A Saturday vehicle crash in Clairton involving Democratic state Senate candidate Nicole Ruscitto has generated questions and finger-pointing after the county’s Republican committee leader asked publicly “why no breathalyzer was administered” following the crash.

Ms. Ruscitto, a former Jefferson Hills borough council member, was not injured in the accident. She is running for election in the 37th Senate District against incumbent Republican Sen. Devlin Robinson. The contest has been dubbed a Pennsylvania “spotlight race” by the national Democratic Legislative Campaign Committee.

Alcohol is the topic that has caused the most political friction since the crash.

Word of the accident was posted on social media Saturday night by Sam DeMarco, chairman of the Allegheny County Republican Committee. Mr. DeMarco wrote on X that “the fact pattern calls for a more thorough investigation than we have been led to believe Clairton Police have conducted.” He laid out a chronology that said Ms. Ruscitto left a bar and restaurant in Clairton “and her car apparently traveled off the road, some distance along a hillside and sheared off a utility pole.”

Advertise with us

He asked that local police retain all evidence and camera footage tied to the crash and wrote, “Police need to explain why no breathalyzer was administered, given the circumstances.”

On Sunday, the Senate Democratic Campaign Committee posted on X that Ms. Ruscitto — following a long day of campaigning the previous day — “went to pick up dinner & was in a car accident when she swerved to avoid another car.”

On Thursday, SDCC spokesperson Brittany Crampsie said Mr. DeMarco was “making false accusations without any kind of proof, and it is a distraction from the real issues of this campaign.”

Ms. Crampsie said Ms. Ruscitto had one drink on Saturday inside Terrace Gardens, an establishment where she has watched football games and chatted with the owner. Terrace Gardens is about a half-mile from Ms. Ruscitto’s home.

“There was no reason to administer a breathalyzer,” Ms. Crampsie said.

Advertise with us

Clairton police came to the scene. Concerning Ms. Ruscitto, Ms. Crampsie said, “She calls her husband; he drives her home.”

Clairton Police Chief Robert Hoffman issued a statement that referred to the Republican committee statement as a “false allegation that the Clairton Police Department is ‘covering up’ the accident.” Chief Hoffman said the investigation is continuing, that witnesses should contact the department, and the department “remains steadfast in not involving itself in politics.”

The mayor, Richard Lattanzi, said he has known Chief Hoffman for many years, and he is a “stand-up guy.” He added that “politics is brutal.”

Attempts to reach Ms. Ruscitto were not successful.

Her opponent, Mr. Robinson, said it seemed to him that “everything is hush-hush” and the situation “doesn’t pass the smell test.”

Advertise with us

On Thursday, Mr. DeMarco said the committee has an attorney who will hand over to the district attorney’s office evidence the committee has obtained. Responding to the police chief’s words, Mr. DeMarco said “there was no allegation of cover-up” but rather an insistence that video and other evidence be preserved for a thorough investigation.

Rebecca Spangler, first assistant district attorney, said in generic terms that any evidence related to any alleged crime should be turned over to a local police department. She added, “If the individual believes there is a conflict in the handling of the investigation, they may raise that issue and it may be appropriate for a different police agency to investigate the matter.”

Steve Bohnel contributed.