Despite community pushback, Pittsburgh Public School directors are moving forward with creating a plan that could lead to the closure and consolidation of some district buildings.
School directors on Wednesday approved a motion in a 6-3 vote that directs district administration to develop and present recommendations on a facilities utilization plan. School directors Jamie Piotrowski, Devon Taliaferro and Emma Yourd voted against the measure.
It comes months after Pittsburgh Public officials first announced they were considering closing some schools as the district faces a growing budget deficit and declining enrollment.
“I know that this is a difficult conversation and this is not one that we as school board members are going to ever want to have. … I’m not saying our hair’s on fire, but our hair is kind of on fire,” school director Tracey Reed said. “We really need to have this conversation. We cannot continue to kick the can down the road. We have to begin to think expeditiously, strategically.”
Board president Gene Walker, who introduced the resolution with Superintendent Wayne Walters, said the goal is to have a plan that would give school officials an in-depth understanding of how the district’s 54 school buildings are being used while also looking at how resources within each building are serving students to ensure they are provided with the “education that they deserve.” The report would also be used by the district’s human resources and finance departments to provide input on how Pittsburgh Public can improve its finances.
Under the resolution, work to compile the report will include “broad community outreach” including public hearings. A preliminary plan must be submitted to the board by March 15.
Read More
School directors started the most recent discussions around school closures in October. At the time, district officials expressed concerns over a budget deficit that increased to $29.9 million in the 2024 budget. If those financial constraints continue, Mr. Walker said, “we’re going to be out of money in two years” unless the board takes action such as consolidating buildings. Other concerns included declining enrollment. Currently, the district’s school buildings have room for 40,000 students but Pittsburgh Public only enrolls around 19,000 students.
But that conversation quickly sparked pushback among community members.
During a December budget public hearing, a handful of district parents and residents spoke out against school closures, many expressing concerns that Woolslair PreK-5 in Bloomfield would be closed. The school was included in a 2021 proposal from the district that suggested closing six schools including Miller PreK-5 in the Hill District; Fulton PreK-5 in Highland Park; Woolslair; Manchester PreK-8 in Manchester; Allegheny 6-8 in the North Side; and Arsenal 6-8 in Lawrenceville.
The district has not yet announced which schools it could consider closing. But concerns over the facilities utilization plan, placed on the agenda after last week’s workshop meeting, have continued throughout the week.
412 Justice, a Pittsburgh-based advocacy organization that works toward economic, environmental and education justice, this week posted a letter to Mr. Walters in which they called the plan an “unacceptable non-transparent backroom deal.”
“Where is democracy in this process? It’s problematic that we have a Board and Superintendent, Dr. Wayne Walters, who doesn’t value meaningful community input and misses the opportunity for innovation and critical thinking in addressing budget deficits,” the letter reads. “It is lazy to close schools and move students around like widgets when data show the devastating consequences and impact for all students, and the most detrimental for poor Black students, English language learners, and students with disabilities.”
The group suggested that “whoever votes for this resolution will have blood on your hands.”
The organization also made three demands to the board: vote no to the resolution or take it off the table, consider data and research for past school closures and consolidations in the district. and take into account community input on the proposed strategic planning framework.
Pushback also came from some board members, including Ms. Piotrowski, who put forward a motion to table the vote until next month after raising concerns that the resolution was not included on last week’s agenda. That motion ultimately failed. Others suggested that the resolution will work toward goals preliminarily identified for the district’s strategic plan.
“Part of the strategic plan is an examination of our school district’s footprint and how we may or may not right size that,” Ms. Yourd said. “This resolution feels like it’s getting in front of the strategic plan that would be shared with us ideally in February so I don’t want to vote on a resolution prematurely before we’re hearing about any input from the strategic plan and before the school administration would act on the strategic plan.”
Ms. Taliaferro agreed. She added school directors received little information on the resolution, something the community often reacts to.
“When the conversation about facilities utilization came up in the past it has always sparked the concern of the community because our community values their neighborhood schools, the buildings that occupy those communities. … When we are not transparent about how we go about doing that it causes mistrust in community,” Ms. Taliaferro said. “I’ve always said I’m not afraid to have the conversation about how we modernize our footprint but I will not have that conversation without the voice of the community.”
In response, Mr. Walker said he understood those concerns but suggested that delaying the resolution would only hold up work that will need to be done regardless of what input the district receives on the strategic plan. He said the two documents will be used together to make future decisions for the district.
“The pain that we feel now doing the work,” Mr. Walker said, “is much less than the pain we will feel if we don’t do any of this work now and we just wait a little bit longer.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.