Republican lawmakers have indicated they will not appeal a landmark ruling that found Pennsylvania’s school funding system unconstitutional, Gov. Josh Shapiro said Tuesday. 

During a tour of Pittsburgh Colfax K-8 in Squirrel Hill, Mr. Shapiro said “all indications are that none of the parties will appeal” Commonwealth Court Judge Renee Cohn Jubelirer’s February ruling. The decision deems Pennsylvania’s education funding system, which relies heavily on property taxes, unconstitutional and inequitable. 

“I’ve spoken to all of the leaders – Republican, Democrat – and said to them, ‘Look, by not appealing you acknowledge that we now have a responsibility to get around the table for our children and begin to meet,’” Mr. Shapiro said. “I expect that process to play out over the course of roughly the next year or so.”

Mr. Shapiro did acknowledge there is still time for Republicans – who defended the state during the monthslong trial – to appeal the almost 800-page decision, handed down Feb. 7.

Advertise with us

Senate President Kim Ward and Rep. Bryan Cutler – House Republican leader – did file a motion Feb. 17 stating there were errors in the ruling. Judge Jubelirer set a briefing and argument schedule that runs through May 22.

“We are currently not focused on an appeal; however post-trial motions have been briefed and filed,” Jason Gottesman, Mr. Cutler’s spokesman, said in an email to the Post-Gazette. “No final decision can be made on an appeal until we see the results of those motions.”

Erica Clayton Wright, Ms. Ward’s spokeswoman, added, “The Senate is focused on finishing out the trial process, however it is our preference for the legislature to begin working together toward a 21st century education system that helps every child.”

If the ruling is not appealed, Mr. Shapiro along with state legislators and education advocates will have to work together to create a funding system that changes the way public schools receive money. 

As the system currently stands, Mr. Jubelirer found, students in lower-income districts are “deprived of the same opportunities and resources” as students in wealthier districts. Those inequities have led to wide achievement gaps on state assessments between students in weather and poor districts.

Advertise with us

She also found that the state’s Education Clause was violated “because of a failure to provide all students with access to a comprehensive, effective, and contemporary system of public education” that will allow them to succeed. 

Mr. Shapiro said lawmakers now have the chance over the next two budget sessions to increase education dollars. 

This month, Mr. Shapiro proposed an additional $671.4 million in basic and special education funding, a move he called a “down-payment” to districts. 

But the proposal quickly received pushback from education advocates who said the increase only accounts for inflation. They also questioned why the budget does not include any additional Level Up dollars, a program created in 2021 to boost the amount of state money going to Pennsylvania’s 100 poorest districts.

Mr. Shapiro on Tuesday suggested that it will take the 2023-24 and the 2024-25 budgets “to get both the dollars right and the formula right.

“It took us a long time to get to this system that’s unconstitutional,” Mr. Shapiro said. “It’s going to take a little bit of time in order to come up with a formula and a system that works, that can gain bipartisan support.”