WASHINGTON — The uncertainty swirling around the top of the November ticket as President Joe Biden attempts to rebound from last week’s halting debate performance could have have ripple effects down ballot, experts say, with Republicans ramping up fundraising in key battlegrounds like Pennsylvania and Democrats facing a wide voter enthusiasm gap with Mr. Biden as their nominee.

The ongoing fallout from the debate has already come under the spotlight in Pennsylvania, where U.S. Sen. Bob Casey faces a challenge from Republican former hedge fund CEO David McCormick. 

Mr. McCormick seized on Mr. Biden’s poor debate performance, hitting Mr. Casey in an ad claiming Mr. Casey knew the president wasn’t fit for the job despite professing otherwise on multiple occasions. Mr. Casey, a longtime friend of the president and a fellow Scranton native, went several days without addressing the debate at all, but eventually broke his silence, acknowledging that Mr. Biden “had a bad night and debate,” but arguing that “people know what’s at stake” in the election. 

Despite the president telling Democratic governors he’s committed to the race and White House staffers maintaining he’s fit for the Oval Office, Mr. Biden heads to battlegrounds including Wisconsin and Pennsylvania on Sunday facing mounting scrutiny over every stumble or lapse in recent appearances, along with increasing calls among Democratic lawmakers and pundits to bow out. Trump, whose torrent of falsehoods during the debate didn’t stop him from widening his advantage over Mr. Biden in the first post-debate poll, will rally in Butler on July 13 just before he seals the GOP nomination at the Republican National Convention in Wisconsin.

Advertise with us

Lew Irwin, a political science professor at Duquesne University, told the Post-Gazette that so far, Mr. Casey has done a solid job of championing the Biden administration’s accomplishments while separating himself and his bid for a fourth term from Mr. Biden as a candidate. 

“I won’t be shocked if they show up in a joint appearance in Philadelphia,” he said. “But I also won’t be shocked if Casey has a pesky scheduling conflict.” 

Sen. John Fetterman, a fellow Pennsylvania Democrat who struggled in a primary debate in 2022, has gone further than Mr. Casey and many other Democrats by attacking the media’s coverage of Mr. Biden and, in a fundraising email, calling some Democrats “vultures” for pushing Mr. Biden to exit the race.

Vince Galko, a GOP strategist based in Northeastern Pennsylvania, said the Casey-McCormick matchup “has the attention and importance to be able to stand alone” beyond the turmoil at the top of the ticket. He described Mr. Casey as a “good soldier” who’s been “more loyal to Biden than most,” but suggested the Casey campaign probably “wouldn’t mind getting some fresh blood in there.”

“I’d be worried about the enthusiasm gap,” Mr. Galko said. “Clearly, Republicans are energized, and the debate further fired them up. The biggest concern for Casey is how Joe Biden’s going to affect turnout come November.”

Advertise with us

Harrisburg-based GOP strategist Charlie Gerow said he thinks there are “better issues to go after on Bob Casey” than ties to Mr. Biden or the fallout from the debate. But still, he described Mr. Casey as an “acolyte for Joe Biden and it’s a black mark on his record.”

“He’s going to try to run away from it, but you can’t run away from reality,” he said.

Mr. Irwin said the Casey campaign is unlikely to change gears unless there is a major shift in the polls. Mr. Casey leads by 5 percentage points, according to an average of polls tracked by Real Clear Politics, but all but one of those polls were conducted prior to the debate.

“I don't see the Casey campaign changing anything they’re doing until they’re convinced they have to,” he said. “What they’re doing now is working.”

J.J. Balaban, a Philadelphia-based Democratic strategist and admaker, said Mr. Casey and his team have effectively executed “a campaign that has broader appeal than the presidential nominee of his party, and even if President Biden were to turn down the nomination, it would be surprising for the Casey campaign to change paths.” 

Advertise with us

The increased pressure on Mr. Biden comes as the president faces his first televised interview since the debate, with ABC’s George Stephanopoulos, on Friday night.

It also comes as Pennsylvania voters — who could likely determine which party controls the Senate and the White House — brace for a barrage of advertising in the run up to November. 

The Senate Leadership Fund tied to Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell, R-Ky., has invested $24 million in Pennsylvania ads set to start in September. 

Democrats, including the Casey campaign and multiple PACs, have reserved almost $69 million in ad buys for the fall. Republicans including the McCormick campaign and aligned PACs have invested more than $72.5 million thus far in future ads across the Keystone State, according to Ad Impact. 

Mr. McCormick, a veteran, said in a statement to the Post-Gazette that Mr. Casey “has known Joe Biden isn't up to the task” of “looking out for our troops.”

Advertise with us

“The commonwealth deserves better than their failed leadership and tired, old ideas,” he said.

The Casey campaign did not immediately respond to a request seeking comment.

But the state Democratic Party this week asked for a surge of donations to “fight back” against the “massive” ad buy by Mr. McConnell’s super PAC.

“Democracy is on the ballot this November,” the group posted on X earlier this week. “Birds of a feather flock together — and time and time again, David McCormick has aligned himself with fake electors, election deniers, and Donald Trump.”

On Friday, Mr. Fetterman mocked a Politico headline “Nine questions George Stephanopoulos should ask Joe Biden” by listing a series of alternate questions highlighting Trump’s apparent weaknesses.

Advertise with us

“The media still obsesses on smearing a good president and decent man,” Mr. Fetterman said on X in a post mocking the New York Times’ coverage. 

“I refuse to join the Democratic vultures on Biden’s shoulder after the debate,” he said in a fundraising email Wednesday. “No one knows more than me that a rough debate is not the sum total of the person and their record.”

Mr. Irwin, however, said that as Mr. Biden continues his effort to rehabilitate his candidacy, “frankly, it’s hard to see how he un-rings that bell with the American people.”

If Mr. Biden eventually decides to step aside, potentially paving the way for Vice President Kamala Harris or another candidate, Mr. Irwin expects a dramatic impact on down ballot races across the country: increased Democratic energy. 

“There’s an enthusiasm gap between Republicans and Democrats right now that predates the debate by 10-12 months,” he said. “Republicans have been more fired up. But if you get candidates at the top of the ticket who are able to represent something fresher and newer and younger, I think that is going to translate into energy for Democratic partisans across the spectrum. I think it would really shake up the race … and make it a far more viable situation for the Democrats than what they have right now.” 

Advertise with us

The latest Marquette Law University Law School poll showed voters who are “very enthusiastic” favor Trump by a wide margin, 61% to 39%.

Mr. Galko noted that Trump could be concerned about a strong, younger Democrat or Ms. Harris, who despite “some flaws” would have fundraising, donors and campaign apparatus ready to go if she became the nominee.

“Trump has to be a little careful what he wishes for here,” he said.

Mr. Balaban suggested Democrats may maintain an edge that’s hiding in plain sight, no matter what happens with Mr. Biden.

He noted that four years ago, when Mr. Biden was the Democratic nominee, his candidacy “was never premised on motivating the base.”

“Nonetheless, a record-setting number of Democrats (and voters broadly) turned out,” he said. “It turns out that Donald Trump is a very motivating presence for Democrats.”

Benjamin Kail: bkail@post-gazette.com; @BenKail