WASHINGTON — Investor George Soros, a funder of progressive groups and Democratic candidates, has been a Republican bogeyman for years.
He’s taken on a prominent role this year in Western Pennsylvania as Republicans significantly feature him in their efforts to defeat U.S. Sen. Bob Casey and U.S. Rep. Chris Deluzio in the region’s only two competitive congressional races this fall.
But the rise of antisemitism in the U.S. since the Oct. 7 Hamas attacks on Israel has sparked new concerns that singling out Mr. Soros, a Holocaust survivor, mainstreams the stereotype of the all-powerful Jew pulling the world’s strings.
“There are enormous rhetorical parallels with the way people speak about Jews and the way people speak about Soros,” said Alon Milwicki, a senior research analyst with the Southern Poverty Law Center. “Legitimate criticism of George Soros or Israel is not antisemitism. But when it crosses over into this venue, which has to do with he’s behind everything, he’s the puppet master, he’s the root of all evil, that’s antisemitic 100%.”
Republicans have criticized both Mr. Casey, D-Pa., and Mr. Deluzio, D-Aspinwall, for accepting contributions from the Soros family, whose Open Society Foundations has contributed to some of the groups that later backed the pro-Palestinian demonstrations on college campuses.
The Soros group said in a statement that it leaves grant recipients alone once it makes donations and doesn’t tell them what to do. At the same time, the group said “we never, and will never, coordinate, train, or strategize with protest organizers or participants.”
Read More
But the funding has given Republicans a new excuse to call out Mr. Soros, who in previous years had been accused by U.S. Sen. Chuck Grassley, R-Iowa, of funding protesters opposed to confirming Supreme Court nominee Brett Kavanaugh; by former President Donald Trump of funding caravans of migrants heading to the U.S.; and by former House Speaker Kevin McCarthy, R-Calif., of trying to buy the 2018 midterm election with two other wealthy donors with Jewish backgrounds, Michael Bloomberg and Tom Steyer.
“Republicans' ongoing demonization of George Soros, and conspiracy theories related to alleged Soros influence, is absolutely a form of antisemitism,” said Halie Soifer, CEO of the Jewish Democratic Council of America, agreed. “According to the [Anti-Defamation League], ‘politicians and pundits repeating unsubstantiated conspiracies [about George Soros] essentially validate the same hateful myths propagated by antisemites.’ Even worse, it's so common among Republican and Trump fundraising efforts that it has been normalized, so many don't see it for what it is — an insidious form of hate targeting American Jews.”
A supporter of Mr. Trump, Cesar Sayoc, was arrested in October 2018 and charged with sending pipe bombs to Mr. Soros and other critics of the then-president, including current President Joe Biden and current Vice President Kamala Harris. Mr. Sayoc pled guilty the following March to 65 felonies.
When she was House speaker, California Democrat Nancy Pelosi used to star in Republican fundraising missives. Now Mr. Soros does.
“With Democrat control of the Senate hanging on by a mere thread, shadowy left-wing billionaire George Soros is now interfering in the biggest battleground races with a new final hour plot,” read one recent National Republican Senatorial Committee email. “Soros is plotting to buy up the airwaves so the Democrats can relentlessly drown out our candidates with lying attacks.”
Republicans say they’re raising legitimate issues, not engaging in antisemitic attacks.
Take Mr. Casey, for example. He has received more than $20,000 from the Soros family for his 2024 re-election campaign, including $6,600 from Mr. Soros, according to the research group Open Secrets.
Mr. Soros also has been financially involved in Pennsylvania-area politics. He contributed around $2 million last year to a political action committee supporting Matt Dugan in the Democratic primary for Allegheny County district attorney but lost the general election to the man he defeated, Stephen A. Zappala Jr., who ran as a Republican. He also supported Philadelphia District Attorney Larry Krasner and the Manhattan DA, Alvin Bragg, who on Thursday won convictions against former President Donald Trump.
“Every year George Soros spends millions of dollars funding anti-police politicians like Larry Krasner and extreme left-wing causes like the pro-Hamas riots on college campuses,” said Philip Letsou, a spokesman for the Senate Republicans’ political arm. “George Soros is also one of Bob Casey’s biggest donors, so we will continue to criticize Casey for taking money from an anti-police, pro-Hamas billionaire until Casey disavows Soros.”
Mr. Milwicki asked why Mr. Soros is being singled out.
“It begs the question, ‘Why Soros?’” Mr. Milwicki said. “The answer is because he leans into progressive causes and to antisemitism. It’s not a critique of Soros when you say, ‘Alvin Bragg is a Soros-backed DA.’ It’s disingenuous at best.”
Still, state Rep. Rob Mercuri has used Mr. Soros as a cudgel against Mr. Deluzio, D-Aspinwall, who, according to Open Secrets, received $6,600 from Soros family members for his re-election.
“It’s greatly concerning to me that Chris Deluzio would take money from the Soros family while also claiming to be a champion of Israel,” Mr. Mercuri said. “Deluzio may say one thing, but his record says another.”
A spokeswoman for the House Democrats’ fundraising arm rejected that argument.
“Rob Mercuri has no problem with the leader of his party calling for a ‘unified reich,’ so it shouldn’t be a surprise that he would spread a disgusting antisemitic trope for political gain,” Courtney Rice said. “Western Pennsylvanians will reject his dangerous extremism and conspiracy theories this November.”
The American Jewish Committee says it is not antisemitic to criticize Mr. Soros for his politics or actions. “However, when Soros is used as a symbol for Jewish control, wealth, and power, the criticism may be an updated version of traditional antisemitic tropes,” the AJC said.
But Pamela Nadell, director of the Jewish Studies Program at American University, said almost any talk to Mr. Soros now plays into that antisemitic meme.
“I do see this as a straight line from Judas to Shylock to Rothschild to Soros,” Ms. Nadell said. “This one name stands for this Jewish mastermind cabal that is controlling the word nefariously. ... Certain terms, certain words, certain memes are unacceptable because they express hatred against the American Jewish community.”
Jonathan D. Salant: jsalant@post-gazette.com; @JDSalant





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.