Fulfilling a promise he has been making for the past three months, former President Donald Trump on Saturday returned to the Butler Farm Show grounds, the scene of an attempted assassination in July, to greet tens of thousands of his supporters and honor the man who was killed at the previous rally.
Trump spoke at length about the shooting, the most he has said about it since the day it occurred. This time, he did it all from behind a sheet of bulletproof glass, and there was an edge to the crowd during the speech, which lasted about 90 minutes.
Drones hovered where they didn’t 84 days earlier, and the perimeter stretched past the AGR International building, where would-be assassin Thomas Crooks fired from July 13. No one milled around its base or sat in the shade cast by others in the complex of interconnected buildings.
“For 16 harrowing seconds during the gunfire, time stopped as this vicious monster unleashed evil from his sniper’s perch, not too far away,” Trump said. “By the hand of providence and the grace of God, that villain did not succeed. He did not stop our movement. He did not shake our unyielding resolve.”
On July 13, just minutes into Trump’s speech, Crooks, 20 of Bethel Park, opened fire, hitting the former president in the ear. In the ensuing gunfire, Corey Comperatore, a firefighter from Buffalo Township, was killed shielding his wife and daughters. Jim Copenhaver, 74, and David Dutch, 57, were both critically injured.
Secret Service snipers killed Crooks seconds later.
Read More
Conspiracy theories swirled in the aftermath of the shooting — some of the more extreme claimed that the shooting was organized by his opponents. Trump on Saturday didn’t outright agree, but gave fuel to the fire of that theory.
“They have slandered me, impeached me, indicted me and — who knows — maybe even tried to kill me,” he said. “But I never stopped fighting for you.
“Right here in Pennsylvania,” he continued. “We bled together. Nobody’s gone through what we’ve gone through.”
Dubbed by many of his supporters as “the big one,” Saturday's rally had the buzz and excitement of a big name concert. Thousands had arrived hours before the front gates opened at 10 a.m. And when they did, the crowds filled the field that houses the Butler Farm Show.
Spectators traveled from all over the region and as far away as California.
For many who packed the grounds, it was a pilgrimage of sorts — one that was less about politics and more about the symbolism they found in Trump’s return to the place he was shot.
And the entertainment. Aside from other politicians speaking, spectators were treated to a live painting done by artist activist Scott Lobaido, a skydiving show by the Frog-X Parachute Team, a flyover by the Trump Force One aircraft and a live performance of “God Bless the U.S.A.” by Lee Greenwood. And SpaceX and Tesla owner and billionaire Elon Musk repeatedly urged those in the crowd to vote on Nov. 5.
Trump plane flyover at Butler
In many ways, Saturday marked a typical Trump rally. The atmosphere was raucous, and crowds cheered, screamed and chanted “USA!”
When the former president took the stage at 6 p.m., he seemed to bask in the crowd’s applause a bit longer than usual. After a moment, the immigration chart that Trump was looking at when the shots were fired in July appeared on a screen.
“As I was saying,” Trump said, seemingly picking up where he left off in July.
More than during any speech since the Republican National Convention, his first after the assassination attempt, Trump began with a subdued tone and equated himself and his followers repeatedly, saying, “We’re a team.”
“Your hopes are my hopes, your dreams are my dreams, and I am fighting for your future every single day,” Trump told the crowd. “I will never quit, never bend, never break, never yield, even at death itself.”
‘Most secure place in America’
Multiple snipers could be seen on roofs around the complex.
A Pennsylvania State Police helicopter made passes over the venue as drones hovered overhead.
It was like night and day compared to July’s rally, said U.S Rep. Mike Kelly.
The Republican, whose district includes Butler County, was a few rows behind Trump when the shooting started July 13, and he is now co-leading the task force investigating the attempted assassination. He’s toured the buildings — those covered by snipers that day and those that weren’t — multiple times in the 2 ½ months since.
He called the grounds on Saturday “the safest, most secure place in America.”
The line outside the event started to form before sunrise. By 8 a.m., it stretched through a nearby field and into the distance. The gates opened, and it was a rush onto the grounds and to security: Magnetometers, law enforcement with hand-held metal detectors, and Secret Service agents went through every item in every bag or purse.

