Many yellow diesel school buses that have long contributed to air pollution and have been linked to child asthma are slated for a green makeover to the tune of nearly $1 billion.
The funding, coming from the $1.2 trillion bipartisan infrastructure law, will be administered by the Environmental Protection Agency in the latest round of grants for its Clean School Bus program, which launched with an inaugural round of rebates in 2022.
The program aims to shield children and their communities from the negative impacts of air pollution by replacing old diesel school buses with clean electric bus fleets, all while reducing greenhouse gas emissions. A total of $5 billion was earmarked for the program, about $2 billion of which has already been dispersed.
Pennsylvania is expected to receive more than $47 million for zero-emissions buses in five school districts in low-income communities across the state, including the Pittsburgh Public Schools.
The EPA prioritized applications from school districts that meet a certain income-poverty threshold, which policymakers determined are disproportionately impacted by air pollution.
Of that $47 million, First Student, the school bus company that serves the Pittsburgh schools, will receive almost $40 million to purchase 100 clean school buses, an estimated 45 of which will serve the Pittsburgh area.
Read More
“Kids in the left-behind communities of Western Pennsylvania have higher rates of asthma compared to the rest of the country as a direct result of air pollution,” U.S. Rep. Summer Lee, D-Swissvale, said in a news release from earlier this month.
The American Lung Association consistently ranks Allegheny County among the worst metropolitan areas for air quality. In 2023, children under 18 were one of the most at-risk population groups for the effects of air pollution in Pittsburgh.
A 2022 study between the University of Pittsburgh and UPMC found that more children visit the emergency room for asthma in Allegheny County when the air quality is poor. The study used the real time air quality index, or AQI, to determine when children are most affected by poor air quality.
Even on days when air quality was moderate, or safe for most people, children, whose lungs are still developing, suffered asthma complications and were hospitalized.
Kevin Matthews, head of electrification at First Student, said the funding will bring several fleets of new electric buses to the Pittsburgh Public School district.
The Pittsburgh Public School District is the largest in Allegheny County and the second largest in Pennsylvania, with about 19,000 K-12 students. Many of those schools are in environmental justice communities- areas disproportionately harmed by the negative effects of air pollution.
The road from conditional grant approval to operational clean buses is a long one, however, paved with power concerns.
The electric school buses require extensive charging infrastructure in order to be operational, which demands large amounts of power from local grids and utilities. The Clean School Bus program lacks adequate infrastructure oversight, so the burden falls to local counties and utilities.
A December EPA Office of Inspector General audit of the program found the deployment of the electric school buses has been significantly delayed by the lack of existing charging infrastructure, the ability of local power grids to support it and the amount of time it takes localities to address those issues and order parts.
Charging infrastructure refers to everything bringing power to the site to figuring out how to actually charge the electric buses.
“The Agency may be unable to effectively manage and achieve the program mission unless local utility companies can meet increasing power supply demands for electric school buses,” the EPA audit said. “Utility installation delays must be addressed for taxpayers to reap timely health and environmental benefits of the $5 billion invested in this program…”
The audit also found that the EPA provided utility resources during the 2022 inaugural funding round of the program, but did not require early engagement between recipients and local utilities.
The utility coordination failures slowed down the already lengthy process of building the charging infrastructure.
In ideal scenarios, the design is a collaboration between the local utility and the bus company that shields school districts from paying out-of-pocket costs for the program. That is the case for Pittsburgh Public Schools in this round of funding.
Following the 2022 rebate funding, the EPA required applicants to submit a Utility Partnership Agreement to verify the school district's local utility was aware of and prepared for the potential need for charging infrastructure.
In Allegheny County, First Student has partnered with Duquesne Light to design and build the electric bus charging infrastructure. Duquesne Light has a program that allows the utility to front much of the infrastructure costs associated with electrification.
First Student received money for 16 electric school buses to serve Pittsburgh Public Schools in November 2022 during the first round of Clean School Bus program rebates. The infrastructure has been designed, but construction has yet to begin and the buses have not been ordered.
“We first design the infrastructure because that’s what takes the longest to build,” Mr. Matthews said. “Then once we know the construction schedule for the infrastructure, we decide how many buses to order. Ideally, you want the buses to arrive at the same time the charging infrastructure is finished.”
Mr. Matthews said the company hopes to have the 16 buses by the first day of the next school year, but that hinges on the construction timeline. The estimated 45 buses from the most recent funding round could take years to become operational.
Hannah Moyer, a transportation electrification project developer at Duquesne Light Company, said the process starts with site evaluations to determine if a new transformer is needed.
Transformers are electrical devices that bring power to charging sites and enable all of the other charging infrastructure - chargers, electric panels, conduit and wiring, etc. - to be built. Without an adequate transformer, the infrastructure process cannot continue.
“Right now, transformers do have very lengthy timelines with different supply chain issues,” Ms. Moyer said. “So it could be, you know, a year before someone's getting their transformer in.”
Following the installation of the transformers, sites determine what kind of chargers they need, and how many. Then, they make plans to design the conduit and wiring, which carries power to the charging stations, and assess the capabilities of the site's electric panels.
All of that design and installation, and the long-order times for transformers, means some projects can take months or even years to complete.
The best way to fast-track the process, according to Ms. Moyer, is for bus providers to consult local utilities as soon as they apply for the clean bus grants.
Mr. Matthews said First Student will follow the same infrastructure design they used for the 16 electric buses to prepare for the additional electric fleets, but the timeline for operation remains unclear.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.