Chatham University President Lisa Lambert was surprised in late May when a Forbes social media post listed her small Pittsburgh university as one of several schools around the country “in dire straits financially.”

The global business magazine released its annual financial grades for hundreds of colleges, making calculations based on data points such as endowment assets, reserve ratios and unrestricted net assets exclusive of plant, which is meant to measure an institution’s financial flexibility and liquid reserves.

The outlet then spotlighted a few schools that it deemed “on the brink.”

Chatham — with 2025 unrestricted net assets exclusive of illiquid assets such as buildings of negative $41.6 million, far below many comparable peer institutions — made the list. On social media, the Forbes list received more than 8,600 likes and 12,800 shares on Instagram alone.

Advertise with us

It’s not the kind of publicity that a university wants, especially as higher education leaders are bracing for a shrinking college-age population and as competition for students, grants and other dollars is as tight as ever. Several other Pittsburgh-area colleges received poor marks in the general Forbes report — and, in fact, worse overall grades than Chatham — but were not spotlighted on social media.

 
 
 
View this post on Instagram

A post shared by Forbes (@forbes)

Chatham has been forced to adapt to financial stresses before, in sometimes very public ways. A decade ago, alumni were part of the intense debate as the historically women’s college began enrolling male students to bolster its student ranks and its finances.

And university officials are taking this latest unwanted attention seriously. It’s not that the numbers published by the magazine writers are wrong, Lambert said.

But leaders argue that the stats don’t paint the full picture of the university’s improving financial situation, and, they say, Forbes’ insinuation in the post that Chatham is “burning through its restricted donor funds in order to stay afloat” just isn’t true.

“They got their conclusions wrong,” Lambert told the Post-Gazette in a recent interview. “They took the number and jumped to a conclusion that this means that you must be doing these things, and we aren’t. We don’t need to. That was the real tragedy of that article.”

Advertise with us

Chatham officials are quick to admit the university has had financial issues. Just three years ago, the Shadyside school eliminated 8% of staff positions, restructured the university’s leadership team and consolidated four departments into one to manage a multimillion-dollar deficit. But outdated data might not show the direction that things are headed, Lambert said.

School leaders project Chatham will reach profitability by 2029. The university’s debt has diminished about 40% over the past three years, they said, from about $65 million in 2023 to $39 million in 2026. Its budget is currently balanced.

The university is growing, Lambert said. The private college expects its second-largest freshman class in its nearly 160-year history. Deposits for fall 2026 are up 56% compared to last fall.

“They got their conclusions wrong,” Chatham University President Lisa Lambert said of a Forbes story that listed the small Pittsburgh university as one of several schools around the country “in dire straits financially.” (Justin Guido / For the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

“I’m a big believer in transparency, so the idea that professional news reporters are looking seriously at this industry like every other is absolutely fair,” Lambert said from the university’s green, picturesque urban campus. “I think that there’s a real plus side to this light shining, but the real problem here … is data lag. The kind of data that they have access to is often a few years old.”

Other colleges included in Forbes’ “on the brink” list included Albright College in Reading; Keystone College near Scranton; and two schools in the Cleveland area, Lake Erie College and Baldwin Wallace University. The latter responded to the Forbes report on Facebook, also claiming that the data was “outdated.”

Advertise with us

Forbes did not respond to several Post-Gazette requests to explain how it put together its “on the brink” list.

Nearly half of the 900 nonprofit schools that Forbes ranked received grades of C or lower. Chatham received a D.

Financial concerns are becoming increasingly common for higher education institutions as college-age populations decline and more people question the value of a degree.

Impacts of this changing landscape have been felt in the region: 

• Penn State plans to close seven commonwealth campuses next year. Program cuts are also likely on the horizon for Penn State.

Advertise with us

• Pennsylvania Western University this week announced it would sunset dozens of offerings.

• A Baptist university in West Virginia shuttered in 2023.

• A Philadelphia arts school likewise closed its doors in 2024.

• And West Virginia University leaders slashed dozens of programs and more than 140 faculty positions in 2024. 

“This is a low point in the history of higher education, at least from a financial view,” said Richard Vedder, an economist and professor emeritus at Ohio University. “Pennsylvania is in many ways at the center of this. They overbuilt the universities, and now there’s stagnant or declining populations in most regions.”

Advertise with us
Chatham University’s main Shadyside campus — one of the school’s three locations, along with Eden Hall in Richland and Chatham Eastside near Bakery Square — as seen in a June 7, 2024 file photo. (Benjamin B. Braun / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Cost-cutting strategies

Founded in 1869, Chatham enrolled just over 2,300 students in fall 2024. It operates out of three locations: its main Shadyside campus, the sustainability-focused Eden Hall campus in Richland and Chatham Eastside near Bakery Square. As of fall 2025, the university employed 127 full-time faculty members, 347 part-time faculty and nearly 300 staff members.

