Students, professors and experts warn that West Virginia University’s drastic intent to ax 28 academic programs and lay off 143 faculty members will have dire consequences for the university, state and higher education as a whole.

On Friday, the university’s board of governors approved the sweeping plan of cuts amid a $45 million budget deficit, despite pleas from students and faculty to reconsider. 

The decision leaves future WVU students without the ability to major in world languages, music performance: jazz and commercial music, or recreation, parks and tourism resources. It also robs the Appalachian state of its only mathematics doctorate program, only higher education administration programs, and only majors in Chinese and Russian. 

Administrators at Friday’s board meeting insisted that cuts are necessary and won’t impact WVU’s R1 status. Board of governors chair Taunja Willis Miller told a crowd of protesters that the goal of the cuts — and other debt-mitigation efforts — is to leave the flagship school “better than it is today.”

Advertise with us

But many students and professors believe that the opposite will happen.

“I think it’s really going to hurt West Virginia University’s reputation,” said WVU senior Garrett Cessna. “It's going to sever a lot of academic opportunities for West Virginians throughout the state, who, like myself, are first-generation, from low-income backgrounds, who wouldn't otherwise have the opportunities presented to them if it wasn't for WVU.”

Mr. Cessna, who studies biology and Spanish, double majored in Spanish because he hopes to eventually live and work in Latin America. He said he needed the Spanish major to bolster his language skills and qualify for scholarships to potentially work as an English teaching assistant in Uruguay.

Students show up to express their opinions at the BOG vote meeting Friday, Sept. 15, 2023, in Morgantown, W.Va. (Ron Rittenhouse / The Dominion-Post via AP)

Though Mr. Cessna will be able to complete his Spanish major, he wonders how a lack of foreign language majors could impact future WVU students. 

“I think long-term, the number of students from West Virginia University applying to… critical-need language scholarships is going to be really low because of gutting our foreign languages department,” he said. “I don’t think we’re going to be taken seriously in regard to languages ever again.”

Advertise with us

And as a STEM major, Mr. Cessna is concerned that cuts could overcrowd STEM classrooms and weaken student support. In addition to ending the school’s math doctorate and master’s degrees, the university will lay off a third of its faculty at the School of Mathematical and Data Sciences.

Matthew Kolb, a senior math major, echoed this concern. 

“It’s already the case that West Virginia has below-average math proficiency, and so does the country,” Mr. Kolb said. “Whenever we're sitting here with these larger math courses, it's going to be harder for students.”

Mr. Kolb co-founded the WVU students’ union in July, an organization that pushes for administrative transparency. The union currently has more than 400 members. He said the group plans to “keep fighting” the program cut decision until the spring. 

If cuts happen, Mr. Kolb worries that this could impact the university’s enrollment, which is already down: It dropped 16%, from 29,466 students to 24,741, between 2013 and 2022.

Advertise with us

“If students think that coming here is going to limit their opportunities, they’re not going to come here and it’s going to hurt enrollment,” he said. 

And that struggle could contribute to bigger problems afflicting West Virginia, said Lisa Di Bartolomeo, a Russian studies professor who is anticipating layoff after Friday’s decision. The state consistently ranks low for education, while the population is decreasing.

“West Virginia schools already have fewer qualified teachers. There's a huge teacher shortage in the state. There's already a brain drain for generations of kids — leaving the state, whether it's for school or for jobs — and they never come back,” she said. “And I think these decisions, these cuts are going to exacerbate those issues.

“It concerns me very much as a West Virginian, watching this generation see their dreams be postponed, be chopped, be forced out of state.”

Those impacts could seep outside of the Mountain State. Joy Connolly, president of the American Council of Learned Societies, said that WVU’s decision could be the canary in the coal mine for other colleges that, like WVU, face enrollment challenges, financial struggles and public distrust in higher education.

Advertise with us

She said it is deeply concerning “that a flagship school would say definitively, ‘We’re giving up on a broad education for our citizens.”

“What frightens and angers me, and people like me, most about this is that we see this as a door opening that other states may walk through,” she said. “[This decision] pulls the rug out from under the greatness that the American higher public higher education system has been, and still is, in most parts of the country.”

Clarification: WVU will cut the music performance: jazz and commercial music major, and will continue to offer several other music performance majors.