When Kamala Harris tapped Tim Walz as her running mate, one of the Minnesota governor’s shining resume assets was his military service.

Mr. Walz served a total of 24 years in multiple units and jobs in the Army National Guard, but some of the terms of that service quickly came under attack from JD Vance, Donald Trump’s vice presidential nominee and also a candidate with military service on his resume — four years in the Marine Corps.

Mr. Vance, who has claimed Mr. Walz “abandoned” his Minnesota National Guard unit by retiring before an Iraq deployment and committed “stolen valor” by suggesting he saw combat when he did not, will likely lean into the issue again Thursday at a stop at VFW Post 92 in Lower Burrell. The official topic of the event is military recruitment.

To Edward Witt, Mr. Vance’s attacks crossed a line.

Advertise with us

Mr. Witt, a 43-year-old retired Navy master-at-arms who lives on Pittsburgh’s South Side, said he believes Mr. Vance went too far in criticizing Mr. Walz’s retirement.

“You just don’t do that to your brothers, no matter what branch you're serving or what your rank is,” said Mr. Witt, who served in the Navy for 22 years. “JD Vance is basically disparaging a fellow veteran without proof or validity to his claims.”

Others see problems in political material connected to Mr. Walz.

A resurfaced video from 2018 circulated on social media shows Mr. Walz addressing gun violence, saying, “We can make sure that those weapons of war, that I carried in war, is the only place where those weapons are at.”

That didn’t sit well with Kevin Zaffino, 39, of Washington, Pa., since the governor did not see combat.

Advertise with us

“I think the biggest issue is not really the sparring on military service,” Mr. Zaffino said. “I think the sparring is due to the dishonesty that comes from the Walz campaign about what he did. I think the highlight there is, if he’s willing to be dishonest about that, what else do you think he’s willing to be dishonest about?”

Laura Hitt, a spokeswoman for the Harris-Walz campaign, said last week that Mr. Walz “misspoke” in the 2018 video, according to the Associated Press.

“In making the case for why weapons of war should never be on our streets or in our classrooms, the governor misspoke,” Ms. Hitt said. “He did handle weapons of war and believes strongly that only military members trained to carry those deadly weapons should have access to them, unlike Donald Trump and JD Vance, who prioritize the gun lobby over our children.”

Debates about the value of military service and who gets to claim it have been a regular feature of political campaigns for decades. After World War II, elected officials who didn’t spend time in the military were relatively rare, since so many people served in that global conflict. In more recent years, candidates such as Bill Clinton, George W. Bush, Donald Trump, John McCain and John Kerry all have been part of the discussions about military service or lack thereof.

Overall, the public thinks highly of veterans, researchers at the Rand Institute found in a study published in December 2023 that showed Americans believe positive stereotypes about veterans — including loyalty and self-reliance — at high rates and negative stereotypes — such as volatility or exhibiting unethical behavior — at low rates.

Advertise with us

Since Mr. Walz’s name appeared on the Democratic presidential ticket, Mr. Vance’s criticism has been most focused on the issue of seeing actual combat and on the timing of Mr. Walz’s retirement from the military.

“Do not pretend to be something that you’re not,” Mr. Vance said last week while campaigning in Michigan. “I’d be ashamed if I was saying that I lied about my military service like you did.’

Mr. Vance’s four years in the Marine Corps included six months as a combat correspondent in Iraq. He did not see combat himself.

Mr. Vance also claimed that Mr. Walz “abandoned” his unit when he retired to run for Congress in May 2005 before the Department of Army issued a mobilization order for his unit three months later. The unit mobilized that October and deployed to Iraq in March 2006.

In Western Pennsylvania, which has an estimated veteran population of more than 58,000, according to the latest American Community Survey, the topic of military service resonates.

Advertise with us

“Being a veteran myself who retired, I understand that it is a very long process, so, no, he did not abandon his unit,” Mr. Witt said.

Mr. Zaffino, who served 12 years of active duty in the Marine Corps as a logistics officer and is now in the Marine Reserves, added that he likely would not have retired ahead of a deployment.

“If I was a part of a unit and I knew deployment was coming, even if I was at that retirement point, I probably wouldn’t have chosen the path that he did,” Mr. Zaffino said. “That comes from years of deploying with troops and understanding the bond they have and the training that’s required to get them to deploy.”

Mr. Zaffino said he plans to vote for Trump in November.

Shane Tanouye, who spent 26 years in the Army and the National Guard, said he considers the debate about Mr. Walz’s retirement to be nuanced. Some of his service duty included human resources work.

Advertise with us

“Normally what happens is, a unit gets notified that they’re going to deploy and at that point they start doing administrative and medical checks … that’s when I saw, myself, because I processed this paperwork, a lot of people would say, ‘It’s time for me to go,’” he said.

Mr. Tanouye, 50, of Green Tree, said those who retire ahead of deployment can be viewed differently by other veterans.

“They’re running out the door while people are going forward,” he said. “It’s hard to really understand unless you’ve served and you’ve seen it … so timelines don’t make it clear-cut. That’s why we need a lot more information and a lot more perspectives as to his motivations.”

Republicans have also accused Mr. Walz of embellishing his service.

The Harris campaign has referred to Mr. Walz as a “retired command sergeant major,” one of the top ranks for an enlisted soldier, although personnel files show he was reduced in rank a month after retiring, leaving him as a master sergeant for benefits purposes.

Advertise with us

The Minnesota National Guard has said Mr. Walz retired before finishing coursework at the U.S. Army Sergeants Major Academy, as well as before completing other requirements for the promotion. While he did achieve the rank of command sergeant major, he did not hold it after retirement.

This means that, while Mr. Walz can say he retired as a command sergeant major, he cannot say he is a “retired command sergeant major.”

Last week, the Harris campaign edited Mr. Walz’s official biography on its website to reflect that.

Erik Asher, a retired Army veteran who was deployed in West Germany and in the Gulf War in the late 1980s and early 1990s, said he doesn’t believe Mr. Vance’s accusations would resonate with anyone who has military service.

“Voters who never served in the military, I think that it may be convincing, but only to people that are already on the Trump/Vance bandwagon,” said Mr. Asher, 56, of Penn Hills.

Advertise with us

Mr. Asher, who said he plans to vote for Ms. Harris in November, was glad she picked a running mate with a military background.

“His military service means a lot because I’ve seen the last few presidents we had have never served in the military, and I think that’s a real problem because you can’t really be commander-in-chief and do that job properly if you don’t have an actual appreciation of what that means,” he said.