A landmark ruling issued earlier this month was applauded by advocates for the billions of additional dollars it could funnel to Pennsylvania school districts, but if the case follows similar paths as others that have played out across the nation, it could be years before any relief is felt.

Pennsylvania’s school funding lawsuit, first filed in 2014, received a major win Feb. 7 when Commonwealth Court Judge Renee Cohn Jubelirer ruled that the way public schools are funded in the state is unconstitutional. Ms. Jubelirer didn’t offer a solution in her decision and the ruling is expected to be appealed.

While only in the beginning stages, Pennsylvania’s suit is similar to one that played out in Ohio in the 1990s, at least at the onset.

DeRolph v. State of Ohio was filed by the Ohio Coalition for Equity & Adequacy of School Funding on behalf of the Northern Local School District in 1991 challenging the constitutionality of the state’s K-12 public school funding system.

Advertise with us

Following a trial in which 70 witnesses and over 500 exhibits were presented, the court in 1994 declared Ohio’s system unconstitutional. Defendants appealed and in 1996 the Ohio Supreme Court upheld the decision, ordering lawmakers to change how public schools are funded.

But over the next six years the case would continually be sent back to court in an attempt by plaintiffs to pressure lawmakers into paying more money to the school system that today has 610 school districts, teaching almost 1.5 million students.

In 2003, the makeup of the Ohio Supreme Court changed due to judicial elections and despite another ruling that the system was unconstitutional, the court released jurisdiction of the case, essentially ending any further action. Legislators have attempted to change the financing formula since, but several experts today believe districts are still underfunded.

While the Ohio and Pennsylvania funding cases appear to be similar so far, David Sciarra, executive director of the New Jersey-based Education Law Center, believes Pennsylvania will likely not follow the same path.

“I see what happened in Ohio as an extreme outlier, unprecedented anywhere in the country,” Mr. Sciarra said. “I wouldn’t suspect that that’s going to happen in Pennsylvania.”

Advertise with us

He did suggest, however, that Ohio is a “cautionary tale.”

“School funding is still unconstitutional in Ohio after all these years,” Mr. Sciarra said. “But the legislature hasn’t done anything about it to really fix it and the court has said we’re not going to get involved anymore. So in other words they closed the courthouse door.”

In Pennsylvania, it is too early to know what path the case could take, Mr. Sciarra said.

Questions remain about whether defendants will file an appeal. It is also not known how much money Gov. Josh Shapiro will allocate to education in his first state budget proposal, which he will present March 7, or if the governor and legislatures will work together to comply with the court ruling.

“At this point we would expect that the legislature and the governor would comply with the court decision if it’s upheld and sit down and work together and come up with a new funding formula or a new approach to funding or additional investments,” Mr. Sciarra said. “Whatever’s needed in order to comply with what the trial court has now found.”

Advertise with us

DeRolph

The DeRolph case, similar to Pennsylvania, was based on the state’s constitution guaranteeing that legislators will “secure a thorough and efficient system of common schools throughout the state,” William Phillis, head of the Ohio Coalition for Equity & Adequacy of School Funding who worked on the case, said in a recent interview.

The suit, however, alleged that the school system at the time “was not thorough and efficient” and “that the school funding system wasn’t working,” Mr. Phillis said.

The Ohio Supreme Court in 1996 agreed with those allegations, suggesting the operation of the funding formula was wrong and that there was insufficient state funding for school buildings. He also ordered the state to change its overemphasis on local property taxes. At the time, schools did receive state funding, but the system relied heavily on property taxes, creating inadequate and inefficient financing for lower wealth districts.

“Continued reliance on property taxes for the majority of school finances will simply preserve the status quo of inadequacy and deny the students in property-poor school districts a thorough and efficient education,” the court ruling reads.

Advertise with us

Data from The Annie E. Casey Foundation suggests that during the 2020-21 school year, 48% of students were considered economically disadvantaged. In 2019, 18% of students were living in poverty.

While increases in school funding were made over the next few years, the court in 2000 found the financial system substantially unchanged. Other attempts were made over the next two years, but the Ohio Supreme Court in 2002 again ruled the system unconstitutional and directed the General Assembly to find a solution. At that point, however, the court released jurisdiction.

“What the Ohio Supreme Court did is frankly rather shocking,” Mr. Sciarra said. “I’ve never seen it before, I’ve never seen it since. Essentially what you have is something courts just don’t do.”

While the ruling did not lead to a solution for Ohio schools, it did cause the state to adopt a school-facilities funding program, which has funneled $20 billion to districts to bring school buildings up to state standards, Mr. Phillis said.

Lawmakers in 2021 did enact a new funding formula after years of back and forth that calls for a $2 billion per year increase in state education expenditures, or a 20% bump. It also includes a new base cost model that determines the cost of educating an average student.

Advertise with us

But a bill introduced this year in the Senate could expand the state’s EdChoice scholarship program, which provides students funds to attend alternative private schools. Mr. Phillis suggested charter schools and voucher programs drained “all the additional dollars that we’ve seen through litigation.”

“Almost 26 years after the first Supreme Court decision the state still hasn’t fixed the operating formula,” Mr. Phillis said.

Ongoing pressure

Still, ongoing judicial pressure while the case was active did lead to some increases in school funding “that moved the system to becoming more progressive,”  Bruce Baker, an education professor at the University of Miami whose expertise focuses on school financing systems, said.

After the case ended, however, funding began to slightly decrease, something seen in states across the country. Additionally, many states that had fair funding lawsuits took a hit during the Great Recession in 2008, and education funding in many did not recover to what it previously was, Mr. Baker said.

Advertise with us

He added, however, that Ohio’s education funding was “at a pretty good point before they slid back.” Ohio has not reached levels seen in Pennsylvania, which for years has been recognized as having one of the starkest funding gaps between rich and poor school districts.

In Pennsylvania, Mr. Baker said, “it’s systematically, constantly the case that high poverty districts have less funding per pupil.”

Plaintiffs in Pennsylvania’s suit allege that schools are being underfunded by $4.6 billion, an estimate they say does not account for gaps in spending on special education and school buildings.

As Pennsylvania’s system currently stands, about 38% of public education costs are covered by the state. Local school districts must make up the difference through property taxes.

In her almost 800-page ruling, Ms. Jubelirer found that wide achievement gaps on state assessments exist between students in wealthier and poorer districts. Those gaps widen for Black, Hispanic, English-language learners and economically-disadvantaged students.

Advertise with us

She also found that the state’s Education Clause was violated “because of a failure to provide all students with access to a comprehensive, effective, and contemporary system of public education” that will allow them to succeed.

When looking at the Ohio case, Mr. Sciarra said, the lesson “is that you’ve got to keep up the political pressure on the legislature to respond to the court decision. And that’s political. That’s going to take place in the state capital among legislatures and the governor.”

Maura McInerney – legal director at the Pennsylvania-based Education Law Center, one of the organizations that represented districts and parents that brought the Pennsylvania lawsuit – said the Pennsylvania court issued a strong, detailed decision that was “based on overwhelming evidence of glaring deficiencies in low wealth school districts and gross inequities in resources in our high wealth and low wealth schools.”

It provides a roadmap on how to proceed, suggesting the court will continue to exercise judicial oversight.

The Ohio case, Ms. McInerney said, provides an example of what happens when the state does not remedy underlying inequities.

“We’re optimistic that we can have a strong down payment toward equitable school funding,” Ms. McInerney said, “and that a plan can be developed to move us forward.”