The University of Pittsburgh will stop participating in U.S. News & World Report’s law school rankings, following the lead of several other law schools across the country that have withdrawn amid criticism of the methodology.
In a statement, interim dean and law professor Haider Ala Hamoudi said some parts of the rankings are “inconsistent with Pitt Law’s mission and values, including our longstanding commitment to diversity, equity, inclusion, and belonging.”
“The U.S. News ranking system is systematically flawed and harmful to both legal education and the legal profession,” Mr. Hamoudi said in his statement given to the Post-Gazette on Saturday.
“Among other things, the rankings overvalue the amount spent on legal education without regard to how those resources are used, and they place a heavy emphasis on admissions criteria, including standardized tests, in a manner that is not welcoming to students from disadvantaged communities who have been systematically and historically marginalized in our legal system,” he added in his statement.
In recent months, top law schools such as Yale, Harvard, Stanford and Columbia have announced they would no longer submit data to U.S. News for its ranking because of concerns about ethics, equity and mission. The schools have claimed that the ranking formula favors those that recruit wealthy students.
Earlier this month, Penn State also announced it was withdrawing its two law schools, Penn State Dickinson Law and Penn State Law in University Park, from the law school rankings.
Read More
“For years, law school deans and faculty have been expressing concerns about the deeply flawed yet highly influential ranking of law schools published annually by U.S. News and World Report,” Justin Schwartz, Penn State’s interim executive vice president and provost, said.
Other Pennsylvania law schools that have withdrawn include the University of Pennsylvania’s Carey Law School.
In the statement, Pitt Law said it will share additional employment data publicly on its website as it is collected.
In response to all the schools withdrawing, U.S News & World Report announced last month it would change how it ranks law schools.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.