Chartiers Valley School District will outsource its bus services to a private company and furlough dozens of drivers, despite pleas and heated arguments from parents and drivers who implored the district to continue maintaining its own garage.

The school board voted 5-4 Tuesday night to approve a seven-year contract with First Student, the largest student transportation provider in North America, ending a 2½-year contentious debate over the issue.

The board also approved furloughs of 41 employees, including drivers, bus monitors and a head mechanic.

School leaders project the move will save the district $5.1 million and lead to a balanced budget. Rising operational costs and labor shortages prompted the decision.

Advertise with us

“We had an inefficient model, and a very costly one,” Superintendent Daniel Castagna said.

But community members worry that outsourcing busing will lead to safety issues and won’t save the district money in the long run.

Transportation employees also say they were blindsided by the furlough decision, only learning of the board’s intent to vote on the issue Monday night. Union leaders with the Chartiers Valley Education Support Professionals believed active negotiations were ongoing, and called Tuesday’s decision a “slap in the face.” District bus drivers have been working without a contract after their last agreement expired in June 2024.

“Nobody wants First Student to come in,” union President Mike Dupree said in a statement. “We constantly hear from parents that First Student is messing with their kids’ bus routes, longer wait times, just all around unreliable. ... We’re on the chopping block for the district to cut us loose so that they can bring in this big money private company that just doesn’t care about this community.”

Tuesday’s tense meeting lasted about two hours. Of the numerous parents, grandparents and drivers who spoke during public comment, several brought up safety concerns they have with First Student. They specifically cited a 2025 incident in which a First Student driver in the Baldwin-Whitehall School District crashed a school van into a car while intoxicated and fled from the scene.

Advertise with us

“Our kids, my kids are the most precious things on this earth, and the decision to subcontract our kids is putting them at risk,” said Susan Andreone, a driver who was furloughed. “If you decide to subcontract with that company, I hope you can all live with yourselves should something happen to our kids.”

Others spoke of the personal relationships that children have with district drivers. Stephanie Van Balen, who has two children currently in the district, said the “most consistent part” of her family’s morning is seeing the school bus driver “Mr. Bob” pull up to the stop right on time.

“He is reliable, and I know he will be there,” Van Balen said, eliciting applause from the audience. “I never doubt that he will show up at 7:51 and take care of my girls from the minute that they step onto the bus until he drops them off safely at school.”

Several parents said they would prefer a tax increase to First Student busing. One such parent was Melissa Whalen, who has a special needs child in the district. She’s worried about her child’s transportation moving forward.

“It’s unconscionable to me that a group of elected officials are so blatantly ignoring the will of the community that elected them,” Whalen said. “... Personally, as a taxpayer here in Scott Township, I would prefer my tax dollars going to treat these people right, the people that have been there for my special needs child every day.”

Advertise with us

None of the public commenters spoke in favor of the contract. When board directors approved it, boos and yells erupted from the crowd.

Directors in favor of the contract included Ed Brosky, Jeff Choura, Kate Drury, Louise Huehn and Darren Mariano. Those against were Mark Fiorilli, Mitchell Montani, Megan Sexton and Lisa Trainor.

Fiorilli, who has two children in the district, said he voted against the contract because he believes students should feel “safe and comfortable” going to and from school every day.

“This all became about money, and not about the kids,” he said. “It’s supposed to be about our kids and education.”

The district’s contract with First Student begins on July 1 and will run through June 30, 2033. The company partners with numerous other school districts in Western Pennsylvania, including Pittsburgh Public Schools. Chartiers Valley serves students from Bridgeville, Heidelberg, Collier and Scott.

Advertise with us

The new contract will guarantee raises for transportation employees, sign-on bonuses for new hires, benefits for part-time drivers, and modernization of the fleet, Castagna said.

As part of the deal, First Student will buy the district’s fleet of more than 70 school buses — which transport 3,400 students every day — for roughly $2.8 million.