Saddled with college debt and recently unemployed, Jamie Harrington knew he needed a “hard reset.”

The 35-year-old, who has a bachelor’s degree in history and graduate certificate in geospatial technologies from the Indiana University of Pennsylvania, was let go from a Pittsburgh financial institution earlier this year. Despite his education and more than a decade of work experience, Mr. Harrington faced upward of 100 job rejections.

That’s when the Beaver resident decided to pivot his entire career. This fall, he enrolled at the Community College of Beaver County to earn an associate degree in advanced manufacturing and process technology.

When Mr. Harrington graduates in several years, he expects to earn between $39 to $47 an hour at a plant.

Advertise with us

He’ll also have a job and skillset that he believes will make him “bulletproof” from recessions, offshoring and artificial intelligence.

“I've lived it for 15 years now — what the job [market] is like,” Mr. Harrington said. “They tell you this college degree is going to open up doors for you when in actuality, it really doesn't anymore.”

Mr. Harrington isn’t the first to perceive — or directly experience — the wavering value of a traditional college education.

Nearly two-thirds of American voters believe a four-year college degree isn’t worth the cost, found a November poll by NBC News. Traditional college enrollment has been on a gradual decline over the past decade, with young men making up larger portions of these losses, reported Pew Research Center.

Of those turning away from a four-year degree, many are turning toward the skilled trades.

Advertise with us

More young adults, particularly young men, are beginning to picture themselves as electricians, welders and construction workers — and in turn considering the benefits of working an essential, good paying job with a relatively low entry fee.

This spring, nationwide enrollment in high vocational public two-year institutions grew nearly 12%, reported National Student Clearinghouse. Since 2020, enrollment at trade-focused schools has jumped almost 20%.

In Pennsylvania, enrollment at vocational-technical schools increased more than 13% between 2018 and 2023. These schools enrolled more than 62,400 students during the 2023-24 school year, according to the most recent data available from the state Department of Education.

It’s a pattern that high schools across the region are reporting.

“Overwhelmingly, we’re seeing much higher interest among young men in pursuing the trades,” said Laura Thomson, South Allegheny school district’s workforce development coordinator.

Advertise with us

‘Shift that narrative’

When people ask Joey Gamret what his plans are after graduation, they’re often surprised to hear they don’t involve attending a four-year university.

Joey, a senior at South Allegheny High School, is a star running back on the school’s football team. Rather than continuing his football career in college, though, he plans to join the Iron Workers union.

He’s always been more of a hands-on worker.

“I guess getting a free education is a good opportunity. Me personally, I feel like I'd rather just go to the trades and make money,” Joey said.

He and 30 of his classmates piled into a full school bus in October to attend the Builders Guild trade-focused career fair in the Convention Center Downtown.

Advertise with us

More than 3,500 students from southwestern Pennsylvania went to the two-day event, which showcased opportunities in 16 trades.

The trades are seeing heightened interest from Generation Z, said Paul Ribarchak, apprentice coordinator for Iron Workers Local Union 3.

When he was in high school, it felt like the trades were a “secret society.” Now, more students, parents and schools are realizing that these fields offer a real career avenue.

Typically, students enter the trades through one of two pathways: apprenticeship or trade school. Apprenticeships train students while paying them over several years, while trade schools involve classroom instruction and hands-on experience in a shorter time period.

Apprentices with the Iron Workers earn nearly $28 an hour. After three years, these apprentices can become journeymen, starting at $41.50 an hour, Mr. Ribarchak said.

Advertise with us

Upon retirement, an ironworker with a 40-year career will receive a $6,000-per-month pension check.

“For a young person wanting to make money, it's a no-brainer,” Mr. Ribarchak said.

October’s trade fair wasn’t just informational. Appealing to students with an itch for hands-on work, many of the trades had interactive aspects at their stations.

At the Iron Workers booth, students could climb a mini column, simulating real work that ironworkers do. Meanwhile, the carpentry booth allowed students to try their hand at using power tools.

Aiden Schane, a South Allegheny senior who plays on the varsity basketball team, is interested in going into carpentry. Aiden cited debt as a top reason he’s opting for the trades over a four-year degree. Carpentry also runs in the family; his grandfather is a carpenter.

Advertise with us

“More kids my age are opening up their eyes,” Aiden said. “It’s a way better plan than going to college.”

