Four Riverview School Board candidates will appear only on the Democratic ballot during Tuesday’s primary election after their attempts to cross-file were challenged and ultimately barred from also being on the Republican ticket
Candidates Leanne Jacobs-Rohan, Roger Pogoda, and incumbents Jennifer K. Chaparro and Antonio Paris — four out of 10 candidates vying for five open school board seats — filed to be on both the Democratic and Republican ballots, a move that is typical in school board races. School board elections are one of the few races where candidates can cross-file, meaning they appear on both parties’ tickets.
But their attempts to be on the Republican ballot were challenged in the Allegheny County Court of Common Pleas, however, by Oakmont resident Kimberly Butler, a registered Republican.
In court filings Ms. Butler — who previously ran for Oakmont council but was not elected — suggested that the Republican nomination was circulated by the candidates, all of whom are registered Democrats, or by others who are also Democrats. The filings read that a “petition circulator must be registered to vote in the same political party as the petition signers.”
On March 23, Judge John McVay agreed with the claims. He said the Republican nomination petitions from all candidates do “not comply with the requirement that the petition signers must be registered to vote in the same political party as the circulator.”
Judge McVay prohibited the candidates from appearing on the Republican ballot.
Read More
“We all just kind of were like ‘We can’t believe this happened. OK, we’re going to have to work really hard knocking on doors and explaining this,’” Ms. Jacobs-Rohan told the Post-Gazette. “We didn’t want it to seem like there were all these Democrats listed because of all the cross-files.”
Out of 10 candidates running for Riverview School Board, Ms. Jacobs-Rohan, Mr. Pogoda, Ms. Chaparro, Mr. Paris and Erin Schuetz — who was permitted to cross-file — are endorsed by the Oakmont Democrats.
Candidates Colette Saxon-Kmetz, Nick Paradise, Isabelle McDade, Seth Wermager and Melissa Botta-Havran are running on the slate Friends of Riverview Education. Ms. McDade is the only candidate not cross-filed. Those candidates have been featured on the Oakmont Republican Committee Facebook page.
Emails sent to Friends of Riverview Education and to the Oakmont Republican Committee seeking comment were not returned.
Ms. Jacobs-Rohan said the Democrats did not challenge any of the other candidate’s petitions.
Robert Lindeman, president of the Riverview Education Association, said the district has a long history of candidates cross-filing. He noted that “to my knowledge we’ve never seen a mass challenge like apparently we saw this time around.”
“I’m kind of disappointed that it occurred,” Mr. Lindeman said. “I think that doesn’t meet the way we’ve done things here at Riverview in the past and it also sort of tries to sidestep the will of the voters a little bit.”
Ms. Jacobs-Rohan noted that “it’s our mistake” not having a registered Republican circulate the petitions “and we have to deal with it.”
Democratic candidates are now working to spread the word about the situation.
“We’re trying to get the word out that there really are only five [Democrats] and these are the five,” Ms. Jacobs-Rohan said. “Some people just vote party and they might just think they can pick five at random and they can’t.”







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.