Ricky Lizarraga did everything right. The West Mifflin Area senior applied to colleges early. He submitted his Free Application for Federal Student Aid on time. He decided he wanted to study criminology in the fall.

But those right steps didn’t count for much during a college application season that has been plagued with unprecedented mistakes and delays because of the revamped FAFSA form. Nationally, thousands of high school seniors, including Mr. Lizarraga, are still waiting to hear how much federal aid they would receive if they attend different colleges this fall.

In a normal year, students would be sorting through their financial aid offers by now. They would have weeks, maybe even months, to prepare for the traditional decision day on May 1. Some might have moved on to picking out twin XL bedding for their dorms and sharing their school of choice on graduation party invitations. Many would be sitting in the final weeks of their high school careers wearing sweatshirts sporting their future college.

This isn’t a normal year. As commitment deadlines edge closer, uncertainty and anxiety have been festering for students whose decisions are stalled by incomplete pictures of how much different colleges will cost them. Because of the delays in the rollout, many schools are still processing FAFSA information to give financial aid offers to students.

Advertise with us

The Post-Gazette spoke to several regional high school seniors whose decisions and futures have been impacted by the tumultuous launch of the updated form.

For Mr. Lizarraga, the waiting — and general financial concerns as college costs balloon every year — eventually prompted him to pivot his future plans, making a “last minute” decision in late March.

Read More

Rather than attend one of the 20 colleges he applied to, Mr. Lizarraga will enlist in the Navy. He’ll take some college credits during active duty, and if he doesn’t earn his degree then, he’ll attend one of the colleges he was accepted into, such as the University of Pittsburgh, Duquesne University or Ohio State. The Navy will cover all tuition costs.

“I was worried about how much I would get in financial aid and [whether] it would be enough because I don’t want to live in any type of debt. Even with the highest amount they would give me, I’d still be in a considerable amount of debt. The Navy will take care of that,” said Mr. Lizarraga, whose involvement at West Mifflin includes serving as class president, participating in marching band and running on the track team.

“The delay definitely didn't help because I wasn't sure what I was going to do or where to go. ... It definitely impacted my future.”

Advertise with us

Waiting on packages

In previous years, the FAFSA portal opened in October, and students’ forms were processed by the Department of Education in around a week. Students then waited to hear from individual colleges about aid. Depending on the college, financial aid letters were usually sent within several weeks of schools receiving FAFSA information.

This year, the department released a simplified version of the application that has been in the works since 2020. That updated FAFSA aimed to make a tedious form less daunting.

But hiccups in the launch began months ago. The form was initially supposed to be available in October. Instead, the new application — riddled with technology issues — was released in late December.

Challenges didn’t stop there. Delayed transfers of financial information to colleges and miscalculations further hindered the federal aid process for both students and colleges.

Colleges are now scrambling to send their financial aid packages to prospective students. Those packages provide students and families with information on how much federal, state and institutional aid students will receive if they attend a certain college.

Advertise with us

In the Pittsburgh region, Duquesne, Point Park University and Robert Morris University have begun sending packages. Slippery Rock University said on Wednesday that the school planned to start sending packages by the end of last week.

As for Pitt, Penn State and the Indiana University of Pennsylvania, each school aims to send their packages throughout the remainder of the month.

To assuage the impact of delays on students, most of these schools have pushed back their decision deadlines, traditionally May 1, to May 15 or June 1. The Pennsylvania Higher Education Assistance Agency also extended its deadline to fill out the FAFSA for state grant purposes from May 1 to June 1.

But students still end up with more limited time frames — in some cases, less than a month — to consider colleges with complete financial options in mind.

“For me, [cost] is a big thing I consider when choosing a school. I want to know how much I'm going to pay,” said Dylan Swierczynski, a senior at Greensburg Salem High School. “... When I'm going to make this final decision, [I want to] compare prices and see what it's going to come down to after aid — but I can't do that without any sort of response from the schools.”

Advertise with us

As of Monday, Mr. Swierczynski hadn’t received financial packages from any of the colleges that accepted him. Three other students interviewed by the Post-Gazette throughout the month of April said they hadn’t received their packages yet, either.

Mr. Swierczynski has narrowed his options to Penn State, West Virginia University and the University of Utah. An ice hockey player, he plans to study business.

He described the entire FAFSA process as “stressful.” Anthony Waddell, a senior at Central Catholic High School, agreed.

People ask Mr. Waddell where he plans to attend college. He can’t give them an answer right now, as he’s waiting to hear about financial aid. Mr. Waddell, who is part of Central Catholic’s Black Student Union, plans to study business at Duquesne, Robert Morris or IUP.

“I want to graduate with the least amount of debt possible,” Mr. Waddell said. “[The FAFSA delay] definitely does make it difficult [to decide]. It’s just stressful.”

Advertise with us

Other students, such as Bethel Park senior Madelyn Sams, are fairly certain which school they’ll attend, but are still waiting for financial aid packages to make their final decision.

Going into her senior year, Ms. Sams was excited to apply to colleges, select a school and start preparing for the next stage of her life.

Now, with financial aid packages at a standstill, it’s “hard to feel like you’re moving on,” said Ms. Sams, who intends to study nursing at Penn State’s Behrend campus.

“A few of my friends have been talking and we’re just wondering how people have committed already,” said Ms. Sams, who serves as president of Bethel Park’s Student Government Association and a squad leader for the marching band. “Good for them if they’ve gotten a scholarship already [or] if they can pay for [tuition], but we’re definitely waiting for that financial aspect.”

The future for FAFSA

Experts are concerned that this year’s debacle could have a long-term impact on enrollment and trust in the financial aid process.

Advertise with us

Locally and nationally, FAFSA submissions have dropped significantly this year. Completion rates are lower than they were at the height of the pandemic, said Ellie Bruecker, interim director of research at the Institute for College Access and Success.

Ms. Bruecker worries that this could impact fall enrollments.

“If we’re seeing FAFSA completions this far behind, I think it is logical that we're going to see some declines in enrollment,” she said. “We don’t know what those are going to look like, but I think we have a good idea of where they’re going to be… I think they’re going to be concentrated among students with more financial need and students of color.”

And it could erode trust in the Department of Education and FAFSA process for millions of college students and families, she said.

From a student’s perspective, Ms. Sams, of Bethel Park, believes transparency and effective financial processes are key to enjoying the college experience.

“At the end of the day, this is a contract you’re signing,” Ms. Sams said. “Obviously, you want to enjoy the school you go to. Part of that enjoyment is knowing what they’re giving you and knowing that it's a trustworthy institution.”