South Allegheny just recently began taking a more aggressive approach to introducing students to the trades. The goal was to ensure every student had a career plan upon graduation, said Ms. Thomson.

Now, South Allegheny regularly invites workers with the trades to speak to students, and takes students on trips to trade-focused events like October’s career fair. When a student enters an agreement with a trade union, the district holds a signing similar to those done for student athletes.

The post-secondary focus was once heavily weighted toward four-year degrees. Now, school officials tailor each student’s outlook to their interests and life goals.

"It takes all of us to shift that narrative,” Ms. Thomson said. “Exposure and experience are key.”

Advertise with us

‘Something is definitely different now’

Carrick High School instructor Carl Uccellini walks down two flights of stairs to get to his classroom in the Pittsburgh Public building.

Mr. Uccellini — or “Mr. U,” as his students call him — technically has two classrooms. The first is a traditional set up, with desks, posters and a whiteboard.

The second is a massive lab dedicated to the school’s carpentry program, which Mr. Uccellini leads.

Carrick High School carpentry student William Garrett works on a project during class, Tuesday, Dec. 9, 2025, in Carrick. (Alexandra Wimley / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Every day, for roughly two and a half hours, 22 juniors and seniors learn to build home essentials such as rafters and stairs, while also receiving their OSHA certification.

They’ve even constructed a small home that sits in the school’s back parking lot.

Advertise with us

Mr. Uccellini, who has taught carpentry at Carrick since 2013, has watched students’ interest in the program grow. Even over the past five years, he said the stigma surrounding the trades — whether it be from students or parents — has dropped drastically.

“I don’t know if the student debt situation turned things around, but something is definitely different now,” he said.

Mr. Uccellini regularly takes his students on field trips to view construction sites in the area. On a wall in Mr. Uccellini’s classroom are the smiling faces of several Carrick graduates who have gone on to work at local construction sites, including the new airport terminal and Hillman Library.

Carrick is one of six Pittsburgh Public high schools that offers career and technical education programs.

Fifteen years ago, the labs to these CTE programs were shut down. The district worked with local unions to get the programs up and running again, said Angela Mike, executive director of Pittsburgh Public’s CTE program.

Advertise with us

Now — as a growing number of students are expressing interest in the trades — parents are getting on board, counselors are being equipped to offer these students guidance, and Carrick is looking to hire another carpentry instructor.

“I think people are finally starting to catch onto the job forecast,” Ms. Mike said. “Technical careers are the new direction.”

And just because a student is trades-bound, doesn’t mean he or she won’t eventually attend college, noted Brie Adams, the district’s CTE supervisor.

That’s the case for Ahmed Suhail, a junior at Carrick enrolled in the carpentry program. Right now, he’s thinking about entering the carpenter’s union after graduation, and then eventually attending college to become a safety manager.

He’s already applied the skills he’s learned in class to his own life. Ahmed was recently able to help his dad complete a flooring project.

Advertise with us

The essential nature of carpentry is a big draw for Ahmed. Having a good time in class helps, too.

“This class has chemistry. We all get along and we all have fun here,” he said.

‘AI proof’

In Mr. Uccellini’s view, part of the reason that the trades are becoming an “easier sell” is because of the good pay and job security.

Many of his former students are the breadwinners of their families. They know their income source largely can't be disrupted by offshoring or artificial intelligence.

And even though technology used in the trades changes, demand for these professions doesn’t. Skilled carpenters are considered a severe need in Pennsylvania, Mr. Uccellini said.

Advertise with us

“Construction jobs will always be around,” he said.

Lance Harrell, director of workforce development with the Master Builders’ Association of Western Pennsylvania, also stressed the stability of the trades in the age of AI. After all, Google Gemini can’t hang drywall, and ChatGPT can’t install a drop ceiling. “The trades are AI proof,” he said.

“If you’ve been to the hospital, the airport, across the bridge, go to the stadium — that’s a trade,” Mr. Harrell said. “Without the trades, you wouldn’t have a roof over your head.”

In the 2000s and early 2010s, Mr. Harrington, of CCBC, said students were fed a narrative that they had to go to college.

Now, as he and his peers struggle with debt and watch some jobs dry up, perspectives are changing.

Advertise with us

“At this point, higher education — unless you want self-fulfillment — It's just not worth the money you have to pay,” Mr. Harrington said.

“I’m glad Gen Z is figuring this out.”