A new ranking by U.S. News and World Report places Pennsylvania at the bottom of the barrel for higher education offerings.

The Keystone State’s high tuition and debt rates contributed to its low placement in the ranking, which was part of U.S. News’ Best States report. The annual report takes an in-depth look at life in each state and ranks states for factors such as economy, infrastructure, education, crime and healthcare based on objective metrics.

States’ higher education landscapes were analyzed for cost, debt, graduation rates and the share of state citizens who hold degrees. 

In addition to ranking last for overall higher education, Pennsylvania placed 48th for low debt, 47th for tuition and costs, and 27th for the share of state citizens who hold degrees. 

Advertise with us

Pennsylvania did rank 14th for its four-year college graduation rate, which measures the share of undergrads who complete their degrees within six years. That’s the sole higher education measure that Pennsylvania found itself in the top half of states.

Some neighboring states fared well in the ranking, while others received average or poor marks. In the overall ranking, Maryland ranked 15th, New York 17th, Delaware 22nd, New Jersey 29th, Ohio 37th and West Virginia 42nd.

Florida, Washington and California were named the best three states for higher education. 

Eboni Zamani-Gallaher, a higher education professor at the University of Pittsburgh, believes there is more nuance to Pennsylvania’s landscape than rankings show. Zamani-Gallaher said Pennsylvania has problems with college affordability and access, but she also said the state has a “rich landscape” of higher education options.

“It’s a fair assessment to ding our state when we think about how much our students are encumbered [with debt],” Zamani-Gallaher said. “But we have a lot of great institutions of higher education in Pennsylvania, a lot of higher ranked ones.”

Advertise with us

The U.S. News ranking comes as Pennsylvania’s higher education landscape seems to reach a tipping point. 

The state is consistently considered one of the least affordable places to attend college. In a state-by-state college affordability analysis conducted by the Institute for Research on Higher Education in 2016, Pennsylvania ranked second to last in the nation due to its high tuition costs.

In 2019-20, 64% of Pennsylvania college graduates had student loan debt, making Pennsylvania the state with the third highest share of graduates with debt, according to the Institute for College Access & Success. The average Pennsylvania college graduate had nearly $40,000 in debt.

And Pennsylvania is seemingly bloated with schools. A 2022 Chronicle of Higher Education analysis found that, compared to its neighbors, Pennsylvania has a larger number of colleges relative to its student-age population.

Citing concerns over affordability, competition and access, Pennsylvania Gov. Josh Shapiro said during his state budget address in March that Pennsylvania’s system “isn’t working.” Mr. Shapiro has tasked Acting Education Secretary Khalid Mumin with convening a task force to develop a “reform plan” that will be solidified next year. That task force will seemingly comprise leaders of the state’s colleges and universities, and will not include citizens or independent higher education experts.

Advertise with us

In U.S. News’ general education ranking, Pennsylvania placed 36th. It ranked 10th for healthcare, 29th for crime and corrections, 38th for economy and 46th for infrastructure.

Pennsylvania was considered the 40th best state to live in overall. Utah, Washington and Idaho topped the overall ranking.

Maddie Aiken: maiken@post-gazette.com