With little more than two months remaining in the presidential race, the ad war for Pennsylvania’s 19 electoral votes already has surpassed what was spent during the entire 2020 presidential contest — and the most intense campaigning is still to come.

President Joe Biden and Democratic nominee Vice President Kamala Harris will campaign in Pittsburgh on Labor Day, which typically kicks off the hardest, most expensive part of the campaign season as voters intensify their focus on the candidates during the race’s frantic final months. Four years ago, almost two-thirds of all ad spending in Pennsylvania happened after the holiday.

But the historic shakeup atop the Democratic ticket this year has forced the two parties into a high-stakes push to redefine the campaign on their own terms.

Powered by a sudden surge from Ms. Harris and the first significant spending by Donald Trump’s campaign since the 2024 race began, an unprecedented amount of money has flooded into the largest battleground state of the race. The candidates and the wealthy super PACs that support them have exceeded the $336 million spent in Pennsylvania throughout the entire election four years ago, according to data from AdImpact, a political ad tracking firm. That includes $147 million in reserved air time for the coming months — a number that’s likely to rise as the parties compete for this crucial state.

Advertise with us

Ms. Harris alone has poured more money into the state in six weeks than Mr. Biden spent in the preceding year and a half, when he was leading the Democratic ticket.

For Ms. Harris, who suddenly ascended from supporting character to the title role, the challenge is to define her as a leader ready to take charge of the country — especially to the undecided voters who had been telling pollsters for more than a year that they wanted a different choice than a Biden-Trump rematch.

In the Harris campaign’s rush to define her before her opponents can, it has spent about $50 million in Pennsylvania alone — about $10 million a week. Burning through cash at that rate usually only happens as the campaigns near the very end of the race.

“If you get in a good space with positive ads underneath you, it takes more negative ads to beat you down a bit,” said Pittsburgh-based Democratic strategist Mike Butler. “Harris had an incredible need to start defining herself quickly.”

Trump had the same need, but with the opposite aim: to make her seem radical and dangerous.

Advertise with us

Faced with a new opponent, the former president’s campaign had to suddenly pivot. During the race against Mr. Biden, it had relied almost entirely on outside groups to lob attacks at the weakened candidate.

Consider: the week Mr. Biden dropped out, the Trump campaign spent less than $50,000 in Pennsylvania, according to AdImpact.

The next week it spent $1.6 million.

“When Biden was still in the race, people’s attitudes for him were kind of already baked in, so spending that far out might not have carried as much weight behind it,” Mr. Butler said. “But with Harris still being kind of an undefined figure, [Trump] really wanted to jump in there and try to shape people’s opinions before she had significant spending under her.”

In just over a month, the Republican nominee spent nearly $37 million on ads and future air time, almost equalling what he spent during the entire 2020 campaign in Pennsylvania.

Advertise with us

The PACs weigh in

Even as the candidates hammer each other, well-funded super PACs are spending colossal amounts of their own money on the airwaves, making Pennsylvania the most expensive swing state in the country by far, according to AdImpact.

The nearly $200 million spent on the general election in the state dwarfs what other key states have seen. In the next-most expensive state, Michigan, the campaigns and their supporters have spent about $105 million since Super Tuesday, according to a report AdImpact released this week.

“The thinking is, if you win Pennsylvania as a Republican, you basically close the path for Democrats to win the White House,” said Berwood Yost, director of the Center for Opinion Research at Franklin & Marshall University. “It’s the biggest ‘swing state’ prize.”

Spending on both sides is likely to increase sharply in the coming weeks.

The Harris campaign will storm into the final stretch of the race with an unprecedented amount of money. Since taking over the ticket, she raised a record-breaking $500 million, according to Reuters.

Advertise with us

She also has “all of the money that the Biden campaign had accumulated, so she had plenty of cash to spend, and she's going to spend it trying to reinvent herself,” said longtime Republican strategist Charlie Gerow.

Nowhere is that more important than Pennsylvania, which is considered by many to be the tipping-point state in the election.

“Spending in Pennsylvania is vital, because if Donald Trump wins Pennsylvania, he wins the presidency. It’s really that simple,” Mr. Gerow said.

In a few short weeks, the sprawling campaign apparatus that had been built to re-elect Mr. Biden pivoted its messaging to a new candidate. Before Mr. Biden dropped out, the ads focused on a character contrast: on one side, a steady, statesmanlike politician; on the other, an untrustworthy Republican opponent who presided over a chaotic four years in the White House.

Since Ms. Harris became the candidate, the most frequent issue mentioned in ads backing her has been crime — an issue that, until recently, favored Republicans, according to polling. But the Democratic campaign has seized on her past as a longtime prosecutor, a stark contrast to Trump, the first former president to be convicted on felony charges.

Advertise with us

“There's definitely been a shift in tone. I think that her message focuses on issues like crime — which is related to immigration — the economy and abortion rights. Those are the battlegrounds, those are the things that people care about,” said Mr. Yost. “If you can take away crime and immigration, if you can neutralize Republicans on that, that’s where they have an advantage.”

With a smaller war chest than their Democratic opponents, Republicans have prioritized Pennsylvania above every other swing state. In no other battleground state are they as close to Democrats when it comes to ad spending. Since March, when the primary campaigns effectively ended on Super Tuesday, the GOP has spent $89 million in the state, to Democrats’ $99 million, according to AdImpact.

Compare that to Michigan, Wisconsin and Nevada, where they’ve let Democrats outspend them two-to-one.

Both Republicans and Democrats have focused millions of dollars in ads on two of the areas where polling shows Democrats are most vulnerable: immigration and the economy.