Nearly 30 people gathered outside the Pittsburgh Public Schools administration building in Oakland Monday afternoon to rally against the potential closure of school buildings.

The rally, which started an hour before the school board’s scheduled public hearing, was organized by the advocacy organization 412 Justice. It drew dozens of people who chanted “Fund our schools” and “Nothing about us without us” as they called on school directors and administrators to reconsider plans that could lead to the possible closure and consolidation of some schools as the district faces a growing budget deficit and declining enrollments.

“Enough is enough,” Jazlynn Worthy, whose child attends Woolslair, said during the rally. “At what point will someone recognize that these repeated actions are ineffective? We have to continue to speak truth and hold those who have the power to make these decisions accountable. We cannot stand by and watch another person or in this instance this particular group of people make the decision that does more harm for our families than good.”

Behind her, parents and students held signs reading “Closing school = broken communities,” “Closing Black schools is racist” and “Our schools, our cities, our voice.”

Advertise with us

The rally followed months of community pushback after the district in October said they were considering closing some schools based on a growing budget deficit that is expected to reach $23 million this year and declining enrollments that has led to the district educating 18,380 students when it has the capacity to house 40,000. That means, officials previously said, that 28 out of 54 school buildings are operating at or below 50% capacity.

In response, district officials this month presented a proposed framework for a facilities utilization plan, the blueprint that could lead to closures and consolidations.

The framework, which did not have a list of schools that could be closed or consolidated, featured 12 possible recommendations including the creation of a class structure that streamlines students into PreK-5 and 6-8 rather than having some students in PreK-8 and 6-12 schools. The recommendations were based on factors such as current building utilization, facility conditions, educational adequacy, teacher shortages, transportation challenges and student support services.

School directors are now expected to vote Wednesday on contracting with Massachusetts-based consultant Education Resource Strategies to work on the facilities utilization plan, according to Wednesday’s meeting agenda. The contract would not exceed $248,270.

But the proposed plans have continued to receive pushback from parents and residents who have raised concerns over the amount of transparency from the district throughout the process and the impacts closures could have, particularly on students of color and the communities in which they live.

Advertise with us

“You say these children — all colors, brown kids, all of us — are our future, but what future will they have if you’re just ripping it away from them,” parent Shakira Baker said at the rally.

She suggested that moving kids from their community schools will deprive them of staff and teachers who understand where they are coming from and who can cater to their specific needs and backgrounds. Ms. Baker added that consolidating schools will also lead to larger class sizes, impacting teachers who are already struggling each day.

Parent Naomi Chambers agreed, suggesting that the district is going for “low-hanging fruit” that will predominantly impact Black and brown communities.

“Y'all have to stop this game,” Ms. Chambers said. “Start to invest in the schools. That’s how you invest in the families, that’s how you invest in education. We need it. … We can’t do much without an education. We need to learn to be able to get to the next stages of things so we can invest in our own communities.”

Several speakers during the nearly two-hour public hearing also spoke out against school closures, including Hetal Dhagat, a senior attorney at the Pennsylvania-based Education Law Center. Ms. Dhagat said the district needs to consider several factors in the facilities utilization plan, such as how closures will impact neighborhoods. And she suggested that PPS needs to look at more than just facility utilization rates when making final decisions and take public comment more seriously.

Advertise with us

Laura Petty, an attorney with the Washington D.C. Advancement Project, agreed, adding that the district has other options instead of closing schools, such as using the facilities utilization process to provide school communities, particularly those that have been historically marginalized, with resources and supports that they need.

“Right now I just see problems,” parent Hallie Pritts said during the hearing. “I’m concerned that in an effort to do something about the budget problem, we’re going for the hammer, the loudest, bluntest implement — that we’re closing schools so we can say ‘Well, we tried something.’”

Others raised concerns about hiring another consultant — with many pointing out that the district recently hired a consultant to complete a districtwide strategic plan — that could cost hundreds of thousands of dollars.

“Hiring a consultant is a waste of money,” student Lilly Allman said. “Every time we hire a consultant they say they’re going to include everybody but they don’t. … We are always promised that we will have a say with what will happen to us and our community, but what we receive is just empty promises.”

Ms. Worthy, whose child attends Woolslair, said it’s now time for the district to address ongoing issues rather than choosing “the lazy way out.”

“Now is the time to use our voices to demand a seat at the table,” Ms. Worthy said, “and now is the time to use our voices to speak solutions. Now is the time to tell them it is the time to stop.”