Gen Z has a bad reputation.
The generation behind TikTok trends of “quiet quitting” and “lazy girl jobs” is often considered unreliable, entitled and lazy. They have one of the shortest attention spans — coming in at a resounding 8 seconds. And they’ve grown up glued to their phones and other screens.
But they’re tales — and stereotypes — as old as time.
High schools across southwestern Pennsylvania are filled with bustling teenagers, many of whom clutch classic novels assigned by English teachers. The students, who, sure, are likely addicted to their phones — much like everyone regardless of age — often make time for reading by multitasking or filling empty periods throughout their school days with their noses in books.
“I like certain things we read more than others, but I actually look forward to when we read a full-length work that we spend a while on,” 17-year-old junior Emilio Campos, a Shaler Area School District junior, said.
Last year, a slew of reports detailed how several English classrooms across America were failing to give assignments that required reading full-length novels. Instead, teachers were relying on excerpts or chapter summaries to teach certain texts.
Read More
But that’s seemingly not happening in districts across the Pittsburgh region, interviews with leaders and teachers from a handful of area schools found.
“A lot of that is lost if you're just giving them a chunk,” Anne Loudon, a Shaler Area School District English teacher, said. “I could see where there might be value in giving an excerpt if it's a book that lends itself to that, but I don't agree with the trend of just giving them excerpts because it's easier, or whatever the rationale is.”
Reading full novels has a myriad of benefits, Carla Meyer, associate professor and reading clinic director at Duquesne University, said, including helping students become stronger readers and allowing them to gain a better understanding of the context, characters and setting.
“They’re becoming part of the world that they're reading about and I think when you do a shortened excerpt, you do not gain that full awareness of what is happening in the text, how it's affecting the characters, that idea of walking in somebody's shoes,” Ms. Meyer said.
But even as kids are reading books for school, at least locally, an apparent literacy crisis is taking place nationwide as reading scores on standardized tests remain low. And nationwide, some college professors have suggested students are coming to higher education with fewer reading skills and distracted thinking.
Those impacts stem from several factors, experts say, including the pandemic and technology.
During the pandemic students were forced to learn online as school buildings closed. But since then, standardized test scores have struggled to return to pre-pandemic levels.
Nationwide, reading scores for fourth and eighth graders fell 2 points on the National Assessment of Educational Progress, the Associated Press reported. One-third of eighth graders scored below basic in reading, more than ever in the history of the assessment.
In Pennsylvania, standardized test scores from the 2023-24 school year saw improved numbers in math and science. But English language arts saw a slight decline, dropping from 54.5% in 2022-23 to 53.9% in 2023-24.
“When something that big happens and disrupts the educational process, it is going to have an impact,” Ms. Meyer said.
Tom Ralston, an assistant professor at the University of Pittsburgh who previously worked in K-12 education, added that kids today also aren’t reading on their own time.
Federal data found that in 2022 39% of 9-year-olds reported reading for fun, 3 percentage points lower than what was reported in 2020. And 16% reported that they never or hardly ever read for fun. Those numbers worsened for 13-year-olds. In 2023, 14% of students reported reading for fun almost every day. But 31% said they never or hardly ever read for fun.
The problem, Mr. Ralston said, comes down to social media and technology.
“They're consuming media in a different way,” Mr. Ralston said. “When they're on their own they are watching TikTok a lot, and they like YouTube channels and different things like that, which certainly they have their strengths as well, but it's just they're shifting their focus away from what kids were doing probably 20-25 years ago, which is having a real interest in certain genres of literary areas and certain authors.”
Local tactics
Bella Minyo often has a book in her hand.
Study halls tucked into her Shaler High School schedule have become quiet reading periods for the 17-year-old senior. And her nose is often in a novel as she eats lunch and dinner.
Bella is currently taking AP English literature and composition, a class, she said, that has a “pretty strict reading schedule” consisting of up to three books per unit.
But Bella, who enjoys writing her own short stories, doesn’t mind the reading assignments.
“It gives you a better understanding of the entire meaning of the book in context of what the author's intentions were. … I feel like with excerpts, you're missing a lot of that when you're reading it. Like you don't understand certain meanings before and afterwards,” Bella said. “And it sort of takes away from the meaning of the writing as a whole.”
At Shaler, English teachers will often use a mix of full texts and excerpts, which are used to supplement a lesson. Ms. Loudon pointed to a time when she taught the memoir “Lost Names” to 10th graders. During the unit she had students read a chapter from “The Joy Luck Club” that fit thematically into the lesson.
“It helped enhance what they already had,” Ms. Loudon said. “And then, for some, it sparked curiosity for wanting to read the entire novel.”
But full-length novels, she said, allow students to get the full effect of the book while grasping the author’s intention and studying concepts such as plot, rising action and climax.
Pittsburgh Public Schools English teachers follow a similar method.
According to Ann Fillmore, executive director of literacy and library services, the district uses myPerspectives, an online language arts curriculum program. Through the program, each unit includes a main novel. And other texts are also utilized within the units including excerpts, poetry, informational books and fiction depending on the unit.
The mix, Ms. Fillmore said, “provides students with the opportunity to access texts from different perspectives, multiple texts, so that they are able to engage in some critical thinking and discussion.” Multiple texts also allow teachers to meet state standards.
“The demand of those standards is pretty rigorous, so it's important that students are practicing their skills and reading multiple texts that address those standards,” Ms. Fillmore said.
But having full texts at the center, Ms. Fillmore said, provides additional benefits.
“It's important to read a novel so that you're able to get the full perspective of that author, experience the novel for what the author's intent was,” Ms. Fillmore said. “But also to be able to obtain information and gather information around a certain topic is incredibly important when students are reviewing and analyzing perspectives, seeing different lived experiences and understanding the world around them.”
At Baldwin-Whitehall, Krystal Schulte, an English teacher, added that having students read full novels helps prepare them for college. She pointed to an October article by The Atlantic in which several college professors said students were bewildered by assignments requiring them to read multiple books.
“We absolutely do not want that to happen to our students,” Ms. Schulte said.
She also cited the book “Stolen Focus: Why You Can't Pay Attention” by Johann Hari. The author, Ms. Schulte said, found that taking time to read full novels, especially the classics, helped him to fully understand what he was reading and to think critically about the novel.
She noted that in talking to other AP literature teachers across the country, many were upset with the implication that full texts are not being read in high school.
Back at Shaler, Emilio is enrolled in the AP language and composition class. So far, the class has read two plays, “All the King’s Men” and “Fences.”
Reading full novels and plays, he said, allows students to immerse themselves in the books, something that can’t be done with a short story.
“It doesn't really feel like a chore like I feel like it might to some other people,” Emilio said. “I typically enjoy to read. I read for pleasure sometimes, so [it’s] not too bad.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.