Thursday afternoons at the Brighton Heights Healthy Active Living Center in Pittsburgh are usually marked by senior citizens discussing news headlines over lunch — and recently, the ages of the two major candidates running for president of the United States was the focus.

The group of older voters had just participated in the center’s weekly current events session when the conversation turned to how old President Joe Biden, 81, and former President Donald Trump, 77, are.

As Mr. Biden seeks reelection as the oldest president in American history, his age has become a focal point. Numerous polls indicate voters in both parties say he is too old to be president. Just four years younger, Mr. Trump’s longevity has also been questioned. 

In primary and special elections, voters over 65 have historically turned out in force, making them one of the largest age groups at the polls. For some Allegheny County voters of the same generation as the candidates, the age concerns are prevalent. But for others, 81 and 77 are just numbers, and not an indication of ability.

Advertise with us

“Both of these people running for office need a competency test because some things that fly out of their mouth makes me go ‘OK, red flag again,’” said Karen Nibbs, a 68-year-old who teaches dance fitness classes at the Brighton Heights center. 

Even voters in the same age group say it’s a job that isn’t for them because of the high demands. The recently retired Ms. Nibbs said it’s not that she couldn’t do the job — but she wouldn’t want to. 

That opinion was seconded by the voters around the table, and by seniors 10 miles away at the Hazelwood Healthy Active Living Center in Pittsburgh. 

“I think Biden never should have decided to be president again, he should have lived out his life with less stress, but I sure don’t want Donald Trump back in there either,” said Diana Walker, a 67-year-old resident of Hazelwood. 

In March, both candidates secured enough pledged delegates to all-but-guarantee their party nominations this summer, but both Ms. Walker and Ms. Nibbs said they would rather vote for an independent third-party candidate than for either Mr. Biden or Mr. Trump. Robert F. Kennedy Jr., the son of the late U.S. senator and nephew of a former president, has launched a presidential bid as an independent and could shake up the race, several political strategists have said.

Advertise with us

Older voters make up a significant portion of the electorate in Allegheny County. About 26.27% of its 903,510 registered voters are above age 65. That’s a total of 237,269 voters, according to data from the Pennsylvania State Department. 

Seniors are a key demographic for any candidate hoping to win the support of the second most populated county in Pennsylvania, a pivotal swing state. People above age 65 comprise an estimated 242,524 of the county’s 1.25 million population, according to data from the Census Bureau. 

Allegheny County has swung blue in the last three presidential elections by wide margins. In 2020, the county voted for Mr. Biden over Mr. Trump by a 20.38% margin, or 146,741 votes. Mr. Biden ultimately won the state by 1.2%, securing 20 electoral votes that boosted him toward the presidency. 

Mr. Biden’s campaign has especially been on the defensive about his age, particularly after a February special counsel report investigating his handling of classified documents called his memory “faulty” and “poor.” Mr. Biden slammed the report’s description of his memory, saying in a rebuttal, “I’m well meaning, and I’m an elderly man, and I know what the hell I’m doing.” 

“The age is troubling but I would rather have a sickly Joe Biden in office than a hale and hearty Donald Trump, that’s my personal opinion,” said Tom Weber, a 67-year-old Hazelwood resident. 

Advertise with us

Mr. Weber said he is more concerned about who makes up the president's cabinet, and how they will champion various policy initiatives. 

“I don’t think it’s a matter of age, it’s a matter of competence,” said Warren Wake, a 67-year-old Pittsburgh resident. “If you’re not going to give a competency test to a president who is over 80, then I don’t think they’re qualified to oversee other officials.” 

Other seniors echoed Mr. Wake’s thoughts about competency tests, saying they should be given for all elected officials and Supreme Court justices. Some said a retirement age should be enforced across all three branches of the federal government. 

Leland Miller, a 91-year-old Emsworth resident who leads walks at the Brighton Heights center two days a week, said he is more concerned with integrity and individual issues than he is with age. 

Mr. Miller’s stance was echoed by the results of last year’s election in Allegheny County, when thousands of voters split their tickets and cast votes for candidates from both parties. In 40% of precincts, both a Democrat and a Republican won at least one top-tier race, affirming that voters in the county are taking on issues, and not just party. 

Advertise with us

That also was apparent in the race for county executive between Democrat Sara Innamorato and Republican Joe Rockey, when issues such as abortion rights and the Israel-Hamas war took center stage among voters, even though the county-level position has little control over either.

Ms. Nibbs said she has split her vote in recent elections, prioritizing individual candidates over her party. In 2020, she voted for Mr. Trump, but following the Jan. 6, 2021 insurrection on the United States Capitol, she is not planning to vote for him again. 

“I just really don’t want January 6th to happen again and I’m really scared that it is and I think it’s going to be more intense,” Ms. Nibbs said, citing Mr. Trump’s refusal to participate in the Republican primary debates early in the election cycle as another reason she changed her mind. 

For Ms. Walker, Social Security and Medicare are the policy priority that could determine her vote in November. She worries cuts to either of the entitlement programs could be devastating for herself and other seniors. 

“If they get rid of Social Security, a lot of people are going to be homeless,” Ms. Walker said, pointing to a March 11 CNBC interview when Mr. Trump said “there is a lot you can do in terms of entitlements, in terms of cutting.” The comments sparked swift backlash from the Biden campaign, and Mr. Trump later said in a March 13 interview with Breitbart that he would not “jeopardize” either program. 

Advertise with us

Medicare is solvent through 2028 and Social Security is estimated to be solvent through 2034, when cuts will automatically take place unless policy changes are made. Mr. Trump has not released a specific plan for Social Security or Medicare. 

“Affordable housing is another big issue of mine, and also the homeless,” Ms. Walker said. She is in the process of trying to secure affordable housing, which she said has been a challenge. 

Ms. Walker also said she wants to see tax policies that work to redistribute wealth and benefit low-income Americans. That was seconded by Mr. Weber, who noted his young adult children are struggling to make wealth-building purchases, such as cars and houses. 

A deeply polarized Congress is Mr. Weber’s top concern. He worried that candidates running on both sides of the aisle this year would be too “extreme” for an already polarized legislative body. 

“For this country to thrive and excel, we need people in the center of their political parties,” Mr. Weber said, pointing to the months-long partisan battle over federal government funding.

Advertise with us

After the conversation at the table at Brighton Heights turned to border policy and Pennsylvania voter ID requirements, Mr. Miller asked his fellow voters to focus on down-ballot races at the Congressional and state house level. 

“We need to forget about these candidates that are running for president, because what we should be looking at are the lower ones, and the Senators and House of Representatives, because that’s where the influence is going to come from,” Mr. Miller said. “That’s what I’m trying to encourage people to do.”

Sydney Carruth: scarruth@post-gazette.com