Lambert took the helm in 2025 after serving as a professor and administrator at the private school for four decades. 

Last year, Chatham brought in more than $61 million in revenue and had more than $68 million in liabilities, according to a financial report. That was an improvement from the 2022 fiscal year, when the school brought in about $53 million in revenue and had $83 million in liabilities.

The school has a BBB- rating from S&P Global, indicating that Chatham can meet its financial commitments but is also more subject to adverse economic conditions. Chief Financial Officer Leonard Cullo projects Chatham’s 2026 expenses to be $5 million lower than they were in 2023, despite inflationary pressures. 

Chatham leaders have taken several steps to move toward financial health, they told the Post-Gazette. In March, the school sold its 250,000-square-foot Eastside building to Carnegie Mellon University, though Chatham will maintain a presence there. Officials did not disclose financial details of the sale or leaseback.

Advertise with us

Chatham has sold other houses it owned throughout the region. In Lambert’s view, there’s nothing in the university’s mission statement “about being a landlord.”

The school is divesting from “things that are not directly related to our mission and are not helping students,” she said.

“I think that there’s a real plus side to this light shining, but the real problem here … is data lag. The kind of data that they have access to is often a few years old.”

Chatham University President LISA LAMBERT

The university has also kept compensation and other expenses relatively flat, Cullo said. And, of course, officials are always looking to expand enrollment.

Like many smaller colleges, Chatham saw a post-COVID-19 dip in students, but its decline has been concentrated among graduate students. Undergraduate enrollment in fall 2024 stood at 1,550 students, up by more than 100 compared to 2019, according to Department of Education data. 

Graduate enrollment, meanwhile, fell by 270 students during the same period. In fall 2024, the school enrolled 759 graduate students. The university is working to draw in more students, in part by offering more competitive financial aid packages, expanding recruitment and building up sports, Lambert said.

Advertise with us

Smaller private schools such as Chatham typically don’t have the massive endowments of a University of Pittsburgh or Carnegie Mellon. Chatham’s endowment hovers around $80 million, compared to Pitt’s of $6 billion and CMU’s $3.5 billion. Chatham also doesn’t have significant reserves to draw from, nor does it receive state funds like public universities do.

That means a slight change in enrollment can have a massive impact on finances, Cullo said. Chatham’s base annual tuition currently stands at $45,700.

“We’re tuition dependent,” he said. “It doesn’t take many students to hurt us.”

What the future holds

Experts say struggling universities can turn around their financial situations. But as challenges mount for many institutions, more could close and merge in coming years as a demographic cliff tied to falling birth rates during the Great Recession 18 years ago signals a projected decline in college-age people.

By 2041, the share of high school graduates is expected to drop 13% nationwide and 17% in Pennsylvania.

Advertise with us

Schools can increase revenue through enrollment growth to counteract financial struggles. Offering attractive new programs and expanding dual-enrollment opportunities for high school students can be key, economist and college financial expert Lucie Lapovsky said.

Selling buildings and consolidating services with nearby institutions can make also difference, she said.

Still, Lapovsky believes Pennsylvania and other states have “too many schools,” which can cause somewhat selective schools such as Chatham — which has an acceptance rate of 62% — to struggle.

“Schools where they’re accepting 60, 70% of their students aren’t able to get enough students to pay their price,” Lapovsky said. “It’s a tough time for higher education.”

Chatham leaders have taken several steps to move toward financial health, they told the Post-Gazette. (Benjamin B. Braun / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Vedder, the Ohio University professor, said it doesn’t help that a growing number of people see college as a “risky investment,” he said. Fewer than half of Americans have a great deal of confidence in higher education, found a 2025 Gallup poll.

Advertise with us

Small private colleges with small endowments, Vedder said, are “getting clobbered.

“They’re just dropping like flies,” he said. “I think several hundred of them will die. It’s getting to be a dicey thing.”

But between Chatham’s location in the city, its picturesque campus and its ties to the Pittsburgh community, Lambert hopes it can continue to attract more students and build on its strengths.

The university has already shown the community it can be flexible, having shifted away from its status as a women-only college a decade ago and offering graduate programs starting in 1994.

Lambert believes that kind of flexibility will be instrumental as Chatham aims to adapt and grow.

“That’s what smaller institutions need to do in order to remain relevant,” she said.