Pennsylvania has rolled back controversial cultural competency standards after they were challenged last year by a conservative law group that claimed they violated teachers’ First Amendment rights and encroached upon school districts’ authority to establish curriculum.
The Pennsylvania Department of Education, in a mediated settlement agreement Wednesday, agreed to rescind the Culturally Relevant and Sustaining Education Program, which provided professional development principles and competencies for teacher preparation programs and professional development that aimed to create an inclusive learning environment for students. The department also agreed to notify school districts that they no longer are required to comply with the regulations.
“This has been a longstanding battle and it's consistent with the other fights that we've undertaken to ensure that the government acts appropriately and in accordance with its requirements,” attorney Thomas King, who represented the plaintiffs, told the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette.
The state on Friday issued new guidance to school leaders promoting Common Ground standards, which encourage districts to understand and relate to students experiencing different situations such as food insecurity, trauma and a military lifestyle, among other things, department spokeswoman Erin James said in a statement.
“PDE is proud to offer this resource as an improvement on previously issued guidance, with an expanded focus on digital literacy, mental health and trauma – real issues that impact those in all spaces of learning within every Pennsylvania community,” Ms. James said.
The agreement Wednesday came after three school districts — Mars Area, Laurel and Penncrest — two teachers, several board members and parents sued the education department in April 2023 in Commonwealth Court.
The goal of the suit — funded by the Chicago-based Thomas More Society, a conservative public-interest law center that focuses heavily on pro-life litigation — was to stop the department from implementing the new standards, which asked teachers to acknowledge that bias exists in the education system and to integrate multiple perspectives into teachings to “capitalize on learners’ real-world experiences, identities, and heritage,” the guidelines read.
The standards were part of amendments made in 2022 that required teachers to be trained in culturally relevant and sustaining education. They went into effect in the 2023-24 school year.
The lawsuit claimed the program violated teachers’ First Amendment rights and breached petitioners’ constitutional rights. It said the program usurped local authority of districts to implement curriculum and called for “improper civil disobedience” because it required “educators to ‘disrupt’ lawfully enacted policies and practices of school districts.”
Competencies in the standards that the Thomas More Society questioned when the settlement was announced Wednesday included designing learning experiences that allow students to “identify and question economic, political, and social power structures in the school, community, nation, and world;” believing and acknowledging that microaggressions are real; and disrupting “harmful institutional practices, policies and norms by advocating and engaging in efforts to rewrite policies, change practices and raise awareness.”
The suit also alleged the program was unconstitutionally vague and violated the Regulatory Review Act, the Code of Professional Practice and Conduct for Educators and the Nondelegation Doctrine.
“Our attack wasn't directed toward race or gender or equality,” Mr. King said. “It was directed toward the lack of compliance by the Department of Education with the proper adoption of these things. But also the regulations themselves were well beyond anything that the government could impose on its citizens.”
Thomas Breth, special counsel for the Thomas More Society, said in a statement that the “agreement is a triumph against the Department’s blatantly ideological and illegal attempt to inject ‘woke’ activism into school curricula across Pennsylvania, which demanded educators affirm their belief in these ideological tenets and then impose the same upon their students.”
The education department, in its letter to districts, encouraged but did not require schools to incorporate Common Ground Framework into their continuing professional development plans. It includes three sets of competencies for teacher training: cultural awareness; trauma-aware, mental health and wellness; and technological and virtual engagement. The goal is to help educators create an inclusive learning environment for all students.
As for the cultural competency standards, it is now up to school boards to determine whether they want to implement something similar at the local level, Mr. King said.
“Local school boards are best suited to decide these kinds of things as opposed to the Department of Education,” Mr. King said. “And so it's perfectly all right if some school districts like these regulations, they can adopt them in their own district if they want.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.