School vouchers became a hot issue for Pennsylvania lawmakers this week as the budget battle raged in Harrisburg.
Often a blue vs. red issue, school choice entered the forefront of Pennsylvania politics when Gov. Josh Shapiro recently broke party lines to voice his support for a $100 million voucher system that would provide tuition scholarships using taxpayer dollars for disadvantaged K-12 students to attend private schools.
Since then, however, Mr. Shapiro has backed down, citing an “unwillingness” to further delay an already tardy budget.
The state House sent him a $45.6 billion budget late Wednesday after he vowed to veto a line item in it that would provide the money for vouchers.
Here’s what to know about school choice and what a voucher system would have meant for Pennsylvanians.
What is school choice?
School choice refers to programs and policies that support families and students choosing their K-12 educational options, whether that be public school, private school, charter school, home school or special education.
School choice also generally refers to using taxpayer dollars to fund opportunities beyond traditional public schools, such as private and charter schools.
Pennsylvania currently has two programs promoting school choice: the Opportunity Scholarship Tax Credit and the Educational Improvement Tax Credit. Both give tax breaks to businesses that give private school scholarships to students.
How do school vouchers work?
For families that choose a route other than public school, voucher programs provide them with state-funded or school district-funded ways to lessen the cost of other K-12 options.
Fifteen states, including Pennsylvania neighbors Maryland and Ohio, plus Washington, D.C., offer some type of school voucher program.
What has Shapiro said about school choice?
During his gubernatorial campaign, Mr. Shapiro said he favored “adding choices for parents and educational opportunities for students and funding lifeline scholarships,” or school vouchers, according to web archives of his campaign website.
Mr. Shapiro later reiterated this view on Fox News in June, saying “one of the best ways we can guarantee success is making sure every child has a quality education.”
Mr. Shapiro later clarified that he would favor vouchers and school choice programs if they did not cut into funding for public schools.
Who supports school choice? Who opposes it?
The governor’s position separates him from many of his fellow Democrats, who often say vouchers would take money away from already struggling school districts.
Republicans typically support school choice, saying it expands options for students and parents.
When Mr. Shapiro voiced his support for school choice, many Republicans and conservative organizations applauded his position. Mr. Shapiro also received a June letter of support from a coalition of education leaders, organizations and celebrities, including two former U.S education secretaries and Philadelphia native and rapper Meek Mill.
“This is an overwhelming expression of support from a broad coalition on behalf of the 250,000 Pennsylvania students trapped in failing public schools,” part of the letter reads. “Lifeline Scholarships offer them hope and access to quality education.”
Mr. Shapiro received harsh criticism from teachers unions and public education advocates for his comments supporting school vouchers. The Pennsylvania State Education Association, American Federation of Teachers PA, Philadelphia Federation of Teachers and Education Voters of PA all opposed the voucher program. A June letter from numerous unions urged the governor to abandon his voucher support.
“It is clearly irresponsible to appropriate state funds for tuition vouchers that benefit private and religious schools when the commonwealth hasn’t met its most basic duty to students who attend our public schools — the same public schools that the Commonwealth Court has determined are unconstitutionally underfunded,” part of the unions’ letter reads.
Polling indicates the majority of Americans support school choice. According to data from RealClear Opinion Research, 68% of Democrats, 82% of Republicans and 67% of independents said they supported school choice policies in 2022.
What kind of voucher program did Shapiro support?
Mr. Shapiro supported the Lifeline Scholarship Program, which was eventually tweaked and got a new name: Pennsylvania Award for Student Success. Under both versions, disadvantaged students would have been eligible for state-funded scholarships to help pay tuition at private schools.
Total funding for the program would have been $100 million.
Students at public schools in the bottom 15% of test score achievement would benefit.
Eligible high schoolers would receive a $10,000 yearly scholarship, eligible elementary and middle school students would get $5,000 scholarships and eligible special needs students would receive $15,000 scholarships.
The program would be funded by the state treasury; money would not be redirected from school districts.
Which Pittsburgh-area students could have received funds?
Students at low-achieving schools could receive scholarships under the Lifeline program.
During the 2022-23 school year, 43 schools in Allegheny County were considered low-achieving. Over half of those were in the Pittsburgh Public School District.
Other Allegheny County districts with several low-achieving schools included McKeesport Area, Sto-Rox and Woodland Hills.
In surrounding counties, Beaver and Washington have five low-achieving schools each, Westmoreland has four, Fayette has three and Greene has two.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.