Carnegie Mellon University is among 40 private colleges being accused in a lawsuit filed this week of price-fixing strategies that impact students with divorced or separated parents.
The class-action lawsuit alleges that CMU and other schools have artificially reduced the amount of aid that students with divorced or separated parents could receive by factoring noncustodial parents’ finances into aid determinations.
In doing so, the suit claims that impacted students pay an average of $6,200 more for their education compared to those at private institutions that don’t consider noncustodial parents’ finances.
“That concerted action substantially raised the prices that [impacted students] pay to attend college,” part of the complaint reads. “Absent this agreement, the [universities] would have competed in offering financial aid in order to enroll their top candidates.”
CMU did not respond to a request for comment on Wednesday. The university’s admissions website says CMU requires noncustodial parents’ financial information, though applicants who have no contact with that parent can request that this requirement is waived.
“Financial aid eligibility is based on demonstrated financial need, not on a parent’s willingness to pay for education,” a statement on the website reads. “However, Carnegie Mellon recognizes that every family is different and want to be sure to understand your family’s circumstances as they assess your eligibility for aid.”
Other notable universities named in the suit include the University of Pennsylvania, Harvard University, Columbia University and Syracuse University.
The suit was brought on by Boston University student Maxwell Hansen and Cornell University alumna Eileen Chang.
Mr. Hansen’s father has not contributed to his tuition costs, but his income is factored into Mr. Hansen’s aid package, the suit says.
Meanwhile, Ms. Chang’s noncustodial parent is on disability, has a “much higher income” than her custodial parent and is unable to contribute to tuition costs. Ms. Chang asked Cornell’s financial aid office if the university could remove her noncustodial parent’s income from aid consideration, but she was told that noncustodial parents are expected to help pay tuition costs, the suit says.
Both students pay “artificially high prices” that have caused them “financial harm,” the suit alleges.
The pricing strategy in question was developed by the College Board in 2006 with help from the universities named in the suit, according to the complaint. College Board, a nonprofit organization with more than 6,000 member organizations, is also being sued.
The complaint, filed in U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Illinois on Monday, claims that the universities have violated the Sherman Antitrust Act by artificially “fixing, raising, stabilizing and reducing” the amount of aid that impacted students could receive.
The suit demands a jury trial. Mr. Hansen, Ms. Chang and class members are being represented by Seattle-based law firm Hagens Berman.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.