Supporters of Nikki Haley failed to stop Donald Trump from winning the Republican presidential nomination. Could they stop him from winning the presidency?

Almost 1 in 5 Republicans who voted in Tuesday’s Pennsylvania primary cast their ballots for Ms. Haley, the former South Carolina governor and U.S. ambassador to the United Nations, over Mr. Trump, who already has won enough delegates to be renominated in July.

With polls showing a tight race between Mr. Trump and President Joe Biden in Pennsylvania this fall, a defection that large could spell doom for the former president’s chances of regaining the White House.

Allegheny County, home to more registered Republicans than any other in Pennsylvania, led the state with the greatest number of GOP voters spurning their party’s nominee to cast their ballots for a candidate who left the race more than a month ago: 12,734 voters, or more than 19%, according to preliminary results and with four precincts left to be counted.

Advertise with us

“If you’re Donald Trump, you have to be very worried about this significant base erosion,” said former U.S. Rep. Charlie Dent, a Republican who formerly represented the Lehigh Valley in Washington and who said he voted for Ms. Haley on Tuesday. “There are a significant number who are not going to vote for Donald Trump under any circumstances.” 

Ms. Haley polled more than 155,000 votes, or 17% of the total, in the GOP primary, in which only registered Republicans could vote. That’s almost double Mr. Biden’s margin of victory in 2020 and more than triple Mr. Trump’s edge in 2016.

“Donald Trump has a serious general election problem,” said Ammar Moussa, a spokesman for Mr. Biden’s re-election campaign. “His cash-strapped campaign is struggling to communicate on the airwaves, has no real staff footprint in key battlegrounds, and is spending more on his personal problems than reaching voters. And even if he had the money, Trump’s toxic agenda of abortion bans, tax cuts for the wealthy, and ripping away freedoms is a losing one and shows he has no path to building the coalition necessary to win 270 electoral votes.”

Karoline Leavitt, national press secretary for Mr. Trump’s campaign, welcomed the results.

“President Trump continued his winning streak and delivered a resounding primary win in Pennsylvania,” Ms. Leavitt said. “More importantly, President Trump continues to dominate Feeble Joe Biden in every battleground state poll including his home state. The Dishonest Biden campaign has spent millions in Pennsylvania gaslighting voters, but it is not enough to make everyone ignore Bidenflation and rising costs, Biden’s border bloodbath, and his war on American energy.”

Advertise with us

Charlie Gerow, a Harrisburg-based GOP strategist, shrugged off any concerns about Ms. Haley’s share of Tuesday’s vote, noting that “in a lot of elections, even Donald Duck gets 10 or 12%.” 

“You have some people who wanted to make a statement, but will almost certainly vote for Donald Trump in the fall — they’re not going to vote for Joe Biden,” he said. 

Even if those voters stay home, there aren’t enough of them to tip the scales in Mr. Biden’s favor, Mr. Gerow said.

Still, Ms. Haley’s largest percentages came in three of the vote-rich Philadelphia suburban counties that have been trending Democratic during the Trump years — Montgomery (24.7%), Chester (24.2%), and Delaware (23.3%). 

It’s not just the swing areas where Ms. Haley did well. In Lancaster County, a conservative Republican bastion, she won more than 20%, well ahead of her statewide share of 16.6%. 

Advertise with us

That also should be concerning to Mr. Trump, according to Republican political consultant Mike DuHaime.

“He’s going to win those counties, but he may not rack up the margins he needs to overcome the winning margins Biden will get in Philadelphia, Pittsburgh and the smaller cities,” Mr. DuHaime said. “If I were Trump, I would realize there was work to do to bring people back home. It’s not just in the suburban swing areas. You saw some softness even in Republican base areas.”

For decades, political pundits and strategists have focused on Republicans’ strength in the so-called “T,” the deep red swath of territory that runs from Central Pennsylvania’s border with Maryland north to the New York state line and east and west across the commonwealth’s northern tier. Dotted with small towns surrounded by rural farmland and forests, the region has long been the heartland of the state’s Republican Party.

Even many of those rural northern tier counties saw more than 10% of the GOP defecting to Ms. Haley, including McKean (11.4%), Tioga (12.4%), Bradford (15.6%) and Warren (16.3%).

But that ignores the key bloc of GOP voters who live in more densely populated areas like the once reliably Republican suburbs around Pittsburgh and Philadelphia. Taken together, Allegheny County and the four counties that surround Philadelphia are home to almost 960,000 registered Republicans — more than a quarter of the party’s total voter base. Add in Lancaster, which abuts one of the collar counties, and the number of Republicans climbs to more than 1.1 million, fully a third of the state’s GOP voters.

Advertise with us

Taken together, more than 64,000 Republicans in these counties voted for Ms. Haley — a number greater than Mr. Trump’s margin of victory over Hillary Clinton when he won Pennsylvania in 2016 on his way to the White House.

Mr. Dent said the opposition to Mr. Trump was baked in, and his ongoing criminal trial in New York will reinforce the questions some Republicans have about his character.

“I don’t buy the argument that being a criminal defendant is good for your candidacy,” Mr. Dent said.

Two national polls released Wednesday showed almost no defections among Republicans, however. In a Quinnipiac University survey, Republicans backed Mr. Trump by 90% to 6%. And in a Pew Research Center survey, only 4% of voters who supported Mr. Trump in 2020 said they would vote for Mr. Biden this year. (Among those who backed Mr. Biden in 2020, 7% said they would vote for Mr. Trump.)

Christopher Nicholas, a longtime Harrisburg-based Republican consultant, said that the other Democrat on the primary ballot, Rep. Dean Phillips of Minnesota, also performed well in some counties.

Advertise with us

“Both parties are saying that the standard bearers still haven’t locked down all of their partisans,” he said. “From the Republican side, it’s more establishment, moderate business-oriented conservatives. On the Democratic side, it’s more conservative and rural voters. The counties where Phillips did better, those are counties where Trump will outperform the Republican Party. And where Haley did better, Biden will outperform the Democratic vote.”

Benjamin Kail: bkail@post-gazette.com, @BenKail; Mike Wereschagin, mwereschagin@post-gazette.com, @Wrschgn; Jonathan D. Salant, jsalant@post-gazette.com, @JDSalant.