maybe didn’t exist” under Trump are blaming their problems on Mr. Biden and Ms. Harris just because they are currently in office.
When asked about why the presidential race was so close, Mr. Nutter expressed his bewilderment that social media apps like TikTok were being treated as legitimate sources of information in the same way that legendary CBS News anchor Walter Cronkite used to be.
Trump’s “cult” of supporters is taking advantage of the Democrats’ muddled messaging and a rising tide of online disinformation to keep their candidate in the race, he said.
“The truth and facts have been so blurred that I think people just can't figure it out,” he said.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.