‘A tribute like no other’
Trump’s politics and policy seemed to take a backseat at the event. Many of the speakers who went on before Trump mentioned him mostly only in recounting the events of July 13 – often citing his “Fight, Fight, Fight” chant that he started after being shot. They opted instead to focus their speeches on the resiliency and spirit of the Butler community and honoring Mr. Comperatore.
“Eighty-four days ago on this very field, an assassin tried to fill our hearts with terror,” Ohio Sen. and vice presidential candidate JD Vance said Saturday. “We’re here to say we can’t be intimidated [and] we won’t be stopped.”
Behind Trump in the stands in the spot where Mr. Comperatore was shot sat his firefighter jacket bearing his last name and his helmet, surrounded by bouquets and members of his family.
Mr. Comperatore’s wife, daughters and his sister and her family were special guests at Saturday’s rally.
“Corey is not with us tonight and he should be,” Trump said. “In the face of murderous hate, Corey answered the most selfless kind of love. … It is love like Corey’s that is joining us to save our country.”
Trump asked the crowd to participate in a moment of silence at 6:11 p.m., the time the shooting occurred. At that moment, opera singer Christopher Macchio performed a live rendition of Ave Maria. Spectators filmed it on their cellphones while some, decked in Trump gear, cried.
“This is a tribute like no other, and he deserves it,” Trump said. “We will carry his memory in our hearts as long as we live.”
Trump said Saturday was a moment to not only “mark the triumph of the American spirit” but to also pay tribute to Mr. Comperatore and the first responders and law enforcement agencies that assisted that day and the day of a second assassination attempt in Florida last month.
Mr. Dutch was in attendance Saturday, but Mr. Copenhaver could not attend, according to Trump. He said both were “wonderful men” and “big Trump fans.”

Good v. Evil
Hours before Trump took the stage, a clear theme was set. It wasn’t just an election between Republicans and Democrats, it was a battle of good versus evil.
In speeches by Mr. Vance, Trump’s son Eric and his daughter-in-law Lara, they all cited this existential battle, making it clear that a vote for Trump was a vote to preserve “goodness.”
Trump, according to Mr. Vance, is the only thing between the American people and those who want to take away their “God-given rights to speak your mind without censorship, violence or persecution.”
“Trump must win to preserve the constitution,” Mr. Musk said during his speech. “He must win to preserve democracy in America.”
He encouraged people to “get everyone you know” to vote. “If they don’t, this will be the last election.”
Trump said he was “on a mission to rescue this country from a very failed and corrupt” administration.
He claimed that during his administration, the U.S. had the “greatest economy in history” and that should he win in November, he’ll deliver on that and more.
“Four years ago, the entire world respected us and now they laugh at us,” Trump said. “We can’t have them laugh at us.”
He promised to make America a “nation that builds things, makes things better.”


‘Hand of God’
The attempted assassination in July supercharged the religious element in the Trump campaign, and the return to Butler took on the aspect of a pilgrimage for many.
Renee White, 57, made the journey from Newland, N.C. She said she was seated in the bleachers behind Mr. Trump on July 13, and had the photo of TV footage from the scene saved on her phone.
She has attended more than 40 Trump rallies, but the one in July was different, she said.
"What happened in July is and was a God moment," said Ms. White, who is disabled and worked in multiple industries before retiring. "For me to be here for my community is important."
Two of her friends, Andrea and Olivia Noyes, agreed. They are 44-year-old twins and live in Naples, Fla., and Afton, N.Y.
"I would travel from the other end of the world to be here ... my body buzzes for days afterward," Andrea said.
Mr. Vance, in speaking with the crowd, reaffirmed the belief that God intervened in July.
“I truly believe God saved President Trump’s life that day,” Mr. Vance said. “God is with us right now and watches over this incredible nation every single day.”
It wasn’t just Trump who was touched by a force outside themselves, some said.
Dr. James Sweetland, who rendered aid to Mr. Comperatore, said that when the shots rang out in July, he hesitated.
“Then I heard a voice loud, clear, rich and reassuring, it said, ‘Go, go they need your help,’” he said Saturday. “I’m telling you right now that was the voice of God.”
Mike Boatman, from Evansville, Ind., who sat in the front row on July 13 and has attended more than 100 rallies for the former president, said, “I’m glad Trump’s come back here. Maybe it will do a lot of healing.”
Mr. Boatman said this rally felt “different” than the many others he’s attended. The line extended as far as the eye could see more than two hours before gates opened. He also noticed much more security than in July.
Shana DiTosto, from Sharon, attended the July 13 rally and said she was initially not planning to return Saturday because she was scared.
“But if (Trump’s) fighting for us, then we’re going to continue to fight for him,” Ms. DiTosto said. “This is a monumental day… I love this man, and there was no way I wasn’t going to come.”
Trump plans to continue to campaign in Pennsylvania this week, in Reading and Scranton, in a race with Democrat Kamala Harris that is neck-and-neck, according to polls.
Post-Gazette staff writers Steve Bohnel and Adam Babetski contributed.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.